Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2113803424> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2113803424 endingPage "3270" @default.
- W2113803424 startingPage "3266" @default.
- W2113803424 abstract "In contradiction to what has been postulated before, the formation of cationic hydrated TiIII complexes is crucial for the activation of H2O towards hydrogen-atom transfer (HAT). The relevant intermediates have been characterized by modern EPR methods (see spectrum) and cyclic voltammetry. The structural assignments were verified by a comprehensive computational study. The calculated bond dissociation energies are in agreement with a previous kinetic investigation. The reduction of radicals to hydrocarbons through hydrogen-atom transfer (HAT) is a fundamental radical reaction.1 Recent developments in the field concentrate on alcohols and H2O as HAT reagents in the presence of boranes2 and [Cp2TiCl],3 (Cp=C5H5) the use of H2 as the final reductant,4 and on BH3–NHC complexes (NHC=N-heterocyclic carbene).5 All cases feature a weakening of otherwise strong HX bonds. The propensity of H2O to act as a HAT reagent has been explained by a reduction of the bond dissociation energy (BDE) of the OH bond by about 60 kcal mol−1 in the presence of [Cp2TiCl].3 Herein, we demonstrate by EPR spectroscopy and cyclic voltammetry (CV) that the proposed HAT reagent 13c is not present in zinc-reduced THF solutions of [Cp2TiCl2] and H2O. Instead, our results suggest that 2 and 3 are the active HAT reagents (Figure 1). Moreover, we show that previous data in support of 13c are also in agreement with 2, 3 a, and 3 b, and that an older computational study3c needs extension and refinement. Proposed modes of complexation of [Cp2TiCl] by H2O. Electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy and the hyperfine resolving techniques electron spin echo envelope modulation (ESEEM)6 and hyperfine sublevel correlation (HYSCORE) spectroscopy6d, 7 are excellent methods for studying interactions between H2O and [Cp2TiCl]. The g values provide direct information about which orbital is occupied by the unpaired electron. The ESEEM and HYSCORE methods are well suited for examining the coordination sphere of the [Cp2TiCl]–H2O system by the detection of magnetic hyperfine couplings with surrounding nuclear spins. Thus the binding of chloride (I=3/2) and the coordination of H2O or D2O can be studied through their coupling to protons (I=1/2) or deuterons (I=1). Pulsed EPR spectra of zinc-reduced [Cp2TiCl2] in THF were recorded. Without H2O, they are in agreement with a previous study8 on [Cp2TiCl] and show that the unpaired electron resides in a orbital at TiIII. This is also the case upon addition of H2O. However, the shape of the spectrum and especially the gx value change significantly upon addition of various molar equivalents of H2O (see the Supporting Information for the spectra). To understand these effects, ESEEM spectra of Zn-reduced [Cp2TiCl2] in THF with different amounts of added H2O (Figure 2, left panel) and D2O (Figure 2, right panel) were recorded. Under the experimental conditions (microwave frequency of 34 GHz) they contain nuclear modulations derived from chloride (I=3/2) and from deuterons (I=1). Protons (I=1/2) do not contribute, because their Zeeman frequency is 50 MHz and their modulations have zero amplitude.9 Normalized Q-Band 3-pulse modulation patterns (T=30 K) of Zn-reduced [Cp2TiCl2] in THF with different molar equivalents of H2O and D2O added. For the spectra in the frequency domain see the Supporting Information. The frequency of the nuclear modulations changes noticeably upon addition of 10 or 20 equivalents of H2O (Figure 2; left panel) indicating an interaction of the halide with H2O. The modulations become weaker for 40 and more equivalents of H2O. This result suggests that the TiCl bond is eventually cleaved through the generation of hydrated chloride and a titanocene cation. However, from this particular ESEEM spectrum it is not clear if the titanocene cation is hydrated or not. Therefore, to study the interaction of water with the titanocene moiety directly, ESEEM spectra of Zn-reduced [Cp2TiCl2] in THF with different equivalents of D2O added were recorded (Figure 2, right panel). Addition of 10 equivalents D2O resulted in similar, albeit not identical, initial changes of the chloride modulations. This result is related to the different hydrogen-bonding propensities of H and D and to a beginning superposition of the modulations caused by D and Cl. Starting from 20 molar equivalents D2O, the modulations with a frequency of 8 MHz became clearly observable. In the presence of more than 40 equivalents these signals dominate the appearance of the ESEEM spectrum. This coupling constitutes the direct experimental evidence for the coordination of D2O to titanium through a TiO bond. Moreover, the combination of the ESEEM experiments highlights that coordination of water is especially favorable after dissociation of the halide ligand. These conclusions were further verified by HYSCORE experiments. At the employed microwave frequency (X-band, 9.7 GHz) all proton signals appear in the spectral region around 14 MHz, off-diagonal signals (cross-peaks) appear between nuclear transition frequencies that belong to the same proton, similar to 2D NMR spectroscopy experiments. Striking differences are observed between the spectra of Zn-reduced [Cp2TiCl2] without added H2O and those with 10 and 100 equivalents H2O (Figure 3). This result is especially apparent at the frequency coordinates (11, 19) MHz and (19, 11) MHz. Cross peaks are absent for Zn-reduced [Cp2TiCl2] but weak signals appear with 10 equivalents of H2O. With 100 equivalents H2O these cross-peaks become very intense. Interestingly, the line shape of the signals observed with 10 equivalents and 100 equivalents of water is essentially identical. X-band HYSCORE spectra (9.68 GHz, 30 K) of Zn-reduced [Cp2TiCl2] in THF a) without H2O b) with 10 equivalents of H2O, c) with 100 equivalents of H2O, recorded at the gy canonical orientations. Moreover, the HYSCORE technique allows an estimation of the distance between the protons of the bound H2O and the Ti center. The ridges of these cross-peaks do not form straight lines, but are rather bent, indicative of the presence of anisotropic hyperfine interaction.10 Careful analysis allows a determination of the dipolar hyperfine coupling constant T⊥ of 5.7 MHz. This value is comparable to that found for the equatorial protons of [Cu(H2O)6]2+ and indicates that the effective distance between the protons of H2O and the unpaired electron is less than 3.3 Å.10 To verify these conclusions, the Zn-reduced THF solutions of [Cp2TiCl2] with added H2O were investigated by cyclic voltammetry (CV) with concentrations of all the reagents being identical to those of the EPR samples. The voltammograms recorded at sweep rates of 0.1 and 1 V s−1 are shown in Figure 4 (for CVs with higher sweep rates, see the Supporting Information). For both sweep rates two oxidation waves were observed for all the cases investigated. For Zn-reduced [Cp2TiCl2] these are assigned to the oxidation of [(Cp2TiCl)2] and [Cp2TiCl] (first wave) and [Cp2Ti]+ (second wave) in analogy to previous studies.11 Several features of the CVs obtained upon addition of H2O deserve closer attention: CV of Zn-reduced [Cp2TiCl2] a) 0.1 V s−1, b) 1 V s−1) in 0.2 M TBAPF6/THF with 0 (black), 10 (green), and 100 equivalents (red) of added H2O. First, in the presence of H2O the peak current ratio of the two oxidation waves remains essentially independent of the sweep rate, suggesting that [Cp2Ti]+ derived species are present in Zn-reduced solutions in THF with added H2O. This is not the case without H2O.11 It should be noted that not even the addition of the strongly coordinating HMPA (HMPA=hexamethyl phosphoramide) to Zn-reduced solutions of [Cp2TiCl2] results in the generation of solvated [Cp2Ti]+.12 Thus, the solvation of chloride ion through hydrogen bonding by H2O is essential for generation of the titanocene cation. Second, the first oxidation wave of Zn-reduced [Cp2TiCl2] in the presence of H2O does not consist of two individual processes (oxidation of [Cp2TiCl] and [(Cp2TiCl)2]) because no second oxidation peak appears at higher sweep rates.11a These results indicate that [(Cp2TiCl)2] dissociates into monomeric species upon addition of H2O. Third, the oxidation wave of the [Cp2Ti]+ derived species is shifted to more negative values upon addition of H2O. For 10 equivalents of H2O this shift is 50 and 80 mV suggesting the formation of [Cp2Ti(OH2)]+. In the presence of 100 equivalents of H2O shifts of 130 and 180 mV were observed. This change suggests the coordination of a further molecule of water and hence at the presence of [Cp2Ti(OH2)2]+. Finally, the peak potential of the first oxidation wave does not change upon addition of H2O. This implies that H2O does not bind to the Ti nucleus of [Cp2TiCl] because in that case a noticeably more negative peak potential shifted by 50–80 mV in analogy to [Cp2Ti(OH2)]+ should have been observed. The interaction of H2O with [Cp2TiCl] was studied by computational means next. The geometries were optimized at the BP86/TZVP13, 14 level of theory using density fitting. Stationary points were characterized by analyzing the hessian matrix.15 The energies were obtained by B3LYP-d/def2-TZVPP16 single-point calculations using COSMO17 with ε=7.6 including the zero-point energy correction of the BP86 level. In Scheme 1 the behavior of [Cp2TiCl] in the presence of H2O and THF is summarized. If specific interactions of H2O with THF are excluded, the two structures 2 a and 2 b with hydrogen bonding of H2O to the TiCl bond are identified as minima. Structure 2 b is more favorable than 2 a because of a dipole–dipole interaction between O and Ti. However, the complexation energy is far too weak for a covalent TiO bond to be present as postulated in 1. With the inclusion of specific interactions of H2O and THF, the situation becomes slightly more complex. H2O and 2 equivalents of THF form a hydrogen-bonded complex with a ΔE of −7.8 kcal mol−1. Both hydrogen bonds are of equal strength (−3.9 kcal mol−1). Based on these values it is clear that hydrogen bonding in 2 a is too weak to persist when specific THF interactions are included. For 2 b, the inclusion of H2O⋅2 THF leads to a noticeably more favorable binding (−7.4 kcal mol−1 vs. −17.4 kcal mol−1). This change is mainly because of the increase of negative charge on the O of H2O as a result of hydrogen bonding which leads to a stronger interaction with Ti. However, note that an interaction between an α-H of both THF molecules and Cl also contributes to the stability of 2 b⋅2 THF (see the Supporting Information for the structure). However, even the binding of 2 b⋅2 THF is characteristic of a dipole–dipole interaction and not of a TiO bond. Computational results on the complexation of [Cp2TiCl] by H2O with and without THF (B3LYP-d/def2-TZVPP). COSMO17 with ε=7.6. The computational investigation of the formation of cationic titanocenes in the presence of H2O is summarized in Scheme 2. For our study it is important to recall that Zn-reduced solutions of [Cp2TiCl2] contain ZnCl2. This strong Lewis acid makes the heterolytic cleavage of the TiCl bond more favorable through the formation of ZnCl42−. Even so, the cleavage of the TiCl bonds is highly endothermic because of charge separation. Computational results on the formation of cationic titanocene(III) complexes in the presence of ZnCl2 (B3LYP-d/def2-TZVPP). COSMO17 with ε=7.6. For the solvation of the titanocene cations, the inclusion of THF in the mechanistic analysis must not be neglected. Although, the complexation of a single H2O is exothermic (−25.0 kcal mol−1 per Ti), the complexation of the first H2O⋅2 THF is much more favorable (−41.4 kcal mol−1 per Ti). Binding of the second equivalent of H2O⋅2 THF is less exothermic (−19.7 kcal mol−1 per Ti) but more advantageous than binding a single THF alone (−16.4 kcal mol−1 per Ti). Therefore, the reaction of 4 H2O⋅2 THF with 2 [Cp2TiCl] and ZnCl2 results in an exothermic formation of solvated titanocene cations (−19.1 kcal mol−1 per Ti). The formation of 3 b⋅4 THF will become even more exothermic when solvation of ZnCl42− is included in the analysis. While, the calculation of the complete solvation sphere of ZnCl42− is beyond the scope of this study, the validity of our assumption is highlighted by the fact that the interaction of ZnCl42− with 6 equivalents of H2O is exothermic (−30.9 kcal mol−1). The computed bond dissociation energies (BDEs) of 2 b⋅THF, 3 a⋅THF, and 3 b⋅3 THF (52.3, 64.7, and 53.5 kcal mol−1) are summarized in Scheme 3. We propose that a dissociation of one THF from the fully hydrogen-bonded species is necessary for an unhindered backside attack of a radical on H. As expected this dissociation of THF is especially difficult for the most Lewis acidic 3 a⋅2 THF. The difference in BDE between 3 a⋅THF and 3 b⋅3 THF is due to the better stabilization of the TiIV in 7 through complexation. All the species investigated constitute more efficient HAT reagents than traditionally employed cyclohexadienes, stannanes, silanes, and germanes.1 Bond dissociation energies (BDE) of 2 b⋅THF, 3 a⋅THF, and 3 b⋅3 THF by DFT calculations (B3LYP-d/def2-TZVPP) with COSMO17 (ε=7.6). Taking all of our experimental and computational results into account, it seems clear that addition of H2O to Zn-reduced [Cp2TiCl2] does not lead to the formation of 1. The ESEEM spectra show that at a high concentration of H2O, the chloride ligand is removed from the TiIII center. The HYSCORE spectra demonstrate that with 10 and 100 equivalents of H2O identical species are obtained. Both findings imply that even at low concentrations of H2O no 1 is formed. This conclusion is supported by the CV measurements that also preclude a coordination of H2O to a TiIII center with a chloride ligand. Instead, the shifts of the oxidation waves of the titanocene cations demonstrate the presence of water-ligated [Cp2Ti]+ as in 3 a and 3 b. These experimental results are supported by the calculations that suggest that the formation of hydrated titanocene cations is more favorable than the formation of 1 even in the presence of a low number of equivalents of H2O. Moreover, it has been demonstrated that the inclusion of THF is essential for the understanding of the structures and relative stabilities of the complexes involved. It should be noted that the previous computational study3c did not consider the possibility of cationic structures. Moreover, the effects of specific interactions of H2O with THF were neglected. None of the earlier experimental data provided direct structural data for the existence of 1. A UV/Vis study on the interaction of H2O with [(Cp2TiCl)2]3c has demonstrated that the addition of more than 10 equivalents of H2O results in dissociation of [(Cp2TiCl)2]. The resulting Ti species were not characterized further, though. While the observation of the dissociation is in agreement with our data, our EPR and CV measurements provide evidence for the cationic species 3. In a kinetic study, the rate constants for HAT from “[Cp2TiCl]-complexed H2O” to alkyl radicals were reported.18 However, rate constants do not provide any structural information. Moreover, the measured rate constants are lower than those of stannanes even though the BDEs of the titanocene-derived species are substantially lower. This discrepancy can be readily explained with our results because an unfavorable loss of THF from 3 a⋅2 THF and 3 b⋅4 THF is required for HAT (Scheme 3). This leads to a low concentration of the active HAT reagent and hence a reduction of the observed rate constant for HAT. The mechanism of H2O activation by Zn-reduced [Cp2TiCl2] is fundamentally different from that of MeOH activation by boranes.2 This is due to the inability of boranes to form cationic species. Thus, boranes react with alcohols by associative processes to form classical Lewis base adducts. For these species the loss of alkyl radicals during HAT is essential.2 Our mechanistic proposal for the generation of TiIII-based HAT reagents and the HAT itself should be valid for the activation of other molecules and electron-transfer reagents,19 also. This mechanism opens fascinating perspectives for the development of even more efficient and sustainable reagents. Cationic low-valent metal complexes, not necessarily derived from titanium,20 with donor ligands containing OH or NH bonds should give such HAT reagents. Amides and especially peptides or even proteins are prime candidates for such activation towards HAT." @default.
- W2113803424 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2113803424 creator A5002422377 @default.
- W2113803424 creator A5006251012 @default.
- W2113803424 creator A5025032308 @default.
- W2113803424 creator A5052356598 @default.
- W2113803424 creator A5062545081 @default.
- W2113803424 creator A5063277995 @default.
- W2113803424 creator A5081788489 @default.
- W2113803424 date "2012-02-15" @default.
- W2113803424 modified "2023-10-18" @default.
- W2113803424 title "H2O Activation for Hydrogen-Atom Transfer: Correct Structures and Revised Mechanisms" @default.
- W2113803424 cites W1963683620 @default.
- W2113803424 cites W1971849813 @default.
- W2113803424 cites W1971988873 @default.
- W2113803424 cites W1984874697 @default.
- W2113803424 cites W1986715943 @default.
- W2113803424 cites W1988091937 @default.
- W2113803424 cites W1997585837 @default.
- W2113803424 cites W2001218198 @default.
- W2113803424 cites W2008851509 @default.
- W2113803424 cites W2011727400 @default.
- W2113803424 cites W2016570326 @default.
- W2113803424 cites W2023271753 @default.
- W2113803424 cites W2026094502 @default.
- W2113803424 cites W2030687437 @default.
- W2113803424 cites W2034571753 @default.
- W2113803424 cites W2038442961 @default.
- W2113803424 cites W2039560945 @default.
- W2113803424 cites W2041102942 @default.
- W2113803424 cites W2041862870 @default.
- W2113803424 cites W2043004601 @default.
- W2113803424 cites W2043405319 @default.
- W2113803424 cites W2044591029 @default.
- W2113803424 cites W2045606763 @default.
- W2113803424 cites W2045862135 @default.
- W2113803424 cites W2048328398 @default.
- W2113803424 cites W2051997051 @default.
- W2113803424 cites W2055563809 @default.
- W2113803424 cites W2058210956 @default.
- W2113803424 cites W2066275583 @default.
- W2113803424 cites W2069985656 @default.
- W2113803424 cites W2077729746 @default.
- W2113803424 cites W2086957099 @default.
- W2113803424 cites W2093181399 @default.
- W2113803424 cites W2093441359 @default.
- W2113803424 cites W2103005634 @default.
- W2113803424 cites W2116150440 @default.
- W2113803424 cites W2140886907 @default.
- W2113803424 cites W2141066544 @default.
- W2113803424 cites W2143981217 @default.
- W2113803424 cites W2145528941 @default.
- W2113803424 cites W2147303166 @default.
- W2113803424 cites W2154256398 @default.
- W2113803424 cites W2324978346 @default.
- W2113803424 cites W2953166183 @default.
- W2113803424 cites W4254430466 @default.
- W2113803424 doi "https://doi.org/10.1002/anie.201107556" @default.
- W2113803424 hasPubMedId "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22337565" @default.
- W2113803424 hasPublicationYear "2012" @default.
- W2113803424 type Work @default.
- W2113803424 sameAs 2113803424 @default.
- W2113803424 citedByCount "68" @default.
- W2113803424 countsByYear W21138034242012 @default.
- W2113803424 countsByYear W21138034242013 @default.
- W2113803424 countsByYear W21138034242014 @default.
- W2113803424 countsByYear W21138034242015 @default.
- W2113803424 countsByYear W21138034242016 @default.
- W2113803424 countsByYear W21138034242017 @default.
- W2113803424 countsByYear W21138034242018 @default.
- W2113803424 countsByYear W21138034242019 @default.
- W2113803424 countsByYear W21138034242020 @default.
- W2113803424 countsByYear W21138034242021 @default.
- W2113803424 countsByYear W21138034242022 @default.
- W2113803424 countsByYear W21138034242023 @default.
- W2113803424 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2113803424 hasAuthorship W2113803424A5002422377 @default.
- W2113803424 hasAuthorship W2113803424A5006251012 @default.
- W2113803424 hasAuthorship W2113803424A5025032308 @default.
- W2113803424 hasAuthorship W2113803424A5052356598 @default.
- W2113803424 hasAuthorship W2113803424A5062545081 @default.
- W2113803424 hasAuthorship W2113803424A5063277995 @default.
- W2113803424 hasAuthorship W2113803424A5081788489 @default.
- W2113803424 hasConcept C149635348 @default.
- W2113803424 hasConcept C178790620 @default.
- W2113803424 hasConcept C185592680 @default.
- W2113803424 hasConcept C2776640939 @default.
- W2113803424 hasConcept C2781311116 @default.
- W2113803424 hasConcept C41008148 @default.
- W2113803424 hasConcept C58312451 @default.
- W2113803424 hasConceptScore W2113803424C149635348 @default.
- W2113803424 hasConceptScore W2113803424C178790620 @default.
- W2113803424 hasConceptScore W2113803424C185592680 @default.
- W2113803424 hasConceptScore W2113803424C2776640939 @default.
- W2113803424 hasConceptScore W2113803424C2781311116 @default.
- W2113803424 hasConceptScore W2113803424C41008148 @default.
- W2113803424 hasConceptScore W2113803424C58312451 @default.
- W2113803424 hasIssue "13" @default.