Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2059688551> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2059688551 endingPage "27" @default.
- W2059688551 startingPage "1" @default.
- W2059688551 abstract "The law on automatism is undergoing change. For some time there has been a conflict between the medical and the legal views. The medical profession believes that the present division between sane and insane automatism makes little medical sense. Insane automatism is due to an internal factor, that is, a disease of the brain, while sane automatism is due to an external factor, such as a blow on the head or an injection of a drug. This leads to the situation where, for example, the hypoglycaemia resulting from injected insulin would be sane automatism, while hypoglycaemia while results from an islet tumour would be insane automatism. This would not matter if the consequences were the same. However, sane automatism leads to an acquittal, whereas insane automatism leads to committal to a secure mental hospital. This article traces the development of the concept of automatism in the 1950s to the present time, and looks at the anomalies in the law as it now stands. It considers the medical conditions of, and the law relating to, epilepsy, alcohol and drug automatism, hypoglycaemic automatisms, transient global amnesia, and hysterical automatisms. Sleep automatisms, and offences committed during a somnambulistic automatism, are also discussed in detail. The article also examines the need of the Courts to be provided with expert evidence and the role that the qualified medical practitioner should take. It clarifies the various points which medical practitioners should consider when assessing whether a defence of automatism is justified on medical grounds, and in seeking to establish such a defence. The present law is unsatisfactory, as it does not allow any discretion in sentencing on the part of the judge once a verdict of not guilty by virtue of insane automatism has been passed. The judge must sentence the defendant to detention in a secure mental hospital. This would certainly be satisfactory where violent crimes have been committed. However, it is inappropriate in many cases where non-violent confusional crimes, such as petty larceny, have been committed. Suggestions are made for desirable changes in the law." @default.
- W2059688551 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2059688551 creator A5054351204 @default.
- W2059688551 date "1990-01-01" @default.
- W2059688551 modified "2023-09-25" @default.
- W2059688551 title "Automatism, medicine and the law" @default.
- W2059688551 cites W159989554 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W1657459197 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W1963895158 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W1968272989 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W1981625840 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W1981750955 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W1981896763 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W1984363734 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W1994929964 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W1996621597 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W1998135937 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W1998852056 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W2001402863 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W2017085234 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W2018037201 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W2023014513 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W2028667546 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W2031164437 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W2033058727 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W2042454817 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W2050182648 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W2050861878 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W2052746074 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W2058725129 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W2065245557 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W2071539054 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W2072221430 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W2079034548 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W2080158300 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W2082162533 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W2083331033 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W2097207003 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W2098631445 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W2103231247 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W2105072141 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W2115969101 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W2141803318 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W2145859699 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W2147483966 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W2167383580 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W2238024164 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W2239579096 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W2241622669 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W2274034940 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W2280201426 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W2284285606 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W2294841749 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W2301681936 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W2315897527 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W2402922916 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W2415229211 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W2460165939 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W4233488690 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W4234714516 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W4300354122 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W4300756525 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W4317527877 @default.
- W2059688551 cites W79472619 @default.
- W2059688551 doi "https://doi.org/10.1017/s0264180100000758" @default.
- W2059688551 hasPubMedId "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/2192384" @default.
- W2059688551 hasPublicationYear "1990" @default.
- W2059688551 type Work @default.
- W2059688551 sameAs 2059688551 @default.
- W2059688551 citedByCount "43" @default.
- W2059688551 countsByYear W20596885512012 @default.
- W2059688551 countsByYear W20596885512013 @default.
- W2059688551 countsByYear W20596885512015 @default.
- W2059688551 countsByYear W20596885512016 @default.
- W2059688551 countsByYear W20596885512017 @default.
- W2059688551 countsByYear W20596885512018 @default.
- W2059688551 countsByYear W20596885512022 @default.
- W2059688551 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2059688551 hasAuthorship W2059688551A5054351204 @default.
- W2059688551 hasConcept C15744967 @default.
- W2059688551 hasConcept C169760540 @default.
- W2059688551 hasConcept C2776614971 @default.
- W2059688551 hasConceptScore W2059688551C15744967 @default.
- W2059688551 hasConceptScore W2059688551C169760540 @default.
- W2059688551 hasConceptScore W2059688551C2776614971 @default.
- W2059688551 hasLocation W20596885511 @default.
- W2059688551 hasLocation W20596885512 @default.
- W2059688551 hasOpenAccess W2059688551 @default.
- W2059688551 hasPrimaryLocation W20596885511 @default.
- W2059688551 hasRelatedWork W2001402863 @default.
- W2059688551 hasRelatedWork W2059688551 @default.
- W2059688551 hasRelatedWork W2090949864 @default.
- W2059688551 hasRelatedWork W2170662188 @default.
- W2059688551 hasRelatedWork W2276420942 @default.
- W2059688551 hasRelatedWork W2416382811 @default.
- W2059688551 hasRelatedWork W2748952813 @default.
- W2059688551 hasRelatedWork W2899084033 @default.
- W2059688551 hasRelatedWork W3094040214 @default.