Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2108116104> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2108116104 endingPage "275" @default.
- W2108116104 startingPage "261" @default.
- W2108116104 abstract "With the increasing interest in recognizing the discordance between gene genealogies, various gene tree/species tree reconciliation methods have been developed. We present here the first attempt to assess and compare two such Bayesian methods, Bayesian estimation of species trees (BEST) and BUCKy (Bayesian untangling of concordance knots), in the presence of several known processes of gene tree discordance. DNA alignments were simulated under the influence of incomplete lineage sorting (ILS) and of horizontal gene transfer (HGT). BEST and BUCKy both account for uncertainty in gene tree estimation but differ substantially in their assumptions of what caused gene tree discordance. BEST estimates a species tree using the coalescent model, assuming that all gene tree discordance is due to ILS. BUCKy does not assume any specific biological process of gene tree discordance through the use of a nonparametric clustering of concordant genes. BUCKy estimates the concordance factor (CF) of a clade, which is defined as the proportion of genes that truly have the clade in their trees. The estimated concordance tree is then built from clades with the highest estimated CFs. Because of their different assumptions, it was expected that BEST would perform better in the presence of ILS and that BUCKy would perform better in the presence of HGT. As expected, the species tree was more accurately reconstructed by BUCKy in the presence of HGT, when the HGT events were unevenly placed across the species tree. BUCKy and BEST performed similarly in most other cases, including in the presence of strong ILS and of HGT events that were evenly placed across the tree. However, BUCKy was shown to underestimate the uncertainty in CF estimation, with short credibility intervals. Despite this, the discordance pattern estimated by BUCKy could be compared with the signature of ILS. The resulting test for the adequacy of the coalescent model proved to have low Type I error. It was powerful when HGT was the major source of discordance and when HGT events were unevenly placed across the species tree." @default.
- W2108116104 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2108116104 creator A5014754234 @default.
- W2108116104 creator A5031584591 @default.
- W2108116104 date "2011-03-02" @default.
- W2108116104 modified "2023-09-25" @default.
- W2108116104 title "Comparing Two Bayesian Methods for Gene Tree/Species Tree Reconstruction: Simulations with Incomplete Lineage Sorting and Horizontal Gene Transfer" @default.
- W2108116104 cites W1525734744 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W1956721446 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W1977369042 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W1992680333 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W1993231286 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2039334367 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2041323524 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2052184658 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2060425093 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2061646232 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2067121015 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2068225247 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2078921046 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2082473664 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2090326420 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2093601136 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2093631108 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2096689134 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2099400989 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2099435723 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2099459260 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2101132100 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2101896427 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2106704226 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2106947130 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2107508473 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2107608009 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2107780941 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2113531912 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2114227052 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2114430361 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2117741444 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2118127427 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2119438568 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2122465473 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2123305821 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2123800174 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2127713506 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2127803317 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2128252278 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2128749529 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2137180017 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2141541340 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2142385590 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2142755019 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2145608399 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2148723086 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2149194105 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2154427917 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2160690190 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2160936843 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2161305024 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2161444534 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2165038845 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2166145142 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2168852102 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2171317147 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2186169612 @default.
- W2108116104 cites W2342170703 @default.
- W2108116104 doi "https://doi.org/10.1093/sysbio/syr003" @default.
- W2108116104 hasPubMedId "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21368324" @default.
- W2108116104 hasPublicationYear "2011" @default.
- W2108116104 type Work @default.
- W2108116104 sameAs 2108116104 @default.
- W2108116104 citedByCount "106" @default.
- W2108116104 countsByYear W21081161042012 @default.
- W2108116104 countsByYear W21081161042013 @default.
- W2108116104 countsByYear W21081161042014 @default.
- W2108116104 countsByYear W21081161042015 @default.
- W2108116104 countsByYear W21081161042016 @default.
- W2108116104 countsByYear W21081161042017 @default.
- W2108116104 countsByYear W21081161042018 @default.
- W2108116104 countsByYear W21081161042019 @default.
- W2108116104 countsByYear W21081161042020 @default.
- W2108116104 countsByYear W21081161042021 @default.
- W2108116104 countsByYear W21081161042022 @default.
- W2108116104 countsByYear W21081161042023 @default.
- W2108116104 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2108116104 hasAuthorship W2108116104A5014754234 @default.
- W2108116104 hasAuthorship W2108116104A5031584591 @default.
- W2108116104 hasBestOaLocation W21081161041 @default.
- W2108116104 hasConcept C104317684 @default.
- W2108116104 hasConcept C105795698 @default.
- W2108116104 hasConcept C107673813 @default.
- W2108116104 hasConcept C113174947 @default.
- W2108116104 hasConcept C114614502 @default.
- W2108116104 hasConcept C123439655 @default.
- W2108116104 hasConcept C136119220 @default.
- W2108116104 hasConcept C160798450 @default.
- W2108116104 hasConcept C193252679 @default.
- W2108116104 hasConcept C202444582 @default.