Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2029896775> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2029896775 endingPage "325" @default.
- W2029896775 startingPage "307" @default.
- W2029896775 abstract "Mistakes in evidential reasoning can have severe consequences. Especially, errors in the use of statistics have led to serious miscarriages of justice. Fact-finders and forensic experts make errors in reasoning and fail to communicate effectively. As tools to prevent mistakes, three kinds of methods are available. Argumentative methods analyse the arguments and counterarguments that are presented in court. Narrative methods consider the construction and comparison of scenarios of what may have happened. Probabilistic methods show the connections between the probability of hypothetical events and the evidence. Each of the kinds of methods has provided useful normative maxims for good evidential reasoning. Argumentative and narrative methods are especially helpful for the analysis of qualitative information, but do not come with a formal theory that is as well-established as probability theory. In probabilistic methods, the emphasis is on numeric information, so much so that a standard criticism is that these methods require more numbers than are available. This article offers an integrating perspective on evidential reasoning, combining the strengths of each of the kinds of methods: the adversarial setting of arguments pro and con, the globally coherent perspective provided by scenarios, and the gradual uncertainty of probabilities. In the integrating perspective, arguments and scenarios are interpreted in the quantitative setting of standard probability theory. In this way, the integrated perspective provides a normative framework that bridges the communicative gap between fact-finders and forensic experts. Both qualitative and quantitative information can be used safely, focusing on what is relevant." @default.
- W2029896775 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2029896775 creator A5060921040 @default.
- W2029896775 date "2014-08-27" @default.
- W2029896775 modified "2023-09-28" @default.
- W2029896775 title "To catch a thief with and without numbers: arguments, scenarios and probabilities in evidential reasoning" @default.
- W2029896775 cites W114083475 @default.
- W2029896775 cites W1506680948 @default.
- W2029896775 cites W1515210918 @default.
- W2029896775 cites W166257499 @default.
- W2029896775 cites W1755360231 @default.
- W2029896775 cites W1891641877 @default.
- W2029896775 cites W1964667662 @default.
- W2029896775 cites W1980423071 @default.
- W2029896775 cites W200124229 @default.
- W2029896775 cites W2006559750 @default.
- W2029896775 cites W2010366788 @default.
- W2029896775 cites W2011697417 @default.
- W2029896775 cites W2077913887 @default.
- W2029896775 cites W2078438690 @default.
- W2029896775 cites W2104126268 @default.
- W2029896775 cites W2113343982 @default.
- W2029896775 cites W2115089538 @default.
- W2029896775 cites W2116246756 @default.
- W2029896775 cites W2130742751 @default.
- W2029896775 cites W2150706644 @default.
- W2029896775 cites W2153909792 @default.
- W2029896775 cites W2156156961 @default.
- W2029896775 cites W2172126546 @default.
- W2029896775 cites W2317509341 @default.
- W2029896775 cites W2475432070 @default.
- W2029896775 cites W2498346826 @default.
- W2029896775 cites W2795543377 @default.
- W2029896775 cites W3121890212 @default.
- W2029896775 cites W3124115943 @default.
- W2029896775 cites W4240543108 @default.
- W2029896775 cites W4243806410 @default.
- W2029896775 cites W4256682192 @default.
- W2029896775 cites W4301137208 @default.
- W2029896775 cites W581684831 @default.
- W2029896775 cites W2060270487 @default.
- W2029896775 doi "https://doi.org/10.1093/lpr/mgu011" @default.
- W2029896775 hasPublicationYear "2014" @default.
- W2029896775 type Work @default.
- W2029896775 sameAs 2029896775 @default.
- W2029896775 citedByCount "25" @default.
- W2029896775 countsByYear W20298967752014 @default.
- W2029896775 countsByYear W20298967752015 @default.
- W2029896775 countsByYear W20298967752016 @default.
- W2029896775 countsByYear W20298967752017 @default.
- W2029896775 countsByYear W20298967752018 @default.
- W2029896775 countsByYear W20298967752019 @default.
- W2029896775 countsByYear W20298967752022 @default.
- W2029896775 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2029896775 hasAuthorship W2029896775A5060921040 @default.
- W2029896775 hasConcept C105795698 @default.
- W2029896775 hasConcept C107327155 @default.
- W2029896775 hasConcept C111472728 @default.
- W2029896775 hasConcept C12713177 @default.
- W2029896775 hasConcept C133425853 @default.
- W2029896775 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W2029896775 hasConcept C139621336 @default.
- W2029896775 hasConcept C154945302 @default.
- W2029896775 hasConcept C156201811 @default.
- W2029896775 hasConcept C162324750 @default.
- W2029896775 hasConcept C2781306805 @default.
- W2029896775 hasConcept C28901747 @default.
- W2029896775 hasConcept C33923547 @default.
- W2029896775 hasConcept C41008148 @default.
- W2029896775 hasConcept C44725695 @default.
- W2029896775 hasConcept C49937458 @default.
- W2029896775 hasConcept C539667460 @default.
- W2029896775 hasConcept C97944126 @default.
- W2029896775 hasConceptScore W2029896775C105795698 @default.
- W2029896775 hasConceptScore W2029896775C107327155 @default.
- W2029896775 hasConceptScore W2029896775C111472728 @default.
- W2029896775 hasConceptScore W2029896775C12713177 @default.
- W2029896775 hasConceptScore W2029896775C133425853 @default.
- W2029896775 hasConceptScore W2029896775C138885662 @default.
- W2029896775 hasConceptScore W2029896775C139621336 @default.
- W2029896775 hasConceptScore W2029896775C154945302 @default.
- W2029896775 hasConceptScore W2029896775C156201811 @default.
- W2029896775 hasConceptScore W2029896775C162324750 @default.
- W2029896775 hasConceptScore W2029896775C2781306805 @default.
- W2029896775 hasConceptScore W2029896775C28901747 @default.
- W2029896775 hasConceptScore W2029896775C33923547 @default.
- W2029896775 hasConceptScore W2029896775C41008148 @default.
- W2029896775 hasConceptScore W2029896775C44725695 @default.
- W2029896775 hasConceptScore W2029896775C49937458 @default.
- W2029896775 hasConceptScore W2029896775C539667460 @default.
- W2029896775 hasConceptScore W2029896775C97944126 @default.
- W2029896775 hasIssue "3-4" @default.
- W2029896775 hasLocation W20298967751 @default.
- W2029896775 hasOpenAccess W2029896775 @default.
- W2029896775 hasPrimaryLocation W20298967751 @default.
- W2029896775 hasRelatedWork W1035842226 @default.
- W2029896775 hasRelatedWork W1922700522 @default.
- W2029896775 hasRelatedWork W2044332110 @default.