Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2029709650> ?p ?o ?g. }
Showing items 1 to 81 of
81
with 100 items per page.
- W2029709650 endingPage "58" @default.
- W2029709650 startingPage "47" @default.
- W2029709650 abstract "One thing nearly all epistemologists agree upon is that Gettier cases are decisive counterexamples to the tripartite analysis of knowledge; whatever else is true of knowledge, it is not merely belief that is both justified and true. They now agree that knowledge is not justified true belief because this is consistent with there being too much luck present in the cases, and that knowledge excludes such luck. This is to endorse what has become known as the ‘anti-luck platitude’. But what if generations of philosophers have been mistaken about this, blinded at least partially by a deeply entrenched professional bias? There has been another, albeit minority, response to Gettier: to deny that the cases are counterexamples at all. Stephen Hetherington, a principal and vocal proponent of this view, advances what he calls the ‘Knowing Luckily Proposal’. If Hetherington is correct, this would call for a major re-evaluation and re-orientation of post-Gettier analytic epistemology, since much of it assumes the anti-luck platitude both in elucidating the concept of knowledge, and in the application of such accounts to central philosophical problems. It is therefore imperative that the Knowing Luckily Proposal be considered and evaluated in detail. In this paper I critically assess the Knowing Luckily Proposal. I argue that while it draws our attention to certain important features of knowledge, ultimately it fails, and the anti-luck platitude emerges unscathed. Whatever else is true of knowledge, therefore, it is non-lucky true belief. For a proposition to count as knowledge, we cannot arrive at its truth accidentally or for the wrong reason." @default.
- W2029709650 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2029709650 creator A5014139146 @default.
- W2029709650 date "2011-03-01" @default.
- W2029709650 modified "2023-09-30" @default.
- W2029709650 title "Combating Anti Anti-Luck Epistemology" @default.
- W2029709650 cites W1969439334 @default.
- W2029709650 cites W1980348262 @default.
- W2029709650 cites W2027999187 @default.
- W2029709650 cites W2040692170 @default.
- W2029709650 cites W2071295375 @default.
- W2029709650 cites W2078382089 @default.
- W2029709650 cites W2092707543 @default.
- W2029709650 cites W210475654 @default.
- W2029709650 cites W2235992134 @default.
- W2029709650 cites W227433925 @default.
- W2029709650 cites W2327682760 @default.
- W2029709650 cites W2478456423 @default.
- W2029709650 cites W2906723123 @default.
- W2029709650 cites W3132594096 @default.
- W2029709650 cites W3190562697 @default.
- W2029709650 cites W4205801708 @default.
- W2029709650 cites W4212874497 @default.
- W2029709650 cites W4247284182 @default.
- W2029709650 cites W4253842439 @default.
- W2029709650 cites W4254030878 @default.
- W2029709650 cites W4256473140 @default.
- W2029709650 cites W53708859 @default.
- W2029709650 doi "https://doi.org/10.1080/00048400903524375" @default.
- W2029709650 hasPublicationYear "2011" @default.
- W2029709650 type Work @default.
- W2029709650 sameAs 2029709650 @default.
- W2029709650 citedByCount "33" @default.
- W2029709650 countsByYear W20297096502012 @default.
- W2029709650 countsByYear W20297096502013 @default.
- W2029709650 countsByYear W20297096502014 @default.
- W2029709650 countsByYear W20297096502016 @default.
- W2029709650 countsByYear W20297096502017 @default.
- W2029709650 countsByYear W20297096502018 @default.
- W2029709650 countsByYear W20297096502020 @default.
- W2029709650 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2029709650 hasAuthorship W2029709650A5014139146 @default.
- W2029709650 hasBestOaLocation W20297096502 @default.
- W2029709650 hasConcept C111472728 @default.
- W2029709650 hasConcept C118615104 @default.
- W2029709650 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W2029709650 hasConcept C15744967 @default.
- W2029709650 hasConcept C162838799 @default.
- W2029709650 hasConcept C2777152325 @default.
- W2029709650 hasConcept C33923547 @default.
- W2029709650 hasConcept C61783943 @default.
- W2029709650 hasConceptScore W2029709650C111472728 @default.
- W2029709650 hasConceptScore W2029709650C118615104 @default.
- W2029709650 hasConceptScore W2029709650C138885662 @default.
- W2029709650 hasConceptScore W2029709650C15744967 @default.
- W2029709650 hasConceptScore W2029709650C162838799 @default.
- W2029709650 hasConceptScore W2029709650C2777152325 @default.
- W2029709650 hasConceptScore W2029709650C33923547 @default.
- W2029709650 hasConceptScore W2029709650C61783943 @default.
- W2029709650 hasIssue "1" @default.
- W2029709650 hasLocation W20297096501 @default.
- W2029709650 hasLocation W20297096502 @default.
- W2029709650 hasOpenAccess W2029709650 @default.
- W2029709650 hasPrimaryLocation W20297096501 @default.
- W2029709650 hasRelatedWork W1950158261 @default.
- W2029709650 hasRelatedWork W1987346758 @default.
- W2029709650 hasRelatedWork W2029709650 @default.
- W2029709650 hasRelatedWork W2139414617 @default.
- W2029709650 hasRelatedWork W2340759283 @default.
- W2029709650 hasRelatedWork W2394199736 @default.
- W2029709650 hasRelatedWork W3131907989 @default.
- W2029709650 hasRelatedWork W3136727552 @default.
- W2029709650 hasRelatedWork W3188474513 @default.
- W2029709650 hasRelatedWork W4382489350 @default.
- W2029709650 hasVolume "89" @default.
- W2029709650 isParatext "false" @default.
- W2029709650 isRetracted "false" @default.
- W2029709650 magId "2029709650" @default.
- W2029709650 workType "article" @default.