Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2113166097> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2113166097 endingPage "52" @default.
- W2113166097 startingPage "1" @default.
- W2113166097 abstract "Social Security Reform and National Saving in an Era of Budget Surpluses Douglas W. Elmendorf and Jeffrey B. Liebman The unexpected emergence of federal budget surpluses during the late 1990s, combined with official projections that these surpluses will continue for decades to come, has significantly altered fiscal policymaking. Congressional and administration budget proposals now aim to balance the budget exclusive of Social Security, or exclusive of Social Security and Medicare, rather than on an overall, or unified, basis. Some proposals state the goal of paying off the entire stock of federal debt held by the public within a decade and a half. This fiscal bounty has also altered the likely avenues for Social Security and Medicare reform. Traditional options for ensuring the programs' financial stability-benefit cuts and tax increases-have largely given way to new options focused on using the expected surpluses to prefund future obligations. The future obligations of Social Security and Medicare under current law are large. The projected aging of the population and rising health care spending imply that federal outlays on these programs will nearly double as a share of GDP over the next seventy-five years, from 6.3 percent in [End Page 1] 2000 to 12.2 percent in 2075.1 Increased federal spending on Medicaid, which pays for long-term care for low-income seniors, will accentuate this jump. From the perspective of the programs, prefunding these obligations requires a buildup of assets that can be redeemed to pay future benefits. From the perspective of the nation, however, such programmatic prefunding does not necessarily imply that the obligations have been prefunded in an economically meaningful sense. For example, Congress could simply legislate that $3 trillion of additional government bonds be placed in the Social Security trust fund immediately. This action would nearly eliminate Social Security's seventy-five-year actuarial imbalance but would, by itself, have no direct economic effects. Economic prefunding of Social Security and Medicare requires incremental national saving, which is the only way to increase future resources. In this paper we estimate the effect on national saving of a range of Social Security reform plans designed to capture and contrast the main features of existing proposals. The plans we examine specify the income and outlays of-and thus saving within-the Social Security trust fund and any new individual retirement saving accounts that the plans would create. Yet national saving also includes the saving of the non-Social Security part of the federal budget and the non-individual accounts part of the private sector. Hence the overall impact of Social Security reform depends crucially on the response of these other sectors. Our analysis focuses on these responses. We mostly leave aside other critical issues for Social Security reform such as the distribution of benefits, the allocation of risk, and administrative costs, important though these are. We begin by reviewing the dramatic recent improvement in the federal budget and then discuss the appropriate roles of national saving and programmatic prefunding in response to population aging. Next we explore the relationship of Social Security to the rest of the federal budget, with an emphasis on alternative characterizations of the political economy of budget policy. Then we present our methodology for estimating the effect of Social Security reform on national saving and apply this methodology to a representative set of reform proposals. Our analysis yields four primary conclusions about the effect of Social Security reform on national saving. First, budget policy matters: some [End Page 2] elements of reform raise saving if the political process tends to balance the budget excluding Social Security but have no effect on saving if the political process tends to balance the unified budget. In contrast, other elements raise saving only if the political process tends to balance the unified budget. Second, dissimilar plans can have similar effects on capital accumulation, in part because the plans pay out similar total retirement benefits (although often with a different division between traditional benefits and payouts from individual accounts) and in part because responses elsewhere in the budget offset any differences. Third, if policymakers aim to balance the budget excluding Social Security, then all reforms that generate programmatic prefunding-including..." @default.
- W2113166097 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2113166097 creator A5041021357 @default.
- W2113166097 creator A5069268009 @default.
- W2113166097 date "2000-01-01" @default.
- W2113166097 modified "2023-10-17" @default.
- W2113166097 title "Social Security Reform and National Saving in an Era of Budget Surpluses" @default.
- W2113166097 cites W1483942346 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W1492494577 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W1513115447 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W1518363753 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W1579319633 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W1589461435 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W1602531339 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W1978392755 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W1998480263 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W2018792429 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W2041175506 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W2075509142 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W2075762815 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W2078101344 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W2081122090 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W2085190867 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W2091382926 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W2097714656 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W2118052532 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W2134832174 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W2144649442 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W2168605160 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W2172120792 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W2799673219 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W3010599690 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W3121171036 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W3121483570 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W3121695378 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W3122019706 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W3122385050 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W3122610619 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W3122726250 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W3122800355 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W3123278886 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W3123358936 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W3123615576 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W3124783680 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W3125035438 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W3125523940 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W3125602451 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W3125649872 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W3125697080 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W3125924934 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W3125945704 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W3148514846 @default.
- W2113166097 cites W9982409 @default.
- W2113166097 doi "https://doi.org/10.1353/eca.2000.0013" @default.
- W2113166097 hasPublicationYear "2000" @default.
- W2113166097 type Work @default.
- W2113166097 sameAs 2113166097 @default.
- W2113166097 citedByCount "33" @default.
- W2113166097 countsByYear W21131660972017 @default.
- W2113166097 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2113166097 hasAuthorship W2113166097A5041021357 @default.
- W2113166097 hasAuthorship W2113166097A5069268009 @default.
- W2113166097 hasBestOaLocation W21131660972 @default.
- W2113166097 hasConcept C100001284 @default.
- W2113166097 hasConcept C10138342 @default.
- W2113166097 hasConcept C105639569 @default.
- W2113166097 hasConcept C120527767 @default.
- W2113166097 hasConcept C144024400 @default.
- W2113166097 hasConcept C144133560 @default.
- W2113166097 hasConcept C149923435 @default.
- W2113166097 hasConcept C160735492 @default.
- W2113166097 hasConcept C162324750 @default.
- W2113166097 hasConcept C2776534028 @default.
- W2113166097 hasConcept C2777111884 @default.
- W2113166097 hasConcept C2779282124 @default.
- W2113166097 hasConcept C2779999868 @default.
- W2113166097 hasConcept C2780822617 @default.
- W2113166097 hasConcept C2908647359 @default.
- W2113166097 hasConcept C34447519 @default.
- W2113166097 hasConcept C45619296 @default.
- W2113166097 hasConcept C50522688 @default.
- W2113166097 hasConceptScore W2113166097C100001284 @default.
- W2113166097 hasConceptScore W2113166097C10138342 @default.
- W2113166097 hasConceptScore W2113166097C105639569 @default.
- W2113166097 hasConceptScore W2113166097C120527767 @default.
- W2113166097 hasConceptScore W2113166097C144024400 @default.
- W2113166097 hasConceptScore W2113166097C144133560 @default.
- W2113166097 hasConceptScore W2113166097C149923435 @default.
- W2113166097 hasConceptScore W2113166097C160735492 @default.
- W2113166097 hasConceptScore W2113166097C162324750 @default.
- W2113166097 hasConceptScore W2113166097C2776534028 @default.
- W2113166097 hasConceptScore W2113166097C2777111884 @default.
- W2113166097 hasConceptScore W2113166097C2779282124 @default.
- W2113166097 hasConceptScore W2113166097C2779999868 @default.
- W2113166097 hasConceptScore W2113166097C2780822617 @default.
- W2113166097 hasConceptScore W2113166097C2908647359 @default.
- W2113166097 hasConceptScore W2113166097C34447519 @default.
- W2113166097 hasConceptScore W2113166097C45619296 @default.