Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2071006975> ?p ?o ?g. }
Showing items 1 to 59 of
59
with 100 items per page.
- W2071006975 endingPage "507" @default.
- W2071006975 startingPage "506" @default.
- W2071006975 abstract "To the Editor: It was with a sinking sense of deja vu, subspecies depressing, that I read the comments of McDonald and Reichman (Chest 1983; 84:511–12) on Baileys proposed classification of disease caused by different mycobacteria (Chest 1983; 84:625–28). It was as if the last 30 years of my professional life and those of a number of my colleagues had disappeared into a black hole. McDonald and Reichman bemoan the “complexity” and “nonclinical” nature of the Runyon classification, and then imply that nothing more happened in the field until the development of the “newer” serologic and lipid analyses. They then propose that “a sorely needed next obvious step is to look at the entire family of mycobacteria.” Where have these authors been since 1954, the year of Timpe and Runyons landmark paper? Hundreds of microbiologists have labored diligently and effectively to bring order to the genus Mycobacterium. Yes, the classification and the tests needed to achieve that classification are complex. The bacilli are not so obliging as to wear bumper stickers announcing their pathogenic proclivities. We classify them on the basis of their phenotypic properties and phylogenetic relationships, put a name on them in accord with an internationally accepted code of bacterial nomenclature, and then try to establish the relationship of members of each named group to various clinical conditions. A specific pattern of clinical association, difficulty in treatment, etc, may be the only features shared by organisms bearing different species names. For these reasons, it is not the responsibility of the scientists to get together with a name for the “major groups;” these major groups do not exist as natural phenomena, although individual species do exist, at least as defined by phenotypic and evolutionary discontinuities that can be measured by current methodology. Clinicians can use any terms to define clinical groups that are useful to them. I have no quarrel with Bailey's proposed classification of diseases in terms of difficulty of treatment. This classification of disease reflects the resistance of members of different species, and looks reasonable and useful to me. However, it should not in any way lead to abandonment of identification of individual strains with species names in clinical reports. That information is needed for diagnosis and for epidemiologic purposes. For example, if several specimens from a patient yield more than one species, as can occur, the interpretation would be different from that of repeated isolation of a single species. The clinical microbiologist must continue to use the well established (albeit still developing) principles to classify and identify mycobacteria. The clinician can then classify disease on the basis of such useful tables as proposed by Bailey." @default.
- W2071006975 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2071006975 creator A5087709618 @default.
- W2071006975 date "1984-09-01" @default.
- W2071006975 modified "2023-09-23" @default.
- W2071006975 title "Classification of Mycobacteria vs Classification of Mycobacterial Diseases" @default.
- W2071006975 doi "https://doi.org/10.1378/chest.86.3.507-a" @default.
- W2071006975 hasPublicationYear "1984" @default.
- W2071006975 type Work @default.
- W2071006975 sameAs 2071006975 @default.
- W2071006975 citedByCount "0" @default.
- W2071006975 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2071006975 hasAuthorship W2071006975A5087709618 @default.
- W2071006975 hasBestOaLocation W20710069751 @default.
- W2071006975 hasConcept C142724271 @default.
- W2071006975 hasConcept C2780374374 @default.
- W2071006975 hasConcept C2781069245 @default.
- W2071006975 hasConcept C2910378896 @default.
- W2071006975 hasConcept C71924100 @default.
- W2071006975 hasConcept C86803240 @default.
- W2071006975 hasConcept C89423630 @default.
- W2071006975 hasConceptScore W2071006975C142724271 @default.
- W2071006975 hasConceptScore W2071006975C2780374374 @default.
- W2071006975 hasConceptScore W2071006975C2781069245 @default.
- W2071006975 hasConceptScore W2071006975C2910378896 @default.
- W2071006975 hasConceptScore W2071006975C71924100 @default.
- W2071006975 hasConceptScore W2071006975C86803240 @default.
- W2071006975 hasConceptScore W2071006975C89423630 @default.
- W2071006975 hasIssue "3" @default.
- W2071006975 hasLocation W20710069751 @default.
- W2071006975 hasOpenAccess W2071006975 @default.
- W2071006975 hasPrimaryLocation W20710069751 @default.
- W2071006975 hasRelatedWork W1814582052 @default.
- W2071006975 hasRelatedWork W1945972565 @default.
- W2071006975 hasRelatedWork W1978693727 @default.
- W2071006975 hasRelatedWork W2131801164 @default.
- W2071006975 hasRelatedWork W2133838781 @default.
- W2071006975 hasRelatedWork W2227388109 @default.
- W2071006975 hasRelatedWork W2363955146 @default.
- W2071006975 hasRelatedWork W2397742913 @default.
- W2071006975 hasRelatedWork W2414729484 @default.
- W2071006975 hasRelatedWork W2416874798 @default.
- W2071006975 hasRelatedWork W2423424105 @default.
- W2071006975 hasRelatedWork W2427468477 @default.
- W2071006975 hasRelatedWork W2427904073 @default.
- W2071006975 hasRelatedWork W2433192430 @default.
- W2071006975 hasRelatedWork W2461488222 @default.
- W2071006975 hasRelatedWork W2461748629 @default.
- W2071006975 hasRelatedWork W2462430276 @default.
- W2071006975 hasRelatedWork W2463805625 @default.
- W2071006975 hasRelatedWork W2495205047 @default.
- W2071006975 hasRelatedWork W358921784 @default.
- W2071006975 hasVolume "86" @default.
- W2071006975 isParatext "false" @default.
- W2071006975 isRetracted "false" @default.
- W2071006975 magId "2071006975" @default.
- W2071006975 workType "article" @default.