Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2058125983> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2058125983 endingPage "113" @default.
- W2058125983 startingPage "90" @default.
- W2058125983 abstract "Introduction Speech-language pathologists' (SLPs') academic study of language is heavily influenced by linguistic and cognitive viewpoints. A majority of textbooks and writings familiar to SLPs explore in greater detail the linguistic and structural view of language and offer only a limited summary of the behavioral view whose concepts and implications are not carried throughout the text. Most SLPs are well versed in the phonologic, morphologic, syntactic, and structures of language but are not equally well versed in the functional units that are basic to Skinner's (1957) analysis. Nonetheless, SLP's treatment methods are mostly behavioral (Hegde, 1998, 2008a). Inevitably, this has led to a conceptually inconsistent model of language and treatment of language disorders. Chomsky's (1959) critical review of Skinner's (1957) book--Verbal Behavior--is better known than the book itself. Most students and clinicians seem to be unaware of the invalidity of Chomsky's criticism or the competent responses given to his negative review (e.g., Anderson, 1991; MacCorquodale, 1969, 1970; McLeish & Martin, 1975; Palmer, 2006; Richelle, 1976). Rejoinders to his review have pointed out that Chomsky poorly understood Skinner's Verbal Behavior, behavioral methodology, and behaviorism. Chomsky's misunderstanding of Skinner's book and concepts was so severe that it would prompt most examination graders to read no further (Richelle, 1976, p. 209). Chomsky frequently attributed views of other psychologists to Skinner who had unequivocally repudiated them. In a questionable case of scholarship, Chomsky repeatedly misquoted Skinner (Adelman, 2007). More than four decades after he wrote the review, Chomsky was still a critic of Skinner, and with the same distorted understanding of Skinner's work (Virues-Ortega, 2006). A commonly held assumption among most linguists, and SLPs who follow them, is that Skinner's Verbal Behavior has faded into history. The fact, however, is that research on verbal behavior and treatment of verbal behavior disorders based on Skinnerian analysis are flourishing. Among several others in the Unites States, the journals of The Analysis of Verbal Behavior, The Behavior Analyst, Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis, Behavior Modification, and several international journals on behavior analysis regularly publish many articles on the Skinnerian verbal behavior analysis and treatment. This journal, Journal of Speech-Language Pathology and Applied Behavior Analysis is devoted to bridging the gap between the two disciplines. As Schlinger (2008a) has ably demonstrated, Skinner's Verbal Behavior is alive and well. An interesting observation Schlinger makes is that although both Verbal Behavior and Chomsky's (1957) Syntactic Structures had their 50th anniversary in 2007, Skinner's book on Amazon.com, has been selling better than Chomsky's. The verbal behavior approach to treating children with autism is now recognized internationally as the most evidence-based approach. Teaching almost all forms of communication disorders is essentially behavioral (Hegde, 1998, 2006, 2007; Hegde & Maul, 2006; Pena-Brooks & Hegde, 2007), whether some SLPs acknowledge it or not. In fact, if any tide has turned against something, it is the tide against Chomsky's generative linguistics. While Skinner's experimental and applied behavior analysis is thriving worldwide, Chomsky's generative grammar notion has disappeared from linguistics (Harris, 1993; Leigland, 2007). Chomsky's own multiple revisions and qualifications of his 1957 theory have moved away from a cognitive, generative, rule-based theory of language (Schoneberger, 2000). Within just a few years of Chomsky's Syntactic Structures was published, there was the generative semantic rebellion that denied the supremacy of grammar in language. (Linguists often describe newer approaches as revolution, war, rebellion.) Soon came the pragmatic revolution which asserted in the 1970s that language should be understood as actions performed in social contexts--mostly an arm-chair philosophical view which was still structural in its orientation. …" @default.
- W2058125983 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2058125983 creator A5002923320 @default.
- W2058125983 date "2010-01-01" @default.
- W2058125983 modified "2023-09-23" @default.
- W2058125983 title "Language and grammar: A behavioral analysis." @default.
- W2058125983 cites W120248055 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W1496172063 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W1516638448 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W1568382678 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W157094232 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W1577223493 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W1584355541 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W165127026 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W173708309 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W1782262612 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W184021503 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W189966415 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W190031640 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W191142173 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W1927296931 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W1965371897 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W1966753682 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W1972958496 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W1986445274 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W2014169829 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W2014405603 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W2016129004 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W2018105956 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W2021085684 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W2023287691 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W2023694374 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W2035418627 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W2055574061 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W2067936275 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W2069564141 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W2075848454 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W2083878925 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W2099284005 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W2121308464 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W2123081516 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W2126405944 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W2129705892 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W2131682599 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W2134114503 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W2140948501 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W2149353546 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W2149579625 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W2149601790 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W2162587370 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W2335821550 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W2615127929 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W3012551170 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W330664901 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W43351698 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W582309910 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W631752772 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W650744393 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W76773897 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W77895435 @default.
- W2058125983 cites W99755671 @default.
- W2058125983 doi "https://doi.org/10.1037/h0100268" @default.
- W2058125983 hasPublicationYear "2010" @default.
- W2058125983 type Work @default.
- W2058125983 sameAs 2058125983 @default.
- W2058125983 citedByCount "6" @default.
- W2058125983 countsByYear W20581259832012 @default.
- W2058125983 countsByYear W20581259832016 @default.
- W2058125983 countsByYear W20581259832021 @default.
- W2058125983 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2058125983 hasAuthorship W2058125983A5002923320 @default.
- W2058125983 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W2058125983 hasConcept C15744967 @default.
- W2058125983 hasConcept C204321447 @default.
- W2058125983 hasConcept C26022165 @default.
- W2058125983 hasConcept C41008148 @default.
- W2058125983 hasConcept C41895202 @default.
- W2058125983 hasConceptScore W2058125983C138885662 @default.
- W2058125983 hasConceptScore W2058125983C15744967 @default.
- W2058125983 hasConceptScore W2058125983C204321447 @default.
- W2058125983 hasConceptScore W2058125983C26022165 @default.
- W2058125983 hasConceptScore W2058125983C41008148 @default.
- W2058125983 hasConceptScore W2058125983C41895202 @default.
- W2058125983 hasIssue "2" @default.
- W2058125983 hasLocation W20581259831 @default.
- W2058125983 hasOpenAccess W2058125983 @default.
- W2058125983 hasPrimaryLocation W20581259831 @default.
- W2058125983 hasRelatedWork W1512718085 @default.
- W2058125983 hasRelatedWork W1569841287 @default.
- W2058125983 hasRelatedWork W2293457016 @default.
- W2058125983 hasRelatedWork W2359001871 @default.
- W2058125983 hasRelatedWork W2369308426 @default.
- W2058125983 hasRelatedWork W2748952813 @default.
- W2058125983 hasRelatedWork W2789919619 @default.
- W2058125983 hasRelatedWork W2899084033 @default.
- W2058125983 hasRelatedWork W1551406738 @default.
- W2058125983 hasRelatedWork W2610387714 @default.
- W2058125983 hasVolume "5" @default.