Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2101272008> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2101272008 abstract "Some environmental issues for shipping are regulated globally with uniform standards and others with stricter regulations in specific areas. This thesis aims to provide an understanding of why a regional approach was chosen with SOx Emission Control Areas (SECAs) as the main form of control of sulphur oxide emissions from international shipping, with explanations based on documents from negotiations within the International Maritime Organization (IMO) during 1988-1997. The documents were investigated in search of scientific and economic arguments (including supportive information and reported discussions). These were analysed through two ‘conceptual lenses’ to provide different explanations, focusing on the roles of science and economic interests. These lenses were expected to show many explanatory differences, but significant interactions were found. It was found that the Marine Environment Protection Committee of the IMO faced great scientific uncertainty on ship emissions and their contribution to acidification on land. This allowed for an increased role of economic interests, in particular when the Sub-Committee on Bulk Chemicals Handling began drafting regulations for Annex VI to the MARPOL Convention. The actors’ interests decided the policy relevance of science, which was used by the environmental and economic interests to compete rather than to enable consensus. Based on the economic interests of the actors that caused the problem and that would bear the costs of regulation, a science-critical policy environment emerged in which these actors showed as low a contribution as possible to acidification from shipping and extreme economic implications. The focus on the high costs for the oil industry and, in turn, higher fuel costs for shipping, was found to be the primary factor in explaining the regional approach. It was emphasized that economic self-interests are paramount in understanding both the economic and the scientific arguments and the way these could shape policy-making through the power of persuasion. Scientific arguments and claims were used to justify views with underlying economic arguments, which were strengthened with legitimacy. The IMO principles of a compelling need and taking into account costs and economic implications were the primary causes of the cost focus and the critical policy environment. This is a lesson for future policy issues in terms of achieving a balance between industry interests and environmental interests. This thesis’ empirical contribution is based on a large quantity of documents that revealed the scientific and economic basis of different actors’ policies and the policy choices and decisions made by two bodies of the IMO. It contributes theoretically by viewing an international environmental policy-making process through different conceptual lenses. In order to understand why policy-makers in some cases follow the path of environmental protection based on scientific claims and in others follow the path of economic self-interests, we need to take into account both with different conceptual lenses." @default.
- W2101272008 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2101272008 creator A5052667939 @default.
- W2101272008 date "2014-01-01" @default.
- W2101272008 modified "2023-09-24" @default.
- W2101272008 title "Sulphur Regulations for Shipping – Why a Regional Approach?: Scientific and Economic Arguments in IMO Documents 1988-1997" @default.
- W2101272008 cites W113255200 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W1496149102 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W1500087826 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W1504218740 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W1518040380 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W1527311855 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W1527829181 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W1551737440 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W1552073940 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W1593098757 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W1601106317 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W1603087459 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W1634817979 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W1752070589 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W1780237425 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W1798504637 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W1863660469 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W1974491836 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W1975534044 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W1982636319 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W1988680063 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W1995022206 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W1995945562 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W2016820800 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W2017853646 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W2025897332 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W2032720525 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W2034763818 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W2037955071 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W2045407679 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W2051718275 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W2054422547 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W2074372777 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W2074637985 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W2092838154 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W2093523256 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W2115411156 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W2116254729 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W2140282454 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W2147073553 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W2152323124 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W2152389342 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W2156434332 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W2161761531 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W2167340870 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W2167593612 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W2169401895 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W2170689222 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W2175723801 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W2288810599 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W2317197140 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W2321869035 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W2328035621 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W2480076571 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W2493632546 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W2496369459 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W2515095807 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W258460478 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W268092627 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W2753514269 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W2795504231 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W2796026910 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W2799210372 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W2800276540 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W2896890013 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W291651986 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W2988226702 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W3122504087 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W3160452060 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W346339384 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W560631076 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W561673032 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W562704690 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W569698082 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W593439466 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W598625091 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W630104925 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W637468125 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W643505605 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W850204515 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W2251427272 @default.
- W2101272008 cites W2777803356 @default.
- W2101272008 hasPublicationYear "2014" @default.
- W2101272008 type Work @default.
- W2101272008 sameAs 2101272008 @default.
- W2101272008 citedByCount "0" @default.
- W2101272008 crossrefType "dissertation" @default.
- W2101272008 hasAuthorship W2101272008A5052667939 @default.
- W2101272008 hasConcept C107826830 @default.
- W2101272008 hasConcept C144133560 @default.
- W2101272008 hasConcept C155202549 @default.
- W2101272008 hasConcept C158154518 @default.
- W2101272008 hasConcept C162324750 @default.
- W2101272008 hasConcept C17744445 @default.