Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2090846879> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2090846879 endingPage "415" @default.
- W2090846879 startingPage "397" @default.
- W2090846879 abstract "Background Randomized trials of the effects of psychological therapies seek internal validity via homogeneous samples and standardized treatment protocols. In contrast, practice‐based studies aim for clinical realism and external validity via heterogeneous samples of clients treated under routine practice conditions. We compared indices of treatment effects in these two types of studies. Method Using published transformation formulas, the Beck Depression Inventory (BDI) scores from five randomized trials of depression ( N = 477 clients) were transformed into Clinical Outcomes in Routine Evaluation‐Outcome Measure (CORE‐OM) scores and compared with CORE‐OM data collected in four practice‐based studies ( N = 4,196 clients). Conversely, the practice‐based studies' CORE‐OM scores were transformed into BDI scores and compared with randomized trial data. Results Randomized trials showed a modest advantage over practice‐based studies in amount of pre–post improvement. This difference was compressed or exaggerated depending on the direction of the transformation but averaged about 12%. There was a similarly sized advantage to randomized trials in rates of reliable and clinically significant improvement (RCSI). The largest difference was yielded by comparisons of effect sizes which suggested an advantage more than twice as large, reflecting narrower pre‐treatment distributions in the randomized trials. Conclusions Outcomes of completed treatments for depression in randomized trials appeared to be modestly greater than those in routine care settings. The size of the difference may be distorted depending on the method for calculating degree of change. Transforming BDI scores into CORE‐OM scores and vice versa may be a preferable alternative to effect sizes for comparisons of studies using these measures." @default.
- W2090846879 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2090846879 creator A5014048845 @default.
- W2090846879 creator A5014338599 @default.
- W2090846879 creator A5017349953 @default.
- W2090846879 creator A5025057394 @default.
- W2090846879 creator A5027561333 @default.
- W2090846879 creator A5030687390 @default.
- W2090846879 creator A5037958944 @default.
- W2090846879 creator A5056002342 @default.
- W2090846879 creator A5065553319 @default.
- W2090846879 creator A5066968498 @default.
- W2090846879 creator A5067226952 @default.
- W2090846879 creator A5072455307 @default.
- W2090846879 creator A5087313708 @default.
- W2090846879 date "2008-11-01" @default.
- W2090846879 modified "2023-10-15" @default.
- W2090846879 title "Effects of psychological therapies in randomized trials and practice‐based studies" @default.
- W2090846879 cites W1964129217 @default.
- W2090846879 cites W1969298821 @default.
- W2090846879 cites W1981304922 @default.
- W2090846879 cites W1995393126 @default.
- W2090846879 cites W2002207268 @default.
- W2090846879 cites W2018435777 @default.
- W2090846879 cites W2019290064 @default.
- W2090846879 cites W2020165686 @default.
- W2090846879 cites W2025336081 @default.
- W2090846879 cites W2042379575 @default.
- W2090846879 cites W2049024183 @default.
- W2090846879 cites W2049165791 @default.
- W2090846879 cites W2059814460 @default.
- W2090846879 cites W2061378977 @default.
- W2090846879 cites W2064261608 @default.
- W2090846879 cites W2064473661 @default.
- W2090846879 cites W2067495470 @default.
- W2090846879 cites W2072833030 @default.
- W2090846879 cites W2077565497 @default.
- W2090846879 cites W2079095881 @default.
- W2090846879 cites W2083869465 @default.
- W2090846879 cites W2088270917 @default.
- W2090846879 cites W2091430653 @default.
- W2090846879 cites W2094080830 @default.
- W2090846879 cites W2098124720 @default.
- W2090846879 cites W2114350740 @default.
- W2090846879 cites W2130878640 @default.
- W2090846879 cites W2144107029 @default.
- W2090846879 cites W2152984622 @default.
- W2090846879 cites W2169217816 @default.
- W2090846879 cites W2187287753 @default.
- W2090846879 cites W2738334008 @default.
- W2090846879 cites W4230454723 @default.
- W2090846879 cites W4230716340 @default.
- W2090846879 cites W4235813114 @default.
- W2090846879 cites W4247232584 @default.
- W2090846879 cites W4256113794 @default.
- W2090846879 cites W4312861575 @default.
- W2090846879 doi "https://doi.org/10.1348/014466508x311713" @default.
- W2090846879 hasPubMedId "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18625084" @default.
- W2090846879 hasPublicationYear "2008" @default.
- W2090846879 type Work @default.
- W2090846879 sameAs 2090846879 @default.
- W2090846879 citedByCount "56" @default.
- W2090846879 countsByYear W20908468792012 @default.
- W2090846879 countsByYear W20908468792013 @default.
- W2090846879 countsByYear W20908468792014 @default.
- W2090846879 countsByYear W20908468792015 @default.
- W2090846879 countsByYear W20908468792016 @default.
- W2090846879 countsByYear W20908468792017 @default.
- W2090846879 countsByYear W20908468792018 @default.
- W2090846879 countsByYear W20908468792019 @default.
- W2090846879 countsByYear W20908468792020 @default.
- W2090846879 countsByYear W20908468792022 @default.
- W2090846879 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2090846879 hasAuthorship W2090846879A5014048845 @default.
- W2090846879 hasAuthorship W2090846879A5014338599 @default.
- W2090846879 hasAuthorship W2090846879A5017349953 @default.
- W2090846879 hasAuthorship W2090846879A5025057394 @default.
- W2090846879 hasAuthorship W2090846879A5027561333 @default.
- W2090846879 hasAuthorship W2090846879A5030687390 @default.
- W2090846879 hasAuthorship W2090846879A5037958944 @default.
- W2090846879 hasAuthorship W2090846879A5056002342 @default.
- W2090846879 hasAuthorship W2090846879A5065553319 @default.
- W2090846879 hasAuthorship W2090846879A5066968498 @default.
- W2090846879 hasAuthorship W2090846879A5067226952 @default.
- W2090846879 hasAuthorship W2090846879A5072455307 @default.
- W2090846879 hasAuthorship W2090846879A5087313708 @default.
- W2090846879 hasConcept C118552586 @default.
- W2090846879 hasConcept C121332964 @default.
- W2090846879 hasConcept C126322002 @default.
- W2090846879 hasConcept C141071460 @default.
- W2090846879 hasConcept C142724271 @default.
- W2090846879 hasConcept C15744967 @default.
- W2090846879 hasConcept C168563851 @default.
- W2090846879 hasConcept C174106493 @default.
- W2090846879 hasConcept C1862650 @default.
- W2090846879 hasConcept C2779631380 @default.
- W2090846879 hasConcept C2779974597 @default.
- W2090846879 hasConcept C51082289 @default.