Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2072632733> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2072632733 endingPage "424" @default.
- W2072632733 startingPage "412" @default.
- W2072632733 abstract "Citrus canker (Xanthomonas citri subsp. citri) is destructive in many citrus production regions in tropical and subtropical parts of the world. Assessment of canker symptoms is required for diverse reasons, including monitoring epidemics, evaluating the efficacy of control strategies, and disease response in breeding material. The objectives were to compare the ability of experienced and inexperienced raters at assessing citrus canker, to identify factors that affect the quality of the assessment, to determine common sources of error, and to discern how error is related to actual disease magnitude. Two-hundred digital leaf images (0 to 37% area infected) were assessed once by 28 raters, five of whom were experienced plant pathologists (PPs), and 23 who had no experience in disease severity assessment (NPPs). True disease (lesion number [LN], % necrotic area [%N], and % chlorotic+necrotic area [%CN]) was measured using image analysis on a leaf-by-leaf basis, and each parameter was estimated by the 28 raters. LN was neither severely over- nor underestimated, while %N was greatly overestimated, with a lesser tendency to overestimate %CN over the true severity range of these two symptom types. A linear relationship existed between estimate of the disease and true disease for all measures of severity. Data were heteroscedastic and error was not constant with increasing true disease. Agreement between rater estimates and true disease was measured with Lin's concordance correlation coefficient (ρc). LN showed greatest agreement (ρc = 0.88 to 0.99), followed by %CN (ρc = 0.80 to 0.95) and %N (ρc = 0.19 to 0.84). Greater lesion number resulted in overestimation of area infected for both %N and %CN. Overestimation was particularly noticeable at low disease severities. There was a linear relationship between log variance and log true disease for LN (r2 = 0.71), %N (r2 = 0.85), and %CN (r2 = 0.88), and raters tended to estimate disease above 10% to the nearest 5 or 10%. GLM analysis showed differences between PP and NPP groups in assessing disease. For LN, precision of assessment for both groups was similar (r2 > 0.92 and 0.94, respectively), but for estimates of %N and %CN, the PPs were more precise (%N and %CN, r2 = 0.61 and 0.73, respectively) compared to NPPs (%N and %CN, r2 = 0.45 and 0.58, respectively). Absolute error for mean LN was low. The absolute error of %N and %CN showed overestimation to approximately 8% area infected. Above 8%, absolute error increased, but comprised both over- and underestimation. For %N and %CN, relative error was almost exclusively positive and dramatic at severity <8% (up to approximately 600%), but at severity >10% it was relatively small. Error in rater estimates of canker severity is ubiquitous. Understanding these sources of error will aid in the development of both appropriate training and relevant rating aids." @default.
- W2072632733 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2072632733 creator A5037936482 @default.
- W2072632733 creator A5043545199 @default.
- W2072632733 creator A5055109186 @default.
- W2072632733 creator A5060152913 @default.
- W2072632733 creator A5071617904 @default.
- W2072632733 date "2009-04-01" @default.
- W2072632733 modified "2023-10-01" @default.
- W2072632733 title "Comparison of Assessment of Citrus Canker Foliar Symptoms by Experienced and Inexperienced Raters" @default.
- W2072632733 cites W1084521104 @default.
- W2072632733 cites W1643630418 @default.
- W2072632733 cites W1971522910 @default.
- W2072632733 cites W1971554183 @default.
- W2072632733 cites W1973678526 @default.
- W2072632733 cites W1989418985 @default.
- W2072632733 cites W1990448174 @default.
- W2072632733 cites W1991671557 @default.
- W2072632733 cites W1992017941 @default.
- W2072632733 cites W1997108943 @default.
- W2072632733 cites W1998573323 @default.
- W2072632733 cites W2008196892 @default.
- W2072632733 cites W2009494157 @default.
- W2072632733 cites W2009950474 @default.
- W2072632733 cites W2030173962 @default.
- W2072632733 cites W2047431705 @default.
- W2072632733 cites W2055686953 @default.
- W2072632733 cites W2061235077 @default.
- W2072632733 cites W2067868771 @default.
- W2072632733 cites W2090078959 @default.
- W2072632733 cites W2091913822 @default.
- W2072632733 cites W2096362956 @default.
- W2072632733 cites W2142583696 @default.
- W2072632733 cites W2313339984 @default.
- W2072632733 cites W2328161578 @default.
- W2072632733 cites W2509144745 @default.
- W2072632733 cites W2898058775 @default.
- W2072632733 cites W4233016643 @default.
- W2072632733 cites W4237116629 @default.
- W2072632733 doi "https://doi.org/10.1094/pdis-93-4-0412" @default.
- W2072632733 hasPubMedId "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30764221" @default.
- W2072632733 hasPublicationYear "2009" @default.
- W2072632733 type Work @default.
- W2072632733 sameAs 2072632733 @default.
- W2072632733 citedByCount "39" @default.
- W2072632733 countsByYear W20726327332012 @default.
- W2072632733 countsByYear W20726327332013 @default.
- W2072632733 countsByYear W20726327332014 @default.
- W2072632733 countsByYear W20726327332015 @default.
- W2072632733 countsByYear W20726327332017 @default.
- W2072632733 countsByYear W20726327332018 @default.
- W2072632733 countsByYear W20726327332019 @default.
- W2072632733 countsByYear W20726327332020 @default.
- W2072632733 countsByYear W20726327332021 @default.
- W2072632733 countsByYear W20726327332022 @default.
- W2072632733 countsByYear W20726327332023 @default.
- W2072632733 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2072632733 hasAuthorship W2072632733A5037936482 @default.
- W2072632733 hasAuthorship W2072632733A5043545199 @default.
- W2072632733 hasAuthorship W2072632733A5055109186 @default.
- W2072632733 hasAuthorship W2072632733A5060152913 @default.
- W2072632733 hasAuthorship W2072632733A5071617904 @default.
- W2072632733 hasBestOaLocation W20726327331 @default.
- W2072632733 hasConcept C104317684 @default.
- W2072632733 hasConcept C105795698 @default.
- W2072632733 hasConcept C126322002 @default.
- W2072632733 hasConcept C14168384 @default.
- W2072632733 hasConcept C144027150 @default.
- W2072632733 hasConcept C160798450 @default.
- W2072632733 hasConcept C18903297 @default.
- W2072632733 hasConcept C2775862043 @default.
- W2072632733 hasConcept C2777247689 @default.
- W2072632733 hasConcept C2779134260 @default.
- W2072632733 hasConcept C2910266619 @default.
- W2072632733 hasConcept C33923547 @default.
- W2072632733 hasConcept C42972112 @default.
- W2072632733 hasConcept C523546767 @default.
- W2072632733 hasConcept C54355233 @default.
- W2072632733 hasConcept C55493867 @default.
- W2072632733 hasConcept C60644358 @default.
- W2072632733 hasConcept C71924100 @default.
- W2072632733 hasConcept C86803240 @default.
- W2072632733 hasConceptScore W2072632733C104317684 @default.
- W2072632733 hasConceptScore W2072632733C105795698 @default.
- W2072632733 hasConceptScore W2072632733C126322002 @default.
- W2072632733 hasConceptScore W2072632733C14168384 @default.
- W2072632733 hasConceptScore W2072632733C144027150 @default.
- W2072632733 hasConceptScore W2072632733C160798450 @default.
- W2072632733 hasConceptScore W2072632733C18903297 @default.
- W2072632733 hasConceptScore W2072632733C2775862043 @default.
- W2072632733 hasConceptScore W2072632733C2777247689 @default.
- W2072632733 hasConceptScore W2072632733C2779134260 @default.
- W2072632733 hasConceptScore W2072632733C2910266619 @default.
- W2072632733 hasConceptScore W2072632733C33923547 @default.
- W2072632733 hasConceptScore W2072632733C42972112 @default.
- W2072632733 hasConceptScore W2072632733C523546767 @default.
- W2072632733 hasConceptScore W2072632733C54355233 @default.
- W2072632733 hasConceptScore W2072632733C55493867 @default.