FRINK Linked Data Fragments server

Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2061648436> ?p ?o ?g. }

• W2061648436 endingPage "668" @default.
• W2061648436 startingPage "667" @default.
• W2061648436 abstract "Reviewed by: Birthing the Nation: Sex, Science, and the Conception of Eighteenth-Century Britons Donna T. Andrew Lisa Forman Cody . Birthing the Nation: Sex, Science, and the Conception of Eighteenth-Century Britons. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2005. xxi + 353 pp. Ill. $99.00 (0-19-926864-9). Lisa Forman Cody argues that changes in the understandings of and practices surrounding sex and birth helped to define eighteenth-century [British] national, religious, regional, and even class identities (p. 240). More particularly, she invokes the rise of man-midwifery as the explanatory factor to demonstrate how two modern categories—national identification, and fundamental, oppositional sexual difference—not only emerged in the eighteenth century, but were constituent of each other (p. vii). This is a very ambitious enterprise, and perhaps it is inevitably somewhat speculative and suggestive rather than rigorous, quantitative, or empirical. Most of the analysis consists of Cody's readings of contemporary explorations—explorations that led to the construction (she argues) of a body of natural and modern facts not only about sex, gender, reproduction, and the family (p. viii), but simultaneously about the nature of political, national, and imperial relations. In the course of the volume she reads caricatures, pamphlets, newspapers, and various medical and scientific writings to illustrate her point. At this point I wish to say two things: First, that some of these readings seem to me to be unlikely and overstretched, and it is always worthwhile to remember Papa Freud's dictum that a cigar may just be a good smoke. This I think is particularly apposite to Cody's interpretation of the opening image of the book, The Happy Deliverance: After explaining that the actions in the depicted scene reveal a strident anti-Catholic, [End Page 667] antifeminist, and antiforeign bias (surely not novel in early modern British history), she later identifies the man-midwife who delivers the pregnant male monarch as an evangelical divine, perhaps the charismatic Methodist preacher George Whitefield (p. 212). I looked in vain for either an argument for this identification or a footnote—surely even speculation should have more foundation than this. The second difficulty I encountered was one of voice. In this history, the only action portrayed is that of the author (I) reading the lives of the central actors in this book (p. ix). Even the audience was imagined (see p. xiii). The use of the passive voice is everywhere; when actors are named (unless they are man-midwives), they are usually referred to collectively, as Britons or Georgians. I do not wish to overlabor this point: one does hear a few distinct voices, like Horace Walpole's and Jane Sharp's, but often we must be content with collective descriptions and assertions about what they believed and why. Another indication of the same problem is the frequent use of qualifiers like perhaps, probably, or seemed to (see, e.g., the analysis of the story of the midwife toad, p. 248, in which three consecutive sentences rely on such unfounded, but possible, conjecture). One of the main points of Cody's book is that before the advent of male midwives, childbirth was . . . considered a secret, private affair, left to the management of women alone (p. 31). This she contrasts with the public discussion surrounding childbirth in the aftermath of its male takeover. There were, of course, many childbirths that were never secret or private—namely, those of royal consorts who thought nothing of having hordes of men and women in the birthing chamber. There were also many public discussions of the importance of childbirth in the voluminous early modern British literature on the value of a growing population for a powerful and wealthy nation, well before the appearance of male midwives. Historical development is rarely as integrated and monocausal as Cody implies. Furthermore, ideas in the past (as in the present) were rarely as free-floating as this book suggests; though it is often difficult to establish who was doing what to whom, and why, these are surely the historian's debts to the reader. Donna T. Andrew University of Guelph Copyright © 2007 The Johns Hopkins University Press" @default.
• W2061648436 created "2016-06-24" @default.
• W2061648436 creator A5014146822 @default.
• W2061648436 date "2007-01-01" @default.
• W2061648436 modified "2023-10-17" @default.
• W2061648436 title "Birthing the Nation: Sex, Science, and the Conception of Eighteenth-Century Britons (review)" @default.
• W2061648436 doi "https://doi.org/10.1353/bhm.2007.0061" @default.
• W2061648436 hasPublicationYear "2007" @default.
• W2061648436 type Work @default.
• W2061648436 sameAs 2061648436 @default.
• W2061648436 citedByCount "0" @default.
• W2061648436 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
• W2061648436 hasAuthorship W2061648436A5014146822 @default.
• W2061648436 hasConcept C107993555 @default.
• W2061648436 hasConcept C144024400 @default.
• W2061648436 hasConcept C17744445 @default.
• W2061648436 hasConcept C199539241 @default.
• W2061648436 hasConcept C201280247 @default.
• W2061648436 hasConcept C29595303 @default.
• W2061648436 hasConcept C74916050 @default.
• W2061648436 hasConcept C94625758 @default.
• W2061648436 hasConcept C95457728 @default.
• W2061648436 hasConceptScore W2061648436C107993555 @default.
• W2061648436 hasConceptScore W2061648436C144024400 @default.
• W2061648436 hasConceptScore W2061648436C17744445 @default.
• W2061648436 hasConceptScore W2061648436C199539241 @default.
• W2061648436 hasConceptScore W2061648436C201280247 @default.
• W2061648436 hasConceptScore W2061648436C29595303 @default.
• W2061648436 hasConceptScore W2061648436C74916050 @default.
• W2061648436 hasConceptScore W2061648436C94625758 @default.
• W2061648436 hasConceptScore W2061648436C95457728 @default.
• W2061648436 hasIssue "3" @default.
• W2061648436 hasLocation W20616484361 @default.
• W2061648436 hasOpenAccess W2061648436 @default.
• W2061648436 hasPrimaryLocation W20616484361 @default.
• W2061648436 hasRelatedWork W2005352059 @default.
• W2061648436 hasRelatedWork W2037806844 @default.
• W2061648436 hasRelatedWork W2353965235 @default.
• W2061648436 hasRelatedWork W2368337155 @default.
• W2061648436 hasRelatedWork W246376258 @default.
• W2061648436 hasRelatedWork W2486960440 @default.
• W2061648436 hasRelatedWork W2762144663 @default.
• W2061648436 hasRelatedWork W2958218547 @default.
• W2061648436 hasRelatedWork W43745523 @default.
• W2061648436 hasRelatedWork W4375821821 @default.
• W2061648436 hasVolume "81" @default.
• W2061648436 isParatext "false" @default.
• W2061648436 isRetracted "false" @default.
• W2061648436 magId "2061648436" @default.
• W2061648436 workType "article" @default.