Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2033429559> ?p ?o ?g. }
Showing items 1 to 72 of
72
with 100 items per page.
- W2033429559 endingPage "12" @default.
- W2033429559 startingPage "1" @default.
- W2033429559 abstract "Confessions of a British North Americanist: Borderlands Historiography and Early American History Helena M. Wall (bio) While preparing his presidential address to the American Historical Association in 1931, Herbert Bolton revealed his hopes for it to Guy Stanton Ford: “The most expansive idea which interests me is the presentation of American History as Western Hemisphere History, instead of Brazilian History, Canadian History, or United States History. It is inconceivable that we should not have histories of Europe as well as histories of Germany, France, England, etc. It is just as absurd to assume that the Western Hemisphere has developed in isolated chunks and yet we in the United States have proceeded on that assumption.” 1 Bolton’s complaint is especially ironic in view of the history of American history. Several of the early masters of American historical writing were attracted specifically to the non -English elements of America’s colonial past: Parkman on the French and their Indian allies and Prescott on the Spanish conquest of Mexico and Peru come immediately to mind; John Lothrop Motley’s work on the Dutch Republic grew out of his study of the Spanish empire; and the distinguished medievalist, Henry C. Lea, found his great subject in the Spanish church and the Inquisition that colored so much of Spanish colonial expansion. 2 But as more American historians focused on American history, they trained their attention on Anglo -American traditions—Protestant civilization, the rule of law, the rise of democratic institutions—all cast in a decidedly Whiggish key. George Bancroft perfected this approach, almost to the point of self-parody: “England Takes Possession of the United States,” he entitled his chapter on early English settlement. 3 The occasional crafty French Jesuit or arrogant Spaniard would appear in these histories but they did so as foils; they threw into sharper relief the superior virtue of the English and justified the eventual, inevitable triumph of British America. George Unwin wrote that in British historical writing the slave trade appeared only in connection with its abolition; so too we might say that France and Spain have appeared in American history primarily in connection with their defeat. As one of the most prominent practicing Borderlands historians, David Weber, has observed, [End Page 1] “The story of American history has been told from the perspective of the winners—the descendants of the English—and the lives and progeny of the losing Spanish side have not been woven into the fabric of American history. American history is usually seen as a process—as the story of the expansion of English America rather than the stories of the diverse cultures that comprise our national heritage.” 4 Weber counts himself as a “third-generation Boltonian,” and his synthesis of Borderlands scholarship, The Spanish Frontier in North America, is written with the fervor of an intellectual rescue mission. Bolton himself, with more than twenty books and over a hundred Ph.D. students to his credit, did as much as any one human being could to promote a common American history. In the past generation, with some of the regularity and all of the effectiveness of New Year’s resolutions, many other historians, including some who have not specialized in “borderlands” history, have echoed his sentiments. Review Essays, historiographical pieces, festschrift contributions, even obituaries, have called on American historians, especially those specializing in the colonial period, to cast their gaze beyond the borders of British North America. The objects of these exhortations, British North American specialists, haunting as they do the precincts of Cambridge, New Haven, and Williamsburg, have seemed largely unmoved—not hostile, not contentious, but not responsive either. As David Weber, once again, lamented in 1987, “specialists in the history of English colonial Virginia or colonial New York are understood to write American history; specialists in Spanish colonial Florida or California write regional history.” 5 Like the Proper Bostonian matron who, when asked how she planned to travel to the Great American West, replied “via Dedham,” British North Americanists have drawn—and drawn in—the boundaries of their world to their own satisfaction. Until now. The changing politics, population, and intellectual climate of the United States demand that we rethink our common past..." @default.
- W2033429559 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2033429559 creator A5080486462 @default.
- W2033429559 date "1997-01-01" @default.
- W2033429559 modified "2023-10-16" @default.
- W2033429559 title "Confessions of a British North Americanist: Borderlands Historiography and Early American History" @default.
- W2033429559 cites W1559516080 @default.
- W2033429559 cites W1579672335 @default.
- W2033429559 cites W1989422061 @default.
- W2033429559 cites W1989988248 @default.
- W2033429559 cites W2023558500 @default.
- W2033429559 cites W2051451044 @default.
- W2033429559 cites W2087976587 @default.
- W2033429559 cites W2098071307 @default.
- W2033429559 cites W2139670164 @default.
- W2033429559 cites W2145913641 @default.
- W2033429559 cites W2161356307 @default.
- W2033429559 cites W2286579391 @default.
- W2033429559 cites W2315749390 @default.
- W2033429559 cites W2318802702 @default.
- W2033429559 cites W2321621311 @default.
- W2033429559 cites W2325276787 @default.
- W2033429559 cites W2332207796 @default.
- W2033429559 cites W2332663863 @default.
- W2033429559 cites W2339242141 @default.
- W2033429559 cites W2417936389 @default.
- W2033429559 cites W2482795170 @default.
- W2033429559 cites W2484163785 @default.
- W2033429559 cites W2491004728 @default.
- W2033429559 cites W2789017837 @default.
- W2033429559 cites W2798198810 @default.
- W2033429559 doi "https://doi.org/10.1353/rah.1997.0028" @default.
- W2033429559 hasPublicationYear "1997" @default.
- W2033429559 type Work @default.
- W2033429559 sameAs 2033429559 @default.
- W2033429559 citedByCount "5" @default.
- W2033429559 countsByYear W20334295592013 @default.
- W2033429559 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2033429559 hasAuthorship W2033429559A5080486462 @default.
- W2033429559 hasConcept C166957645 @default.
- W2033429559 hasConcept C195244886 @default.
- W2033429559 hasConcept C29598333 @default.
- W2033429559 hasConcept C531593650 @default.
- W2033429559 hasConcept C74916050 @default.
- W2033429559 hasConcept C95457728 @default.
- W2033429559 hasConceptScore W2033429559C166957645 @default.
- W2033429559 hasConceptScore W2033429559C195244886 @default.
- W2033429559 hasConceptScore W2033429559C29598333 @default.
- W2033429559 hasConceptScore W2033429559C531593650 @default.
- W2033429559 hasConceptScore W2033429559C74916050 @default.
- W2033429559 hasConceptScore W2033429559C95457728 @default.
- W2033429559 hasIssue "1" @default.
- W2033429559 hasLocation W20334295591 @default.
- W2033429559 hasOpenAccess W2033429559 @default.
- W2033429559 hasPrimaryLocation W20334295591 @default.
- W2033429559 hasRelatedWork W2063553818 @default.
- W2033429559 hasRelatedWork W2132037243 @default.
- W2033429559 hasRelatedWork W2136050632 @default.
- W2033429559 hasRelatedWork W2200178744 @default.
- W2033429559 hasRelatedWork W2412641665 @default.
- W2033429559 hasRelatedWork W2498701363 @default.
- W2033429559 hasRelatedWork W2897398036 @default.
- W2033429559 hasRelatedWork W2983599067 @default.
- W2033429559 hasRelatedWork W4223910059 @default.
- W2033429559 hasRelatedWork W2540962092 @default.
- W2033429559 hasVolume "25" @default.
- W2033429559 isParatext "false" @default.
- W2033429559 isRetracted "false" @default.
- W2033429559 magId "2033429559" @default.
- W2033429559 workType "article" @default.