FRINK Linked Data Fragments server

Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2066933272> ?p ?o ?g. }

• W2066933272 endingPage "8" @default.
• W2066933272 startingPage "8" @default.
• W2066933272 abstract "Having read “The Aharonov-Bohm Effects: Variations on a Subtle Theme” by Herman Batelaan and Akira Tono-mura (Physics Today, September 2009, page 38), we note with some dismay that the principal effect, that related to magnetic flux, continues to be attributed to its re-discoverers rather than to the original discoverers. Batelaan and Tonomura write, “The AB effect was already implicit in the 1926 Schrödinger equation, but it would be another three decades before theorists Yakir Aharonov and David Bohm pointed it out.” 1 1. Y. Aharonov, D. Bohm, Phys. Rev. 115, 485 (1959). That is incorrect: It took only two decades before the effect was pointed out, not by Aharonov and Bohm but by Werner Ehrenberg and Raymond “Rory” Siday. 2 2. W. Ehrenberg, R. E. Siday, Proc. Phys. Soc. B 62, 8 (1949). Aharonov and Bohm cited that prior publication in their second article. 3 3. Y. Aharonov, D. Bohm, Phys. Rev. 123, 1511(1961). According to Bohm’s biographer F. David Peat, “After their first paper had been published, Bohm learned that the effect had already been postulated by a maverick physicist called Rory E. Siday.” 4 4. F. D. Peat, Infinite Potential: The Life and Times of David Bohm, Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA (1997), p. It seems curious that the biographer should use the term “postulated” rather than “proposed” and that he should comment on Siday’s personality but not on Ehrenberg’s. One of us (Sturrock) knew them both: Raymond was very smart but somewhat brash; Werner was erudite and a model of propriety, who would never have subscribed his name to an article unless he was convinced it was correct.It seems that the main scientific, rather than sociological, reason that the AB proposal was taken more seriously than the ES proposal is that the former was presented in the context of quantum mechanics, the latter in the context of electron optics. Aharonov and Bohm made a rapid transition from quantum mechanics to wave theory. Ehrenberg and Siday made a more detailed transition from geometrical optics to wave theory. For the case of magnetic flux, the two articles presented identical theoretical predictions. Our view is that the ES article was tedious but conceptually sound, whereas the AB article was lively but involved a questionable conceptual leap—namely, a relativistic generalization based on a noncovariant analysis. Soon after Sturrock arrived at Stanford University in 1955, and before the Aharonov-Bohm publication, he asked Leonard Schiff, Stanford’s quantum mechanics expert, whether Schiff found the Ehrenberg-Siday proposal convincing. He did.In the interests of accuracy and of giving credit where credit is due, we think it would be appropriate to use “Ehrenberg-Siday effect” for the case of magnetic interference and to reserve “Aharonov-Bohm effect” for electrical interference.We are indebted to Elliott Bloom, Dieter Kern, Walt Harrison, Peter Hawkes, Garret Moddel, Fabian Pease, Jeff Scargle, and Lenny Susskind for helpful discussions on this matter.REFERENCESSection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCES <<CITING ARTICLES1. Y. Aharonov, D. Bohm, Phys. Rev. 115, 485 (1959). Google ScholarCrossref, ISI2. W. Ehrenberg, R. E. Siday, Proc. Phys. Soc. B 62, 8 (1949). Google ScholarCrossref3. Y. Aharonov, D. Bohm, Phys. Rev. 123, 1511(1961). Google ScholarCrossref, ISI4. F. D. Peat, Infinite Potential: The Life and Times of David Bohm, Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA (1997), p. Google Scholar© 2010 American Institute of Physics." @default.
• W2066933272 created "2016-06-24" @default.
• W2066933272 creator A5006555416 @default.
• W2066933272 creator A5047911128 @default.
• W2066933272 date "2010-04-01" @default.
• W2066933272 modified "2023-10-06" @default.
• W2066933272 title "More variations on Aharonov-Bohm" @default.
• W2066933272 cites W2028948400 @default.
• W2066933272 cites W2080888862 @default.
• W2066933272 cites W2091575493 @default.
• W2066933272 doi "https://doi.org/10.1063/1.3397054" @default.
• W2066933272 hasPublicationYear "2010" @default.
• W2066933272 type Work @default.
• W2066933272 sameAs 2066933272 @default.
• W2066933272 citedByCount "4" @default.
• W2066933272 countsByYear W20669332722016 @default.
• W2066933272 countsByYear W20669332722017 @default.
• W2066933272 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
• W2066933272 hasAuthorship W2066933272A5006555416 @default.
• W2066933272 hasAuthorship W2066933272A5047911128 @default.
• W2066933272 hasBestOaLocation W20669332721 @default.
• W2066933272 hasConcept C111919701 @default.
• W2066933272 hasConcept C115260700 @default.
• W2066933272 hasConcept C121332964 @default.
• W2066933272 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
• W2066933272 hasConcept C139989952 @default.
• W2066933272 hasConcept C33332235 @default.
• W2066933272 hasConcept C33566652 @default.
• W2066933272 hasConcept C37914503 @default.
• W2066933272 hasConcept C41008148 @default.
• W2066933272 hasConcept C62520636 @default.
• W2066933272 hasConceptScore W2066933272C111919701 @default.
• W2066933272 hasConceptScore W2066933272C115260700 @default.
• W2066933272 hasConceptScore W2066933272C121332964 @default.
• W2066933272 hasConceptScore W2066933272C138885662 @default.
• W2066933272 hasConceptScore W2066933272C139989952 @default.
• W2066933272 hasConceptScore W2066933272C33332235 @default.
• W2066933272 hasConceptScore W2066933272C33566652 @default.
• W2066933272 hasConceptScore W2066933272C37914503 @default.
• W2066933272 hasConceptScore W2066933272C41008148 @default.
• W2066933272 hasConceptScore W2066933272C62520636 @default.
• W2066933272 hasIssue "4" @default.
• W2066933272 hasLocation W20669332721 @default.
• W2066933272 hasOpenAccess W2066933272 @default.
• W2066933272 hasPrimaryLocation W20669332721 @default.
• W2066933272 hasRelatedWork W1971590269 @default.
• W2066933272 hasRelatedWork W2036382731 @default.
• W2066933272 hasRelatedWork W2066832011 @default.
• W2066933272 hasRelatedWork W2084494627 @default.
• W2066933272 hasRelatedWork W2089311698 @default.
• W2066933272 hasRelatedWork W2090457670 @default.
• W2066933272 hasRelatedWork W2146691474 @default.
• W2066933272 hasRelatedWork W3102427995 @default.
• W2066933272 hasRelatedWork W3103234735 @default.
• W2066933272 hasRelatedWork W3130965325 @default.
• W2066933272 hasVolume "63" @default.
• W2066933272 isParatext "false" @default.
• W2066933272 isRetracted "false" @default.
• W2066933272 magId "2066933272" @default.
• W2066933272 workType "article" @default.