Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2024891207> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2024891207 endingPage "214" @default.
- W2024891207 startingPage "176" @default.
- W2024891207 abstract "Abstract In 2009 Pertab, James, and Bigler published a critique of two prior meta-analyses by Binder, Rohling, and Larrabee (1997) and Frencham, Fox, and Maybery (2005) that showed small effect size difference at least 3 months post-injury in individuals who had sustained a mild traumatic brain injury (mTBI). The Binder et al. and Frencham et al. meta-analyses have been widely cited as showing no lasting effect of mTBI. In their critique Pertab et al. (2009) point out many limitations of these two prior meta-analyses, demonstrating that depending on how inclusion/exclusion criteria were defined different meta-analytic findings occur, some supporting the persistence of neuropsychological impairments beyond 3 months. Rohling et al. (2011) have now critiqued Pertab et al. (2009). Herein we respond to the Rolling et al. (2011) critique reaffirming the original findings of Pertab et al. (2009), providing additional details concerning the flaws in prior meta-analytic mTBI studies and the effects on neuropsychological performance. Keywords: Mild traumatic brain injuryMeta-analysis limitationsNeuropsychological outcomes Acknowledgments Dr. Bigler provides forensic consultation related to traumatic brain injury. No other conflict of interest is present for any other author. Notes 1As of this writing, according to the Institute for Scientific Information (ISI; see Thomson Reuters, 2012) and Google Scholar (i.e., http://www/googlescholar.com retrieved May 7, 2012). 2mTBI classification is fraught with problems of nomenclature. For the purposes of this paper the terms mTBI and concussion will be used interchangeably. 3As with Rohling et al. (Citation2011), for the sake of consistency in this paper a negative effect size indicates better performance by the control group than the TBI group." @default.
- W2024891207 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2024891207 creator A5028514701 @default.
- W2024891207 creator A5050665731 @default.
- W2024891207 creator A5057138503 @default.
- W2024891207 creator A5064921523 @default.
- W2024891207 creator A5072670809 @default.
- W2024891207 creator A5077219114 @default.
- W2024891207 date "2013-01-29" @default.
- W2024891207 modified "2023-10-18" @default.
- W2024891207 title "Reaffirmed Limitations of Meta-Analytic Methods in the Study of Mild Traumatic Brain Injury: A Response to Rohling et al." @default.
- W2024891207 cites W1952082102 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W1963580910 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W1966291682 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W1966672249 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W1966741901 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W1967847233 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W1970334626 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W1972105383 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W1974355482 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W1975578591 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W1977440378 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W1985345440 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W1986008527 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W1988149423 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W1989253964 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W1990275952 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W1995712362 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W1998016450 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2001660569 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2003806363 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2004054763 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2007881045 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2008594392 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2009575516 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2013106345 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2013893967 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2014772387 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2015889969 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2021641089 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2021995866 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2029852601 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2032452232 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2038382506 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2038425717 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2043290329 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2044956386 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2049066313 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2053885070 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2059714521 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2061402690 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2062219436 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2063841819 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2064707507 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2065650645 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2065712139 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2066821479 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2067966687 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2068154238 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2068260202 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2068767931 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2070313008 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2074201269 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2074570744 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2075591451 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2077927847 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2078827077 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2081191399 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2081325915 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2081638200 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2082170040 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2084625947 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2085738321 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2086434149 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2087393332 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2088283978 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2089340265 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2090525704 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2091420898 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2091962617 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2092703451 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2095792933 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2096010550 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2101063409 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2101732604 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2103242862 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2104694495 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2106837589 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2111066106 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2111279030 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2111416401 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2117200377 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2117555987 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2118590621 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2118974951 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2119899792 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2124911240 @default.
- W2024891207 cites W2128152952 @default.