FRINK Linked Data Fragments server

Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2108243709> ?p ?o ?g. }

• W2108243709 abstract "Using argumentation to debate and reach conclusions is a particularly human activity relevant to many professions and applications. Debates exist not only in the Houses of Parliament, but also in such disciplines as medicine and law. In this theoretical thesis I explore three new logical constructs for realistic debate modelling, namely: confirmation, preclusion and reflection. Confirmation is two or more arguments for a claim, used to provide corroboration of evidence. Preclusion is an attacking argument that says ‘one or other of your arguments is wrong’; an argumentation technique used adeptly by Sherlock Holmes and many politicians. Reflection is a way of identifying logical redundancies (i.e. predictable patterns) in the argument data structure of a debate. A reflection originates from an unpredictable ‘reflector’ argument and gives rise to the predictable or ‘reflected’ argument. One type of reflection can be said to ‘flow down’ a tree of arguments, where the reflector is nearer the root and the reflected arguments further from the root, while another kind ‘flows up’ the tree in the reverse direction. Incorporating preclusion into the model of reflection increases this to four distinct types of reflection, two up-tree and two down-tree. The value of identifying and removing reflections is to ensure intuitive, or arguably ‘correct’, results when judging debates, be that judgement based on the existence or number of arguments. Removing reflection also aids human comprehension of the debate as it reduces the number of arguments involved. This logical analysis of reflection and preclusion leads to the definition of a reflection-free, preclusion-aware, debate-tracking tree. Finally, the framework addresses judging the tree to determine who won the debate, with a proposal that takes confirmation into account when reaching conclusions. Confirmation assessment is helpful in resolving inconsistencies. Out of scope are notions of alternating moves by competing players and computational complexity." @default.
• W2108243709 created "2016-06-24" @default.
• W2108243709 creator A5083457861 @default.
• W2108243709 date "2008-01-01" @default.
• W2108243709 modified "2023-09-27" @default.
• W2108243709 title "Tracking and judging debates using argumentation : the roles of confirmation, preclusion and reflection" @default.
• W2108243709 cites W102060495 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W146262510 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W1482768500 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W1485823765 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W1487409515 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W1487795664 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W1497933618 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W1500855390 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W1501202226 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W1501337828 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W1509271294 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W1514637386 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W151765464 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W1529749645 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W1541038063 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W1541732678 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W1552415562 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W1557433357 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W1559820017 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W1566892080 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W1569684448 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W1580355372 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W1583628292 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W1586617399 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W1606218761 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W1636624698 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W169016388 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W1714916096 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W171772552 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W1752174299 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W1794299720 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W1825730661 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W1961668815 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W1970045008 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W1976303542 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W1979320841 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W1979394595 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W1997210479 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W2000387210 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W2007807962 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W2009578745 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W2013788787 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W2015722806 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W2029665446 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W2029784280 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W2034224961 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W2036265926 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W2039020269 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W2041139729 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W2043417657 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W2046131379 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W2050211807 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W2064496149 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W2069176561 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W2084827335 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W2098746567 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W2100657934 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W2104126268 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W2105117537 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W2105953471 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W2107316243 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W2113169658 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W2127580579 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W2146485107 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W2149567024 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W2151427054 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W2152212999 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W2156092566 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W2157731917 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W2159569510 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W2161664509 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W2171853123 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W2184369258 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W226985236 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W2333071398 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W28385484 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W2908436493 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W2913246815 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W3026851316 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W3141728133 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W403189958 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W560017174 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W56146011 @default.
• W2108243709 cites W75176724 @default.
• W2108243709 hasPublicationYear "2008" @default.
• W2108243709 type Work @default.
• W2108243709 sameAs 2108243709 @default.
• W2108243709 citedByCount "0" @default.
• W2108243709 crossrefType "dissertation" @default.
• W2108243709 hasAuthorship W2108243709A5083457861 @default.
• W2108243709 hasConcept C111472728 @default.
• W2108243709 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
• W2108243709 hasConcept C185592680 @default.
• W2108243709 hasConcept C199360897 @default.

• next