Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2063278826> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2063278826 endingPage "82" @default.
- W2063278826 startingPage "61" @default.
- W2063278826 abstract "Cognitive Error and Contemplative Practices:The Cultivation of Discernment in Mind and Heart Wesley J. Wildman Brains are amazing organs in all creatures with central nervous systems and especially in human beings. But they are not perfect. Without forgetting the larger success story of cognitive evolution, I want to explore the way that cognitive biases sometimes produce errors in both religious and secular social settings and how such errors can be diagnosed and corrected when they occur. This will involve noticing that error diagnosis and correction is a process that certain social groups have a vested interest in resisting or neglecting, in some respects, while the very same social groups may furnish resources that support the detection of cognitive errors, in other respects. This presents a moral quandary for both secular and religious groups. Should we educate children to be fully aware of their cognitive vulnerability to advertising, thereby learning how to resist and eventually become immune to one of the fundamental power sources of modern market economies? Should religious groups explain to young people their cognitive tendencies to posit the action of supernatural beings whether or not any such action exists, even though this may disrupt the power of religious groups to forge bracing social togetherness that supports psychologically useful coping skills? While I do not seek to answer such complex moral questions in this paper, I do argue that knowledge of cognitive biases and the resulting tendencies to cognitive error, self-defeating behaviors, and self-deception should be made available to those individuals and groups who are interested in promoting a high degree of critical self-awareness in the analysis of beliefs and behaviors in both secular and religious contexts. The term error is a potentially problematic one in that it misleadingly suggests that there might be a uniquely correct way in which cognition should work. I do not wish to suggest such a binary opposition. After all, biases exist in the human cognitive system either because they have been selected in the evolutionary process for their survival benefits or because they are side effects of other traits selected for their usefulness. My concern is with the wondrous human discovery that we can analyze [End Page 61] our behaviors and beliefs with such precision that we can sometimes detect when our cognitive biases produce mistaken beliefs and self-defeating behaviors. This forms the basis for my contention that cognition can often work better than it does—more accurately, less self-destructively—when tendencies to cognitive error are diagnosed, corrected, and perhaps even systematically resisted. The profound irony here is that the very same social groups (secular and religious) with an obvious vested interest in resisting such enlightenment in some respects can also promote processes of discernment and insight in other respects. Existing literature in the cognitive psychology of religion rarely bothers with such subtleties. It is common to assume that simply to notice the operation of cognitive biases in religion—say, in supporting belief in supernatural entities who providentially interact in human affairs, or in establishing and reinforcing people's willingness to defer to certain kinds of religious authority—is at the same time to establish the presence of rampant cognitive error, massive resistance to diagnosing and correcting it, and thus the infliction of pernicious cruelties on young children who have no way of escaping the resulting irrational indoctrination. This moral reflex to condemn religious groups because of their characteristic reluctance to acknowledge the role of cognitive biases in their beliefs and practices is understandable given the irrationality, ignorance, or denial that such reluctance suggests. I frankly acknowledge that I share this moral concern. But the actual complexities of religious practice demonstrate that the situation demands a subtler evaluation. Resistance to awareness of cognitive biases exists both inside and outside religious groups; economic and political practices in all eras and of all types have every bit as much to gain from neglecting to enlighten people about their cognitive operations as religious groups do—just consider the techniques employed in commercial advertising and political campaigns. Moreover, religious groups also promote methods of discernment and self-awareness that have historically been, and continue to be, the dominant method by which..." @default.
- W2063278826 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2063278826 creator A5044817673 @default.
- W2063278826 date "2009-01-01" @default.
- W2063278826 modified "2023-10-17" @default.
- W2063278826 title "Cognitive Error and Contemplative Practices: The Cultivation of Discernment in Mind and Heart" @default.
- W2063278826 cites W1503651125 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W1504443228 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W1511657425 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W1514427256 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W1521267411 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W1548199768 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W1579112519 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W1586163875 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W1590776345 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W1595438251 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W1603542031 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W1629317078 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W1649509181 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W1698190436 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W1775343853 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W1910152176 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W1938339836 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W1941760665 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W1974609125 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W1976650980 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W1985193495 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W1989957044 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W2002651217 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W2009455845 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W2016173482 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W2031168866 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W2033392732 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W2049218516 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W2059910272 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W2062292460 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W2064408990 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W2070257463 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W2074940875 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W2094852080 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W2097698292 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W2099063295 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W2112353765 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W2133044046 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W2144947807 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W2153762366 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W2165337576 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W2165857496 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W2759068 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W2798680473 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W3122886852 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W316287604 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W407511569 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W419628521 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W433523780 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W568723422 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W573131319 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W596544485 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W610096061 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W615705891 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W615853183 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W617530374 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W620683739 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W625705279 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W626636296 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W628754668 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W630340150 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W638602263 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W648882670 @default.
- W2063278826 cites W2890669511 @default.
- W2063278826 doi "https://doi.org/10.1353/bcs.0.0046" @default.
- W2063278826 hasPublicationYear "2009" @default.
- W2063278826 type Work @default.
- W2063278826 sameAs 2063278826 @default.
- W2063278826 citedByCount "1" @default.
- W2063278826 countsByYear W20632788262023 @default.
- W2063278826 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2063278826 hasAuthorship W2063278826A5044817673 @default.
- W2063278826 hasConcept C111472728 @default.
- W2063278826 hasConcept C121332964 @default.
- W2063278826 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W2063278826 hasConcept C15744967 @default.
- W2063278826 hasConcept C163258240 @default.
- W2063278826 hasConcept C169760540 @default.
- W2063278826 hasConcept C169900460 @default.
- W2063278826 hasConcept C178288346 @default.
- W2063278826 hasConcept C180747234 @default.
- W2063278826 hasConcept C2780211513 @default.
- W2063278826 hasConcept C2780791683 @default.
- W2063278826 hasConcept C62520636 @default.
- W2063278826 hasConcept C77805123 @default.
- W2063278826 hasConceptScore W2063278826C111472728 @default.
- W2063278826 hasConceptScore W2063278826C121332964 @default.
- W2063278826 hasConceptScore W2063278826C138885662 @default.
- W2063278826 hasConceptScore W2063278826C15744967 @default.
- W2063278826 hasConceptScore W2063278826C163258240 @default.
- W2063278826 hasConceptScore W2063278826C169760540 @default.
- W2063278826 hasConceptScore W2063278826C169900460 @default.