Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2046398840> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2046398840 endingPage "745" @default.
- W2046398840 startingPage "717" @default.
- W2046398840 abstract "A New Claim for the Family Renown:Alice James and the Picturesque Elizabeth Duquette While he was not surprised by the power, the temper, the humour and beauty and expressiveness of his sister's diary, Henry James admits to being somewhat astonished at the portrait it presented of Alice James herself. I have been immensely impressed, he writes in a letter to his older brother William, with the thing as a revelation of a moral and personal picture. It is heroic in its individuality, its independence. Even as he vehemently opposed its unedited publication, describing himself as intensely nervous and almost sick with terror about the possible publicity arising from its introduction to a general readership, Henry nonetheless held that the diary constitute[d] . . . a new claim for the family renown.1 Until recently, and despite her brother's fond assessment, critics have struggled to find an appropriate means of reading Alice James's text for the simple fact that, as Leon Edel observed in his 1964 preface to the Diary, Alice's claim for attention must be modest when judged next to the works of her illustrious brothers.2 As scholars have toiled to reconstruct the life and work of a woman who has been long understood as a mere appendage (xxx) to her brothers, the perception of Alice's status as modest, marginal, and minor has been reevaluated.3 Yet relying heavily on the psychoanalytic methodology undergirding some feminist approaches, critics too often judge Alice's journal as indicative of loss and failure. Unfulfilled, repressed, and ignored, Alice James becomes, in many readings, a martyr to patriarchal hegemony.4 While recognizing the potential value of arguments so inflected, however, I believe that focusing primarily on what Alice James was not allowed to accomplish not only perpetuates her status as an appendage, it seriously obscures what she actually does achieve in the text.5 How, then, are we to understand the parameters of Alice James's claim to renown, familial or otherwise? The problems foregrounded by Henry's remark are, in fact, paradigmatic of the critical issues surrounding the diary as an object of literary study in general. If the diary is a private document, an intimate account of an individual's feelings, actions, and thoughts, how can it function as a vehicle for fame? The [End Page 717] complexities inherent in such a question are further complicated by the emphasis scholars have placed on the role of the marketplace in assessing the work of nineteenth-century American women writers. [T]he demands of booksellers, reviewers, and buyers for whom the book is intended, Susan K. Harris has argued, impact the circumstances of a given book's production, and consequently provide important contextual information for the contemporary critic attempting to construct an appropriate evaluative paradigm to appreciate the text.6 And yet, this emphasis on conditions of production tends to reify the opposition between public and private that diaries, especially women's diaries, often eschew. As scholars have demonstrated, many diarists, even those who do not explicitly voice a hope of publishing their works, often address an imagined reader in their prose and revise their writing with an eye to coherence of both style and content.7 By focusing too exclusively, in other words, on one definition of public, predicated on commercial consumption, an impasse has been created which relegates the diary to an equally narrow definition of private.8 This is a concern, in fact, that Alice James thematizes in her diary, where her most violent remarks are reserved for journals that are mere receptacle[s] for feeble ejaculations (37). While she maintains she is glad to have read the third volume of George Eliot's Letters and Journals, nothing about her evaluation indicates she found the work either engaging or profitable: [W]hat a monument of ponderous dreariness is the book! . . . Not one burst of joy, not one ray of humour, not one living breath in one of her letters or journals. . . . Whether it is that her dank, moaning features haunt and pursue one thro' the book, or not, but she makes upon me the impression, morally and physically, of mildew, of some morbid growth—a fungus..." @default.
- W2046398840 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2046398840 creator A5052519549 @default.
- W2046398840 date "2005-01-01" @default.
- W2046398840 modified "2023-09-25" @default.
- W2046398840 title "A New Claim for the Family Renown: Alice James and the Picturesque" @default.
- W2046398840 cites W136603631 @default.
- W2046398840 cites W1483006906 @default.
- W2046398840 cites W1588445472 @default.
- W2046398840 cites W1965626403 @default.
- W2046398840 cites W1973129809 @default.
- W2046398840 cites W1974510850 @default.
- W2046398840 cites W1985243072 @default.
- W2046398840 cites W1999148176 @default.
- W2046398840 cites W2025127823 @default.
- W2046398840 cites W2035501798 @default.
- W2046398840 cites W2039187775 @default.
- W2046398840 cites W2040016671 @default.
- W2046398840 cites W2053721722 @default.
- W2046398840 cites W2080247256 @default.
- W2046398840 cites W2084956820 @default.
- W2046398840 cites W2087265434 @default.
- W2046398840 cites W2087459633 @default.
- W2046398840 cites W2093217722 @default.
- W2046398840 cites W2131724083 @default.
- W2046398840 cites W2169682093 @default.
- W2046398840 cites W2226655732 @default.
- W2046398840 cites W2319614242 @default.
- W2046398840 cites W2328467081 @default.
- W2046398840 cites W2329659050 @default.
- W2046398840 cites W2504840844 @default.
- W2046398840 cites W2751379301 @default.
- W2046398840 cites W2781652490 @default.
- W2046398840 cites W2795769085 @default.
- W2046398840 cites W565317836 @default.
- W2046398840 cites W569161237 @default.
- W2046398840 cites W581223528 @default.
- W2046398840 cites W588779073 @default.
- W2046398840 cites W599519958 @default.
- W2046398840 cites W609625982 @default.
- W2046398840 cites W612669211 @default.
- W2046398840 cites W613836517 @default.
- W2046398840 cites W615875764 @default.
- W2046398840 cites W657485444 @default.
- W2046398840 doi "https://doi.org/10.1353/elh.2005.0024" @default.
- W2046398840 hasPublicationYear "2005" @default.
- W2046398840 type Work @default.
- W2046398840 sameAs 2046398840 @default.
- W2046398840 citedByCount "4" @default.
- W2046398840 countsByYear W20463988402015 @default.
- W2046398840 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2046398840 hasAuthorship W2046398840A5052519549 @default.
- W2046398840 hasConcept C107038049 @default.
- W2046398840 hasConcept C11171543 @default.
- W2046398840 hasConcept C124952713 @default.
- W2046398840 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W2046398840 hasConcept C142362112 @default.
- W2046398840 hasConcept C144024400 @default.
- W2046398840 hasConcept C15744967 @default.
- W2046398840 hasConcept C162462552 @default.
- W2046398840 hasConcept C19165224 @default.
- W2046398840 hasConcept C2777106239 @default.
- W2046398840 hasConcept C2778222013 @default.
- W2046398840 hasConcept C2780430339 @default.
- W2046398840 hasConcept C2780620123 @default.
- W2046398840 hasConcept C52119013 @default.
- W2046398840 hasConcept C95457728 @default.
- W2046398840 hasConceptScore W2046398840C107038049 @default.
- W2046398840 hasConceptScore W2046398840C11171543 @default.
- W2046398840 hasConceptScore W2046398840C124952713 @default.
- W2046398840 hasConceptScore W2046398840C138885662 @default.
- W2046398840 hasConceptScore W2046398840C142362112 @default.
- W2046398840 hasConceptScore W2046398840C144024400 @default.
- W2046398840 hasConceptScore W2046398840C15744967 @default.
- W2046398840 hasConceptScore W2046398840C162462552 @default.
- W2046398840 hasConceptScore W2046398840C19165224 @default.
- W2046398840 hasConceptScore W2046398840C2777106239 @default.
- W2046398840 hasConceptScore W2046398840C2778222013 @default.
- W2046398840 hasConceptScore W2046398840C2780430339 @default.
- W2046398840 hasConceptScore W2046398840C2780620123 @default.
- W2046398840 hasConceptScore W2046398840C52119013 @default.
- W2046398840 hasConceptScore W2046398840C95457728 @default.
- W2046398840 hasIssue "3" @default.
- W2046398840 hasLocation W20463988401 @default.
- W2046398840 hasOpenAccess W2046398840 @default.
- W2046398840 hasPrimaryLocation W20463988401 @default.
- W2046398840 hasRelatedWork W163049555 @default.
- W2046398840 hasRelatedWork W2034160010 @default.
- W2046398840 hasRelatedWork W2065927710 @default.
- W2046398840 hasRelatedWork W2314025760 @default.
- W2046398840 hasRelatedWork W2416726498 @default.
- W2046398840 hasRelatedWork W2748952813 @default.
- W2046398840 hasRelatedWork W2899084033 @default.
- W2046398840 hasRelatedWork W330470027 @default.
- W2046398840 hasRelatedWork W4246619863 @default.
- W2046398840 hasRelatedWork W4299497409 @default.
- W2046398840 hasVolume "72" @default.
- W2046398840 isParatext "false" @default.