Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2100497492> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2100497492 endingPage "778" @default.
- W2100497492 startingPage "768" @default.
- W2100497492 abstract "It is not well-known whether self-report measures and clinician-rated instruments for depression result in comparable outcomes in research on psychotherapy. We conducted a meta-analysis in which randomized controlled trials were included examining the effects of psychotherapy for adult depression. Only studies were included in which both a self-report and a clinician-rated instrument were used. We calculated the effect size (Hedges' g) based on the self-report measures, the effect size based on the clinician-rated instruments, and the difference between these two effect sizes (Δg). A total of 48 studies including a total of 2462 participants was included in the meta-analysis. The differential effect size was Δg = 0.20 (95% CI: 0.10–0.30), indicating that clinician-rated instruments resulted in a significantly higher effect size than self-report instruments from the same studies. When we limited the effect size analysis to those studies comparing the HRSD with the BDI, the differential effect was somewhat smaller, but still statistically significant (Δg = 0.15; 95% CI: 0.03–0.27). This meta-analysis has made it clear that clinician-rated and self-report measures of improvement following psychotherapy for depression are not equivalent. Different symptoms may be more suitable for self-report or ratings by clinicians and in clinical trials it is probably best to include both." @default.
- W2100497492 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2100497492 creator A5063304307 @default.
- W2100497492 creator A5064711465 @default.
- W2100497492 creator A5066785680 @default.
- W2100497492 creator A5074837834 @default.
- W2100497492 date "2010-08-01" @default.
- W2100497492 modified "2023-10-16" @default.
- W2100497492 title "Self-reported versus clinician-rated symptoms of depression as outcome measures in psychotherapy research on depression: A meta-analysis" @default.
- W2100497492 cites W1536883482 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W1766577204 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W1962246885 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W1964802560 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W1971615296 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W1973659191 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W1975461321 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W1975967545 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W1978384112 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W1986375210 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W1986628810 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W1992887640 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W1995204094 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W1997702978 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W1999649023 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2000745518 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2007965177 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2010926754 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2011664864 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2015006744 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2020027855 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2020279836 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2029137642 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2029684800 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2030706033 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2032149427 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2033585778 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2035461543 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2045722520 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2052111748 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2058051739 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2067495470 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2070584665 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2070886305 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2071170636 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2072358421 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2073663905 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2074772116 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2075315512 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2081289967 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2090022905 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2091752314 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2092121221 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2094304844 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2094622809 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2101341196 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2107031757 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2112519660 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2112778345 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2114613490 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2116486172 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2117688130 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2122365164 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2124295269 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2125435699 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2125556141 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2126165777 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2128913569 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2131373320 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2131823335 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2138381308 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2143449854 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2145371763 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2149264570 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2150506050 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2152301107 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2159824734 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2159859899 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2161213313 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2161776721 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2169217816 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2170332928 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2790059254 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2980019583 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W585171062 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W80967649 @default.
- W2100497492 cites W2128077214 @default.
- W2100497492 doi "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cpr.2010.06.001" @default.
- W2100497492 hasPubMedId "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20619943" @default.
- W2100497492 hasPublicationYear "2010" @default.
- W2100497492 type Work @default.
- W2100497492 sameAs 2100497492 @default.
- W2100497492 citedByCount "225" @default.
- W2100497492 countsByYear W21004974922012 @default.
- W2100497492 countsByYear W21004974922013 @default.
- W2100497492 countsByYear W21004974922014 @default.
- W2100497492 countsByYear W21004974922015 @default.
- W2100497492 countsByYear W21004974922016 @default.
- W2100497492 countsByYear W21004974922017 @default.