Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2038751004> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2038751004 endingPage "29" @default.
- W2038751004 startingPage "1" @default.
- W2038751004 abstract "ARTICLES An Analytic Dictionary of English Etymology Anatoly Liberman A he obvious purpose of an etymological dictionary is to disclose the origin and history of words. Early etymologists did not have to justify their efforts, because they addressed a readership that was grateful for any information. For centuries etymology meant guesswork , and every new dictionary contained numerous conjectures. Later it became customary to summarize other scholars' guesses, all of which were supposed to have equal value. Some authors had a mission, namely, to prove that all words of English (in my discussion, I will concentrate only on English) derive from Hebrew or Greek, or Gaelic, or Dutch, or a noun meaning earth. Several such dictionaries bear visible traces of insanity. A scholar might set out to cure the faults of his predecessors. Thus Charnock (1889) states that modern works on etymology omit many important words, dismiss many others as being of uncertain origin, offer idle, absurd, or specious etymologies, do not give proper explanations, ignore onomatopoeia, boycott all etymologies which are not consistent with euphonic change, ignore words shown to have been formed by growth [prefix, infix, suffix], decay [aphœresis, syncope, apocope], and inversion, and deal ineptly with words derived from proper names. In his book, Charnock (a reputable scholar) hoped to provide remedies for these multifarious ills. But the appearance of Skeat's fourth edition and of the OED made attempts like Charnock's uninteresting, even ludicrous. It is instructive to observe what motivation the later authors of English etymological dictionaries had. Weekley (1921), although an immensely erudite and original thinker, looked upon himself as primarily a popularizo- and wrote an etymological dictionary that was, in his opinion, more complete than Skeat's and more comprehensible Anatoly Liberman to the public. Shipley (1945, VII) informs us that some of the byproducts of his work are an insight into man's growth, a fresh color and vividness of language, and a quickened understanding of English words. The present dictionary, he says, opens such a vista. Those familiar with the product entertain no illusions about its byproducts and the vistas it opens. Partridge avoids the issue but claims to have treated all important words much more thoroughly than his predecessors. Whatever the phrase important words means, Partridge 's claim is groundless. Klein (1966) has been the target of such severe criticism that new invectives are hardly needed. He, not unlike Shipley, promised to give for the first time (!) the history of human civilization and culture condensed in the etymological data of words, and he was especially proud of having fully analyzed 750 words of Semitic origin. Apparently the public did not need an expensive two-volume dictionary for the sake of 750 words, most of which are marginal to the English vocabulary. The authors of the Oxford Dictionary of English Etymology (ODEE) do not discuss its goals. We are not told to what extent the etymologies of the OED have been touched up or rewritten, or what post-1928 sources have been used. But the latest etymological dictionary of English, the Barnhart (1988), contains a clear statement of purpose . I quote some passages from this statement and appraise them briefly. It is truly an American reference work not only because it pays particular attention to the American aspect of semantic development of English words but also because it bases much of its material on points of view developed by American scholars . This is the first dictionary of etymology to be produced by an editorial staff in collaboration with American scholars from various fields of language study, (vii) Doubts arise at once. The American aspect of semantic development had not been neglected by the OED, and it plays an outstanding role in the Second Supplement. Why is it so important that the staff collaborated with American scholars? Is there a distinct American school of English etymology, or did the dictionary receive some impulses from the latest trends of American linguistics? In our etymologies we have tried to forge a closer association between the elements of dating the first recorded appearance of a word and its semantic development and its development of form, (viii) An Analytic Dictionary of English Etymology The OED..." @default.
- W2038751004 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2038751004 creator A5064795020 @default.
- W2038751004 date "1994-01-01" @default.
- W2038751004 modified "2023-10-17" @default.
- W2038751004 title "An Analytic Dictionary of English Etymology" @default.
- W2038751004 cites W115589318 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W1493067049 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W1494375265 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W1498818492 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W1507482050 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W1507983103 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W1512599808 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W1517917655 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W1518008465 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W1518316993 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W1519077461 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W1531403720 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W1552942533 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W1553593367 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W1557358850 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W1566669414 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W1568007644 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W1581175478 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W1602659612 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W1603580062 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W1605720830 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W1606254687 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W1607477220 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W1637234639 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W1802088498 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W1987427240 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W2006970417 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W2028575454 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W2038573283 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W2070848105 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W2073380846 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W2087364513 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W2092836721 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W2139209344 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W2150581959 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W2268336023 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W2315447351 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W2317734409 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W2331726477 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W2343362001 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W2343899149 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W2796148442 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W2807958416 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W2882986594 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W3028187259 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W3108680842 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W373171743 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W434578389 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W580413075 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W592575414 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W597625503 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W605821980 @default.
- W2038751004 cites W653660496 @default.
- W2038751004 doi "https://doi.org/10.1353/dic.1994.0008" @default.
- W2038751004 hasPublicationYear "1994" @default.
- W2038751004 type Work @default.
- W2038751004 sameAs 2038751004 @default.
- W2038751004 citedByCount "7" @default.
- W2038751004 countsByYear W20387510042014 @default.
- W2038751004 countsByYear W20387510042015 @default.
- W2038751004 countsByYear W20387510042019 @default.
- W2038751004 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2038751004 hasAuthorship W2038751004A5064795020 @default.
- W2038751004 hasConcept C105795698 @default.
- W2038751004 hasConcept C111472728 @default.
- W2038751004 hasConcept C121934690 @default.
- W2038751004 hasConcept C124952713 @default.
- W2038751004 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W2038751004 hasConcept C142362112 @default.
- W2038751004 hasConcept C182767506 @default.
- W2038751004 hasConcept C193427332 @default.
- W2038751004 hasConcept C22432085 @default.
- W2038751004 hasConcept C2776291640 @default.
- W2038751004 hasConcept C2779804580 @default.
- W2038751004 hasConcept C2780876879 @default.
- W2038751004 hasConcept C33923547 @default.
- W2038751004 hasConcept C41895202 @default.
- W2038751004 hasConcept C74916050 @default.
- W2038751004 hasConcept C91304198 @default.
- W2038751004 hasConcept C95457728 @default.
- W2038751004 hasConceptScore W2038751004C105795698 @default.
- W2038751004 hasConceptScore W2038751004C111472728 @default.
- W2038751004 hasConceptScore W2038751004C121934690 @default.
- W2038751004 hasConceptScore W2038751004C124952713 @default.
- W2038751004 hasConceptScore W2038751004C138885662 @default.
- W2038751004 hasConceptScore W2038751004C142362112 @default.
- W2038751004 hasConceptScore W2038751004C182767506 @default.
- W2038751004 hasConceptScore W2038751004C193427332 @default.
- W2038751004 hasConceptScore W2038751004C22432085 @default.
- W2038751004 hasConceptScore W2038751004C2776291640 @default.
- W2038751004 hasConceptScore W2038751004C2779804580 @default.
- W2038751004 hasConceptScore W2038751004C2780876879 @default.