FRINK Linked Data Fragments server

Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2080584598> ?p ?o ?g. }

• W2080584598 endingPage "611" @default.
• W2080584598 startingPage "600" @default.
• W2080584598 abstract "The aim of this study was to compare the methodological quality and input paper characteristics of systematic reviews and meta-analyses reported in the medical and surgical literature by performing a systematic 'overview of reviews'. Ulcerative colitis (UC) and Crohn's disease (CD) were used as the framework for this comparison as they are relatively common serious conditions, with both medical and surgical options for therapy.Medline, Embase, CINHAL and the Cochrane Database were searched to November 2013. Eligible papers were systematic reviews or meta-analyses that considered a question of therapy in CD or UC. Two independent reviewers selected the papers, extracted the data and scored their methodology using the AMSTAR scoring system. The papers were categorized into medical therapy (M), surgical therapy (S) or medical and surgical therapy (MS) groups. Following retrieval of the sample of meta-evidence papers, the original input studies used in their creation were identified and a search of Medline, Embase, CINHAL and the Cochrane Database was performed. A team of researchers then examined the collection of papers for bibliographic and financial information.Five hundred papers were identified in the meta-evidence search, of which 118 were deemed eligible. There was a difference in the AMSTAR-rated average quality of the papers between the S and M group (S 7.36 vs M 8.75, P = 0.01). On average S papers were published in journals with a lower impact factor (S 3.26, M 5.04, MS 5.30, P < 0.001). S papers also showed more heterogeneity (I(2) ; S 37%, M 24%, MS 10%, P < 0.001). Some 25% of S meta-analyses used data-sets with significant heterogeneity (I(2) > 75%), compared with 8% of M meta-analyses and 3% of the MS meta-analyses. Some 5% of S papers were done on data sets that had I(2) values > 90%. There was no difference in the average number of papers assessed in each group, the average number of patients per meta-paper, the average time covered by the reviews, the average number of papers considered within each meta-analysis, or the average number of patients considered within each meta-analysis. Considering the conclusions of each meta-analysis, S meta-evidence was 50% more likely than M meta-evidence to be unable to make recommendations for practice. A total of 1499 original input papers were identified, of which 283 were used in more than one review. Within the non-repeated papers (n = 1023) the average impact factor within the S group was lower than that of the M and the MS groups (3.720 vs 11.230 vs 7.563, respectively; ANOVAP < 0.001). M papers had higher rates of pharmaceutical sponsorship than S papers (M 56% vs S 1%) and twice the level of government support (M 16% vs S 8%). Of note, 21% of M papers had corporate sponsorship but did not list any conflict of interest.Compared with M meta-analyses, S meta-analyses in the UC and CD domain are more likely to be of poorer methodological quality, are of a greater degree of heterogeneity and less often offer a positive conclusion. The papers used to generate meta-evidence in M papers have a greater degree of corporate and government sponsorship, and are more likely to come from journals with higher impact factors." @default.
• W2080584598 created "2016-06-24" @default.
• W2080584598 creator A5004630554 @default.
• W2080584598 creator A5050319217 @default.
• W2080584598 creator A5086475018 @default.
• W2080584598 creator A5087953446 @default.
• W2080584598 date "2015-06-22" @default.
• W2080584598 modified "2023-09-26" @default.
• W2080584598 title "Inflammatory bowel disease meta-evidence and its challenges: is it time to restructure surgical research?" @default.
• W2080584598 cites W1487976653 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W1506111603 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W1516188083 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W1519025828 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W1535489029 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W1542252223 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W1543168456 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W1592603924 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W1602806874 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W1612648896 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W1820287241 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W1825209974 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W1849173567 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W1857468674 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W1918215726 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W1952529329 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W1972681156 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W1978593886 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W1979059321 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W1979601230 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W1980692490 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W1984426896 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W1988453884 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W1988984458 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W1992917440 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W1995508220 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W1997277278 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W1997597229 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W1999251143 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2001678644 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2002145441 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2003112722 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2003314961 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2006767730 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2009025779 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2010193391 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2014229988 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2014243678 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2014491373 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2015408970 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2016996348 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2017325988 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2022623040 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2026267556 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2030638161 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2030662008 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2031700917 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2031908681 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2032570946 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2035535787 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2036050085 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2041298053 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2046585884 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2051299545 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2054822000 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2055399737 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2055879151 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2059019883 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2059059627 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2059964008 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2060298945 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2060313927 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2060322657 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2061120504 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2065383525 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2065794091 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2066234520 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2073414271 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2073644162 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2081069584 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2081689742 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2082742240 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2083640874 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2087238701 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2087952079 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2088251577 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2089800618 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2098452439 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2099599131 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2101372859 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2103300582 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2103637454 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2113897732 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2118028203 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2119790985 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2121569640 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2122315292 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2123412554 @default.
• W2080584598 cites W2124127371 @default.

• next