Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2105685265> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2105685265 abstract "Only 15% to 30% of product development projects require the development of new product concepts. This means that the majority of design projects are carried out within the embodiment design and detail design phases. However, the majority of the research studies on the mechanical engineering design process, or design process for short, have been focusing on the conceptual design phase. The embodiment design and detail design phases are considered to be more routine-like and less complex, but the existing embodiment design and detail design methodologies (a methodology consists in a design process model, with related methods and supporting tools) suffer from at least two shortcomings: they are not as thoroughly developed as conceptual design methodologies, and there is a lack of dedicated methods and supporting tools for the generative design activities (hereafter called synthesis) of these phases. This thesis constitutes the first part of an overall research project whose goal is to contribute to the development of a support methodology for the synthesis activities in the later phases of the design process. As a first step, it has been decided to put the engineering designer, or designer for short, at the center of the study. As the designer is the primary user of a design methodology, it is necessary to understand the designer's thinking patterns, to clarify his/her skills and know-how, and to identify some common or specific actions to form the theoretical foundation upon which the support methodology can be developed. Thus the first step of this overall research project is to observe and analyze how the designer performs the synthesis activities in the later phases of the mechanical engineering design process. There is a lack of empirical pre-knowledge of the embodiment design and detail design phases; this first step is therefore explorative in nature and aims at covering this research domain extensively. The design activity of six designers (three students and three experts) has been observed in depth under an experimental setup.Each of the participants had to solve the same problem: to design a support device for a hydraulic piston. The verbal protocol analysis method has been applied to extract a model of their design activities, both on a strategic and tactical level as well as in a problem-solving perspective. The findings concerning the problem-solving process show that the designer, though following a fairly structured approach, developed no more than two alternatives, rapidly selected one of them and then lengthily studied and developed this alternative. There was no systematic evaluation moment. The activity of solution finding, characterized by synthesis, is balanced by an activity of mechanical modeling of the problem, which serves to both understand the generated solution and to monitor its correctness. At the strategic and tactical levels, the experts' design process has the following pattern: rapid understanding of the problem; consideration, very early in the process, of the shape of the parts and their interactions; concrete selection of materials; optimized selection of standard components; dimensioning of the joints. The early selection of standard components led to an early focus on the spatial restrictions and interface compatibility problems. On the other hand, the students reasoned about abstract mechanical structures, without defining the components until late in the process, and thus faced complications later on. A list of weaknesses observed on the part of the designers' process has also been established. The results of this explorative study now need to be further investigated; some complementary studies have to be carried out to statistically verify them. In addition to that, an investigation of the design activity in an industrial environment is needed in order to establish whether or not there are additional factors influencing the embodiment design and detail design phases. (Less)" @default.
- W2105685265 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2105685265 creator A5082158569 @default.
- W2105685265 date "2006-01-01" @default.
- W2105685265 modified "2023-09-27" @default.
- W2105685265 title "On synthesis in the later phases of the mechanical engineering design process" @default.
- W2105685265 cites W11391707 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W130489743 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W1493084650 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W1493518227 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W1494785284 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W1510231618 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W1511836058 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W153703672 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W1553802931 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W1560089513 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W1562578637 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W1574311936 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W1576167540 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W1576584855 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W1589891864 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W1601605178 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W1602115669 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W1833017738 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W1912531130 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W1963547174 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W1963861386 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W1970761477 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W1971140940 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W1976218518 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W1977093570 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W1977402938 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W1979841306 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W1984314602 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W1985013992 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W1986499245 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W1989289666 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W1997081300 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2000384611 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2010041293 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2014683305 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2025224174 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2025293013 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2026818281 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2027405348 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2037646394 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2047134707 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2049006605 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2053680135 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2056789685 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2058312438 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2078092124 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2079265907 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2079778326 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2084169382 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2084474944 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2085020917 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2088517766 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2090299671 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2096360482 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2099660582 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2102126638 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2105640325 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2109716245 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2118141571 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2135477755 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2137587429 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2138786385 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2150658633 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2151587352 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2154531937 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2158668719 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2164291529 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2310140282 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2396715162 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2412175394 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2424351 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2477971848 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2480253396 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2493549247 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2495674880 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2502350824 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2504846114 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2524976724 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2528972707 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2582628485 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2797256608 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2804655122 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W28357659 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2958068212 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W2970264147 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W3041149780 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W3136070364 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W3159374396 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W3202619697 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W3214751942 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W336145253 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W629241095 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W643763019 @default.
- W2105685265 cites W92303929 @default.