FRINK Linked Data Fragments server

Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2104143313> ?p ?o ?g. }

• W2104143313 endingPage "210" @default.
• W2104143313 startingPage "179" @default.
• W2104143313 abstract "In this response to Pinker and Jackendoff's critique, we extend our previous framework for discussion of language evolution, clarifying certain distinctions and elaborating on a number of points. In the first half of the paper, we reiterate that profitable research into the biology and evolution of language requires fractionation of “language” into component mechanisms and interfaces, a non-trivial endeavor whose results are unlikely to map onto traditional disciplinary boundaries. Our terminological distinction between FLN and FLB is intended to help clarify misunderstandings and aid interdisciplinary rapprochement. By blurring this distinction, Pinker and Jackendoff mischaracterize our hypothesis 3 which concerns only FLN, not “language” as a whole. Many of their arguments and examples are thus irrelevant to this hypothesis. Their critique of the minimalist program is for the most part equally irrelevant, because very few of the arguments in our original paper were tied to this program; in an online appendix we detail the deep inaccuracies in their characterization of this program. Concerning evolution, we believe that Pinker and Jackendoff's emphasis on the past adaptive history of the language faculty is misplaced. Such questions are unlikely to be resolved empirically due to a lack of relevant data, and invite speculation rather than research. Preoccupation with the issue has retarded progress in the field by diverting research away from empirical questions, many of which can be addressed with comparative data. Moreover, offering an adaptive hypothesis as an alternative to our hypothesis concerning mechanisms is a logical error, as questions of function are independent of those concerning mechanism. The second half of our paper consists of a detailed response to the specific data discussed by Pinker and Jackendoff. Although many of their examples are irrelevant to our original paper and arguments, we find several areas of substantive disagreement that could be resolved by future empirical research. We conclude that progress in understanding the evolution of language will require much more empirical research, grounded in modern comparative biology, more interdisciplinary collaboration, and much less of the adaptive storytelling and phylogenetic speculation that has traditionally characterized the field." @default.
• W2104143313 created "2016-06-24" @default.
• W2104143313 creator A5051185267 @default.
• W2104143313 creator A5072532913 @default.
• W2104143313 creator A5087780736 @default.
• W2104143313 date "2005-09-01" @default.
• W2104143313 modified "2023-10-10" @default.
• W2104143313 title "The evolution of the language faculty: Clarifications and implications" @default.
• W2104143313 cites W1639485615 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W17120685 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W1782593725 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W1795671969 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W1964297962 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W1968090699 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W1969153009 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W1970559565 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W1973177861 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W1976933908 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W1980862600 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W1982976845 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W1986237805 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W1990439739 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W1992807165 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W1994155510 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W1995147081 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2001739183 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2007886868 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2008122551 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2009362633 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2021305179 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2023098348 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2028133852 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2032344422 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2035499443 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2040608890 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2046580380 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2056001434 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2063004914 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2070516174 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2071710993 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2082581672 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2094175135 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2100507278 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2102224657 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2103994288 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2106533942 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2107934935 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2108556861 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2112101928 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2114637222 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2116137580 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2118599126 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2123096684 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2131149854 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2132039854 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2133687321 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2136233496 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2139232464 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2143719445 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2143800077 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2145158132 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2145892439 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2149308461 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2150389998 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2150394189 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2156996429 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2162471372 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2165431515 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2165545766 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2166648354 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2167024992 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2168729844 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2224326415 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W2346578572 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W4231258819 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W4244836975 @default.
• W2104143313 cites W4245718798 @default.
• W2104143313 doi "https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cognition.2005.02.005" @default.
• W2104143313 hasPubMedId "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16112662" @default.
• W2104143313 hasPublicationYear "2005" @default.
• W2104143313 type Work @default.
• W2104143313 sameAs 2104143313 @default.
• W2104143313 citedByCount "547" @default.
• W2104143313 countsByYear W21041433132012 @default.
• W2104143313 countsByYear W21041433132013 @default.
• W2104143313 countsByYear W21041433132014 @default.
• W2104143313 countsByYear W21041433132015 @default.
• W2104143313 countsByYear W21041433132016 @default.
• W2104143313 countsByYear W21041433132017 @default.
• W2104143313 countsByYear W21041433132018 @default.
• W2104143313 countsByYear W21041433132019 @default.
• W2104143313 countsByYear W21041433132020 @default.
• W2104143313 countsByYear W21041433132021 @default.
• W2104143313 countsByYear W21041433132022 @default.
• W2104143313 countsByYear W21041433132023 @default.
• W2104143313 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
• W2104143313 hasAuthorship W2104143313A5051185267 @default.
• W2104143313 hasAuthorship W2104143313A5072532913 @default.

• next