Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2078555841> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2078555841 endingPage "800" @default.
- W2078555841 startingPage "790" @default.
- W2078555841 abstract "Objectives The purpose of this study was to use meta-analysis to establish which of the information available to the resident selection committee is associated with resident or doctor performance. Methods Multiple electronic databases were searched to 4 September 2012. Two reviewers independently selected studies that met the present inclusion criteria and extracted data in duplicate; disagreement was resolved by consensus. Risk for bias was assessed using a customised bias assessment tool. Measures of association were converted to a common effect size (Hedges' g). Meta-analysis was performed using the random-effects model for each selection strategy and all outcomes without pooling. Sensitivity analysis for each selection strategy–outcome pair was performed with pooling of effect size. Results Eighty studies involving a total of 41 704 participants were included in the meta-analysis. Seventeen different selection strategies and 17 outcomes were assessed across these studies. The strongest positive associations referred to examination-based selection strategies, such as the US Medical Licensing Examination (USMLE) Step 1, and examination-based outcomes, such as scores on in-training examinations. Moderate positive associations were present for medical school marks and both examination-based and subjective outcomes. Minimal or no associations were seen for the selection tools represented by interviews, reference letters and deans' letters. Conclusions Standardised examination performance and medical school grades show the strongest associations with current measures of doctor performance. Deans' letters, reference letters and interviews all show a lower than expected strength of association given the relative value often assigned to them during resident doctor selection. Objective selection strategies are potentially the most useful to residency selection committees based on current evaluative methods. However, reports in the literature of validated long-term doctor performance outcomes are scant." @default.
- W2078555841 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2078555841 creator A5011229206 @default.
- W2078555841 creator A5054842737 @default.
- W2078555841 creator A5068666547 @default.
- W2078555841 date "2013-07-10" @default.
- W2078555841 modified "2023-10-11" @default.
- W2078555841 title "Associations between residency selection strategies and doctor performance: a meta-analysis" @default.
- W2078555841 cites W1500053948 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W1539825662 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W1717931763 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W1938122880 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W1969736142 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W1971692275 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W1972870603 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W1975301500 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W1979423827 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W1980311027 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W1985089145 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W1986563307 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W1993016226 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W1994408632 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W1997169391 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2000184881 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2001384178 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2005663090 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2006042438 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2011175823 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2012815301 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2018059936 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2025518991 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2025896738 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2027624322 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2028814751 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2031219329 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2031496267 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2031809498 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2033179230 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2038185296 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2039923894 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2040300425 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2042110466 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2044164051 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2044437667 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2044564233 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2045518416 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2049774512 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2051528319 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2056457331 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2057438427 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2063072954 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2063227175 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2064283963 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2067954151 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2070774857 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2074796075 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2075177088 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2075490072 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2075564133 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2082332282 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2082469420 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2087295088 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2089300043 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2092046739 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2092628359 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2103544212 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2104153932 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2107328434 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2107385541 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2107758681 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2111376494 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2122343644 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2125435699 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2126518002 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2134563190 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2134833483 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2139001711 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2146158744 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2149089763 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2152193038 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2154563310 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2154614048 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2157823046 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2158465249 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2161850352 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2330561021 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2439510713 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W2978937913 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W4205932171 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W4241888892 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W4253902053 @default.
- W2078555841 cites W80204720 @default.
- W2078555841 doi "https://doi.org/10.1111/medu.12234" @default.
- W2078555841 hasPubMedId "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23837425" @default.
- W2078555841 hasPublicationYear "2013" @default.
- W2078555841 type Work @default.
- W2078555841 sameAs 2078555841 @default.
- W2078555841 citedByCount "83" @default.