Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2028382023> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2028382023 endingPage "605" @default.
- W2028382023 startingPage "591" @default.
- W2028382023 abstract "To examine whether and how the classification of mental disorders can be based on research, we evaluate the relevance of psychiatric science to the major questions in classification. We conclude that most studies cannot inform the validity of diagnostic categories because they are constrained by the classification through a top-down diagnostic approach. Analyses of relationships between diagnostic categories suggest that most interdiagnostic boundaries in current classifications lack validity. Likewise, genetic studies show that the susceptibility to mental illness is at most partly disorder-specific. Neuroimaging research is uninformative due to unsystematic single-diagnosis studies, use of super-healthy controls, and publication bias. Treatment research suggests moderate specificity in several areas of psychopathology (e.g. lithium for bipolar disorder), but lack of specificity is the rule (e.g. the broad indications of serotonin-reuptake inhibitors). In summary, evidence from multiple lines of research converges to indicate that current classifications contain excessively large numbers of categories of limited validity. Dimensional classification will not solve the problem because the number of dimensions is as uncertain as the number of categories. Psychiatric research should discard the assumption that current classification is valid. Instead of diagnosis-specific investigations, studies of unselected groups assessed with bottom-up approaches are needed to advance psychiatry." @default.
- W2028382023 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2028382023 creator A5036308969 @default.
- W2028382023 creator A5052743082 @default.
- W2028382023 date "2012-12-01" @default.
- W2028382023 modified "2023-10-03" @default.
- W2028382023 title "Basing psychiatric classification on scientific foundation: Problems and prospects" @default.
- W2028382023 cites W1515756878 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W1582811168 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W1640346996 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W1723840021 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W1835209101 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W1942231215 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W1968614105 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W1968918144 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W1969348782 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W1971858313 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W1973753484 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W1973851830 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W1974467112 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W1977465442 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W1977489472 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W1977495631 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W1980045450 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W1987251510 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W1990579903 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W1991750812 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W1993588417 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W1994241243 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W1995730638 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2002342601 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2002640933 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2004762037 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2008771388 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2008981696 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2009311956 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2012453547 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2015779008 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2016281862 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2019068682 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2019465651 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2021366235 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2022170432 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2022382207 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2022463700 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2022847223 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2024040583 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2027778520 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2029009688 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2030553440 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2030761320 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2033562153 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2034315660 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2034528843 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2035175379 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2040259741 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2041198871 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2041527603 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2042891206 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2044922756 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2047150120 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2051275541 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2052998051 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2059581805 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2061195865 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2062879364 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2068730758 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2069228993 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2069482134 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2071810966 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2072443226 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2075431089 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2078151387 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2078488451 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2078701201 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2080951458 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2081722307 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2082460440 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2085137496 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2087148608 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2088303692 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2088842558 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2089821280 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2090446436 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2091682971 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2095068146 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2098597355 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2099017168 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2099788487 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2100280726 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2100694517 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2101646907 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2105282735 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2108044724 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2110374888 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2111472185 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2111845989 @default.
- W2028382023 cites W2112500063 @default.