Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2051213584> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2051213584 endingPage "168" @default.
- W2051213584 startingPage "160" @default.
- W2051213584 abstract "Peer review is a gatekeeper, the final arbiter of what is valued in academia, but it has been criticized in relation to traditional psychological research criteria of reliability, validity, generalizability, and potential biases. Despite a considerable literature, there is surprisingly little sound peer-review research examining these criteria or strategies for improving the process. This article summarizes the authors' research program with the Australian Research Council, which receives thousands of grant proposals from the social science, humanities, and science disciplines and reviews by assessors from all over the world. Using multilevel cross-classified models, the authors critically evaluated peer reviews of grant applications and potential biases associated with applicants, assessors, and their interaction (e.g., age, gender, university, academic rank, research team composition, nationality, experience). Peer reviews lacked reliability, but the only major systematic bias found involved the inflated, unreliable, and invalid ratings of assessors nominated by the applicants themselves. The authors propose a new approach, the reader system, which they evaluated with psychology and education grant proposals and found to be substantially more reliable and strategically advantageous than traditional peer reviews of grant applications." @default.
- W2051213584 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2051213584 creator A5001549927 @default.
- W2051213584 creator A5006614898 @default.
- W2051213584 creator A5050130918 @default.
- W2051213584 date "2008-01-01" @default.
- W2051213584 modified "2023-10-05" @default.
- W2051213584 title "Improving the peer-review process for grant applications: Reliability, validity, bias, and generalizability." @default.
- W2051213584 cites W104385083 @default.
- W2051213584 cites W1544729927 @default.
- W2051213584 cites W1547646701 @default.
- W2051213584 cites W1578561495 @default.
- W2051213584 cites W1967379013 @default.
- W2051213584 cites W1976219213 @default.
- W2051213584 cites W1995897266 @default.
- W2051213584 cites W1997834582 @default.
- W2051213584 cites W2008730220 @default.
- W2051213584 cites W2021882344 @default.
- W2051213584 cites W2024728251 @default.
- W2051213584 cites W2030552375 @default.
- W2051213584 cites W2030769837 @default.
- W2051213584 cites W2037185018 @default.
- W2051213584 cites W2053031440 @default.
- W2051213584 cites W2055124066 @default.
- W2051213584 cites W2057624438 @default.
- W2051213584 cites W2061653610 @default.
- W2051213584 cites W2072020930 @default.
- W2051213584 cites W2074219096 @default.
- W2051213584 cites W2074248138 @default.
- W2051213584 cites W2074978652 @default.
- W2051213584 cites W2094015739 @default.
- W2051213584 cites W2102073367 @default.
- W2051213584 cites W2132736842 @default.
- W2051213584 cites W2136945077 @default.
- W2051213584 cites W2141403362 @default.
- W2051213584 cites W2143317665 @default.
- W2051213584 cites W2167113638 @default.
- W2051213584 cites W2283849407 @default.
- W2051213584 cites W3022732902 @default.
- W2051213584 cites W580933825 @default.
- W2051213584 cites W6874264 @default.
- W2051213584 cites W979941391 @default.
- W2051213584 cites W183191217 @default.
- W2051213584 doi "https://doi.org/10.1037/0003-066x.63.3.160" @default.
- W2051213584 hasPubMedId "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18377106" @default.
- W2051213584 hasPublicationYear "2008" @default.
- W2051213584 type Work @default.
- W2051213584 sameAs 2051213584 @default.
- W2051213584 citedByCount "227" @default.
- W2051213584 countsByYear W20512135842012 @default.
- W2051213584 countsByYear W20512135842013 @default.
- W2051213584 countsByYear W20512135842014 @default.
- W2051213584 countsByYear W20512135842015 @default.
- W2051213584 countsByYear W20512135842016 @default.
- W2051213584 countsByYear W20512135842017 @default.
- W2051213584 countsByYear W20512135842018 @default.
- W2051213584 countsByYear W20512135842019 @default.
- W2051213584 countsByYear W20512135842020 @default.
- W2051213584 countsByYear W20512135842021 @default.
- W2051213584 countsByYear W20512135842022 @default.
- W2051213584 countsByYear W20512135842023 @default.
- W2051213584 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2051213584 hasAuthorship W2051213584A5001549927 @default.
- W2051213584 hasAuthorship W2051213584A5006614898 @default.
- W2051213584 hasAuthorship W2051213584A5050130918 @default.
- W2051213584 hasConcept C121332964 @default.
- W2051213584 hasConcept C138368954 @default.
- W2051213584 hasConcept C138496976 @default.
- W2051213584 hasConcept C15744967 @default.
- W2051213584 hasConcept C163258240 @default.
- W2051213584 hasConcept C171606756 @default.
- W2051213584 hasConcept C17744445 @default.
- W2051213584 hasConcept C199539241 @default.
- W2051213584 hasConcept C27158222 @default.
- W2051213584 hasConcept C43214815 @default.
- W2051213584 hasConcept C62520636 @default.
- W2051213584 hasConcept C70364389 @default.
- W2051213584 hasConcept C70410870 @default.
- W2051213584 hasConcept C75630572 @default.
- W2051213584 hasConcept C77805123 @default.
- W2051213584 hasConceptScore W2051213584C121332964 @default.
- W2051213584 hasConceptScore W2051213584C138368954 @default.
- W2051213584 hasConceptScore W2051213584C138496976 @default.
- W2051213584 hasConceptScore W2051213584C15744967 @default.
- W2051213584 hasConceptScore W2051213584C163258240 @default.
- W2051213584 hasConceptScore W2051213584C171606756 @default.
- W2051213584 hasConceptScore W2051213584C17744445 @default.
- W2051213584 hasConceptScore W2051213584C199539241 @default.
- W2051213584 hasConceptScore W2051213584C27158222 @default.
- W2051213584 hasConceptScore W2051213584C43214815 @default.
- W2051213584 hasConceptScore W2051213584C62520636 @default.
- W2051213584 hasConceptScore W2051213584C70364389 @default.
- W2051213584 hasConceptScore W2051213584C70410870 @default.
- W2051213584 hasConceptScore W2051213584C75630572 @default.
- W2051213584 hasConceptScore W2051213584C77805123 @default.
- W2051213584 hasFunder F4320334704 @default.
- W2051213584 hasIssue "3" @default.
- W2051213584 hasLocation W20512135841 @default.