FRINK Linked Data Fragments server

Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2024885003> ?p ?o ?g. }

• W2024885003 endingPage "174" @default.
• W2024885003 startingPage "172" @default.
• W2024885003 abstract "Reviewed by: “Assimilating the Primitive”: Parallel Dialogue on Racial Miscegenation in Revolutionary Mexico Rick López “Assimilating the Primitive”: Parallel Dialogue on Racial Miscegenation in Revolutionary Mexico. By Kelly R. Swarthout. New York: Peter Lang Publishing, 2004. Pp. ix, 179. Tables. Notes. Bibliography. Index. $61.95 cloth. After the Mexican Revolution of 1910, Mexican intellectuals in search of cultural sovereignty embraced the ideal of racial and cultural mixture, or mestizaje. Swarthout focuses on anthropologist Manuel Gamio, educator José Vasconcelos, and the British novelist D. H. Lawrence to examine contrasting ways that intellectuals engaged the primitive in Mexico. She argues that while Europeans viewed the distant Other through the anti-modern lens of primitivism, postrevolutionary Mexican intellectuals developed their own distinctive discourses of the primitive. This was because, in contrast to their European counterparts who were confident of [End Page 172] their own position at the center of modernity, Mexicans had still to figure out how to modernize their country. More importantly, while for Europeans the primitive was a distant Other, for Mexicans the primitive comprised the majority of their domestic population. In Mexicans' drive for modernity, they debated how best to assimilate this indigenous Other into the nation. In his search for a solution to Mexico's problems, Gamio developed a social-scientific indigenista discourse rooted in social practice, but which ultimately proved degrading to natives. Vasconcelos, for his part, exalted the mestizo ideal through a celebration of aesthetic and metaphysical racial mixture, while insisting that only by embracing Hispanic culture and the Greek classics could Mexicans elevate themselves toward modernity and spiritual transcendence. According to Swarthout, both authors engaged the indigenous peasantry as primitive but because of their commitment to modernization, each also rejected primitivism and all its anti-modern baggage. Swarthout contrasts this to D. H. Lawrence, who failed to understand Mexico, and instead imposed a European primitivist reading that focused on the Mexican Indian as a dark, menacing, primeval savage, the irreconcilable antithesis of modern civilization. The book is comprised of three parallel essays. Though lack of concrete examples in the first of these can be frustrating, the essay creatively elucidates some of the transnational intellectual strands from which post-revolutionary Mexican intellectuals drew inspiration. The essay focuses particularly on vitalism, scientization, cultural relativism, and primitivism. The second chapter offers a summary of four hundred years of Mexicans' debates over their identity as a colony, a people, and a nation. At the outset, Swarthout promises to show that twentieth-century Mexicans possessed their own homegrown idea of the primitive rooted in colonial history and nineteenth-century Creole nationalism. Her argument, though, loses focus as she navigates through four centuries of Mexican thought. Swarthout's third essay examines the writings of Gamio, Vasconcelos, and Lawrence. Though the chapter is fragmented, it does provide an insightful elaboration upon Claude Fell's interpretation of Vasconcelos. Readers might find the first chapter of the book to be the most useful thanks to its attention to Mexico's complex relationship to primitivism and Mexicans' eclectic appropriation of German and French vitalism. The implications of Chapters 1 and 2 together might be that postrevolutionary nationalists drew upon transnational discourses of vitalism, scientization, cultural relativism, and primitivism, which they creatively melded with home-grown, nationalist and anti-indigenous interpretations of the primitive. This seems to be where the author is pointing, but the book never states so outright, nor does it follow up on the implications of such an argument. As a result, Swarthout offers fresh insights about the tributaries to Mexicans' twentieth-century intellectual thought, but neglects to explore how these creative insights might revise our understanding of the meaning, motives, implications, or implementation of postrevolutionary mestizaje. An introduction or a conclusion [End Page 173] might have helped frame the author's arguments, as would an engagement with some of the recent contributions to these issues by the likes of Helen Delpar, Mary Kay Vaughan, Karen Cordero Reiman, Agustín Basave Benitez, and others. Despite these problems, specialists in Mexican thought and intellectual history will find Swarthout's discussion of Mexicans' sustained, but ambivalent relationship with primitivism to be insightful and engaging. Rick López Amherst College Amherst, Massachusetts Copyright © 2006 Academy of..." @default.
• W2024885003 created "2016-06-24" @default.
• W2024885003 creator A5002435852 @default.
• W2024885003 date "2006-01-01" @default.
• W2024885003 modified "2023-09-23" @default.
• W2024885003 title ""Assimilating the Primitive": Parallel Dialogue on Racial Miscegenation in Revolutionary Mexico (review)" @default.
• W2024885003 doi "https://doi.org/10.1353/tam.2006.0116" @default.
• W2024885003 hasPublicationYear "2006" @default.
• W2024885003 type Work @default.
• W2024885003 sameAs 2024885003 @default.
• W2024885003 citedByCount "0" @default.
• W2024885003 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
• W2024885003 hasAuthorship W2024885003A5002435852 @default.
• W2024885003 hasConcept C107993555 @default.
• W2024885003 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
• W2024885003 hasConcept C140610115 @default.
• W2024885003 hasConcept C144024400 @default.
• W2024885003 hasConcept C149923435 @default.
• W2024885003 hasConcept C17744445 @default.
• W2024885003 hasConcept C182744844 @default.
• W2024885003 hasConcept C186229450 @default.
• W2024885003 hasConcept C18903297 @default.
• W2024885003 hasConcept C19165224 @default.
• W2024885003 hasConcept C199539241 @default.
• W2024885003 hasConcept C27206212 @default.
• W2024885003 hasConcept C2776639384 @default.
• W2024885003 hasConcept C2778682666 @default.
• W2024885003 hasConcept C2908647359 @default.
• W2024885003 hasConcept C52119013 @default.
• W2024885003 hasConcept C55958113 @default.
• W2024885003 hasConcept C86803240 @default.
• W2024885003 hasConcept C94625758 @default.
• W2024885003 hasConcept C95457728 @default.
• W2024885003 hasConceptScore W2024885003C107993555 @default.
• W2024885003 hasConceptScore W2024885003C138885662 @default.
• W2024885003 hasConceptScore W2024885003C140610115 @default.
• W2024885003 hasConceptScore W2024885003C144024400 @default.
• W2024885003 hasConceptScore W2024885003C149923435 @default.
• W2024885003 hasConceptScore W2024885003C17744445 @default.
• W2024885003 hasConceptScore W2024885003C182744844 @default.
• W2024885003 hasConceptScore W2024885003C186229450 @default.
• W2024885003 hasConceptScore W2024885003C18903297 @default.
• W2024885003 hasConceptScore W2024885003C19165224 @default.
• W2024885003 hasConceptScore W2024885003C199539241 @default.
• W2024885003 hasConceptScore W2024885003C27206212 @default.
• W2024885003 hasConceptScore W2024885003C2776639384 @default.
• W2024885003 hasConceptScore W2024885003C2778682666 @default.
• W2024885003 hasConceptScore W2024885003C2908647359 @default.
• W2024885003 hasConceptScore W2024885003C52119013 @default.
• W2024885003 hasConceptScore W2024885003C55958113 @default.
• W2024885003 hasConceptScore W2024885003C86803240 @default.
• W2024885003 hasConceptScore W2024885003C94625758 @default.
• W2024885003 hasConceptScore W2024885003C95457728 @default.
• W2024885003 hasIssue "1" @default.
• W2024885003 hasLocation W20248850031 @default.
• W2024885003 hasOpenAccess W2024885003 @default.
• W2024885003 hasPrimaryLocation W20248850031 @default.
• W2024885003 hasRelatedWork W1142834574 @default.
• W2024885003 hasRelatedWork W2062437164 @default.
• W2024885003 hasRelatedWork W2140008790 @default.
• W2024885003 hasRelatedWork W2368752264 @default.
• W2024885003 hasRelatedWork W2748952813 @default.
• W2024885003 hasRelatedWork W3014137617 @default.
• W2024885003 hasRelatedWork W3036396266 @default.
• W2024885003 hasRelatedWork W3102734941 @default.
• W2024885003 hasRelatedWork W3116118339 @default.
• W2024885003 hasRelatedWork W3180353138 @default.
• W2024885003 hasVolume "63" @default.
• W2024885003 isParatext "false" @default.
• W2024885003 isRetracted "false" @default.
• W2024885003 magId "2024885003" @default.
• W2024885003 workType "article" @default.