Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2056553390> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2056553390 endingPage "179" @default.
- W2056553390 startingPage "151" @default.
- W2056553390 abstract "A World Neither Brave Nor New:Reading Dystopian Fiction after 9/11 Efraim Sicher and Natalia Skradol Under the general demand for slackening and for appeasement, we can hear the muttering of the desire for a return of terror, for the realization of the fantasy to seize reality. Lyotard 1984: 82 On ne peut pas écrire sur ce sujet mais on ne peut pas écrire sur autre chose non plus. Plus rien ne nous atteint. Beigbeder 2003:18 The End without Ending: The Intrusion of the Real 9/11 has been imagined before in countless hijack or terminal disaster films such as Blade Runner, Apocalypse Now, and Independence Day. Slavoj Žižek presents the TV coverage of 9/11 as the Hitchcock moment of horror that is actually happening; it is the intrusion of the real into fiction. This is what made similar scenes in horror movies unscreenable in the immediate weeks after 9/11 and sent the CIA scurrying after Hollywood scriptwriters in order to try to understand the terrorists. It is an intrusion, Žižek argues, that is the ultimate marker of the passion for the Real (2002: 16-20). One instance of this intrusion occurs in the film The Matrix (1999) when the hero awakens from what he thought [End Page 151] was real into the real reality and sees a desolate landscape littered with the burned ruins of Chicago after a global war. The hero then encounters resistance leader Morpheus, who utters the ironic greeting: Welcome to the desert of the real.1 This essay explores how our imagining of future disaster in dystopian literature is re-visioned and revised by the after-image of the disaster that has actually happened. If there has been a change in our reading of literature and film since 9/11, this change may not be quantifiable (a measurement beyond the scope of this essay and possibly beyond feasibility), but it may teach us something about the way in which the afterimage of the disaster that has actually occurred affects our reading in the would-be anterior future of imagined terminal catastrophe, the imagined end of society, of time, of the story. A similar process of reinterpretation happened after the 2004 tsunami disaster in Asia, which seemed to outdo the scenes in the film The Day After Tomorrow (2004) of a submerged New York. Each of these events challenged the human ability to control history and the environment. Both natural and man-made disasters leave deep impressions on the imagination and on philosophy. For example, the 1755 Lisbon earthquake destroyed an imperial capital equivalent to the size of prewar London and made a laughing-stock of Leibnizian optimism in Voltaire's Candide. Yet natural disasters do not usually have political, military, and historical significance and, unlike 9/11, are rarely thought of as marking the end of an era. 9/11 was an intrusion of the real that made it impossible to un-imagine dystopia as nightmare or fantasy. It is not a matter of whether or not utopian thought is still sustainable or practical, but of what has happened in postmodern fiction under the impact of a real collision of reality and imagination. This destruction was not just another demonstration of a culture of after-images but a singular event, perhaps an ur-event, which showed that the world was in a permanent state of unending disasters. What could looking backward from after 9/11 mean for our reading of dystopian texts? We do not have in mind mere foreshadowing (cf. Bernstein 1994), or Jacques Derrida's delineation of nuclear-holocaust [End Page 152] discourse as an entirely fictional genre (since it had not happened and could not happen without erasing all record, all archive, of its having happened).2 Rather, the effect of reading any dystopian text post factum, when history has given chilling new meaning to the original context in which the disaster was imagined, reverses the relationship between fiction and reality and raises unsettling postmodern suspicions of the real as something that can be known otherwise than as an aesthetic artefact. We are always, when reading narratives, looking forward, in all senses, to the end, but..." @default.
- W2056553390 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2056553390 creator A5001667686 @default.
- W2056553390 creator A5044809950 @default.
- W2056553390 date "2006-01-01" @default.
- W2056553390 modified "2023-10-17" @default.
- W2056553390 title "A World Neither Brave Nor New: Reading Dystopian Fiction after 9/11" @default.
- W2056553390 cites W1488036481 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W1489596293 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W1493053324 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W1512773166 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W1532381672 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W1550554520 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W1552262089 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W1557995978 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W1571088629 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W1594434806 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W1596765496 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W1600774362 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W1908401045 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W1955817254 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W1969887009 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W1972935646 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W1979050846 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W1995463472 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W20063516 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W2009906315 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W2017975079 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W2019018506 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W2038517563 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W2047401270 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W2051151065 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W2073610877 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W2087722852 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W2108221308 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W2118478029 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W2119384911 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W2132443041 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W2172602991 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W2332793081 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W2743709622 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W2798658807 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W2799107455 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W347216838 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W572292271 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W584540832 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W585862836 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W590729331 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W591107909 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W602061414 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W613410459 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W641330530 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W658892285 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W2887622239 @default.
- W2056553390 cites W2888313292 @default.
- W2056553390 doi "https://doi.org/10.1353/pan.0.0057" @default.
- W2056553390 hasPublicationYear "2006" @default.
- W2056553390 type Work @default.
- W2056553390 sameAs 2056553390 @default.
- W2056553390 citedByCount "9" @default.
- W2056553390 countsByYear W20565533902013 @default.
- W2056553390 countsByYear W20565533902015 @default.
- W2056553390 countsByYear W20565533902021 @default.
- W2056553390 countsByYear W20565533902022 @default.
- W2056553390 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2056553390 hasAuthorship W2056553390A5001667686 @default.
- W2056553390 hasAuthorship W2056553390A5044809950 @default.
- W2056553390 hasConcept C105795698 @default.
- W2056553390 hasConcept C124952713 @default.
- W2056553390 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W2056553390 hasConcept C142362112 @default.
- W2056553390 hasConcept C154775046 @default.
- W2056553390 hasConcept C15744967 @default.
- W2056553390 hasConcept C166957645 @default.
- W2056553390 hasConcept C167651023 @default.
- W2056553390 hasConcept C23189370 @default.
- W2056553390 hasConcept C2780310893 @default.
- W2056553390 hasConcept C2780458788 @default.
- W2056553390 hasConcept C33923547 @default.
- W2056553390 hasConcept C41895202 @default.
- W2056553390 hasConcept C51364203 @default.
- W2056553390 hasConcept C52119013 @default.
- W2056553390 hasConcept C534859617 @default.
- W2056553390 hasConcept C542102704 @default.
- W2056553390 hasConcept C554936623 @default.
- W2056553390 hasConcept C5616717 @default.
- W2056553390 hasConcept C95457728 @default.
- W2056553390 hasConceptScore W2056553390C105795698 @default.
- W2056553390 hasConceptScore W2056553390C124952713 @default.
- W2056553390 hasConceptScore W2056553390C138885662 @default.
- W2056553390 hasConceptScore W2056553390C142362112 @default.
- W2056553390 hasConceptScore W2056553390C154775046 @default.
- W2056553390 hasConceptScore W2056553390C15744967 @default.
- W2056553390 hasConceptScore W2056553390C166957645 @default.
- W2056553390 hasConceptScore W2056553390C167651023 @default.
- W2056553390 hasConceptScore W2056553390C23189370 @default.
- W2056553390 hasConceptScore W2056553390C2780310893 @default.
- W2056553390 hasConceptScore W2056553390C2780458788 @default.