Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2121978552> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2121978552 endingPage "137" @default.
- W2121978552 startingPage "107" @default.
- W2121978552 abstract "In order to survive and reproduce, individual animals need to navigate through a multidimensional utility landscape in a near-optimal way. There is little doubt that the behaviourally more advanced species can bring cognitive competencies to bear on this difficult task. Among the cognitive abilities that are helpful in this context is transitive inference. This is typically the competency to derive the conclusion B>D from the premises A>B, B>C, C>D and D>E that imply the series A>B>C>D>E. In transitive inference tests used with humans, the letters stand for verbal items and the inequality symbols stand for a relational expression. To investigate analogous competencies in non-human animals a non-verbal form of the task is used. The premise pairs are converted into a multiple instrumental discrimination task A+B-, B+C-, C+D- and D+E-, where the letters stand for non-verbal stimuli and the plus and minus symbols indicate that choices of the corresponding stimuli either lead to a reward or to a penalty. When these training pairs are adequately discriminated, transitive responding is tested with intermittent presentations of the novel pair B∘D∘, where the circles indicate that responses to the stimuli are not reinforced. Using variants of this basic conditioning task it has been shown that pigeons, rats, squirrel-monkeys, macaques, chimpanzees, young children, older children and adult humans commonly reveal transitive preferences for B over D. Several theories have been proposed to explain this transitive behaviour. The evidence supporting these various models is reviewed. It is shown that the learning of the premises normally brings about a choice and reinforcement biasing and balancing process that can account for transitive responding. It is argued that a very simple algebraic learning model can satisfactorily simulate many of the results obtained in transitivity experiments, including some produced by human subjects who in principle, could have been applying rational logical rules. It is demonstrated that a value transfer mechanism also assumed to explain transitive responding, is in fact, a real phenomenon based on classical conditioning. However, it is argued that it mostly plays a minor role in transitive responding. It is shown that the algebraic learning model can be easily converted into a neural network model exhibiting an equivalent performance. The model can also be modified to cope with the surprising finding that a proportion of human individuals and a few animals subjects learn to discriminate the premise pairs, but nevertheless fail to respond transitively to the conclusion pair. This modification can simulate the results of experiments using non-linear, in particular circular, relational structures. The evolution of transitive responding is considered within the framework of ecosocial demands and neurobiological constraints. It is concluded that, in agreement with a preadaptation (exaptation) evolutionary origin, it seems to involve little beyond the capacity to learn multiple stimulus discriminations." @default.
- W2121978552 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2121978552 creator A5025516966 @default.
- W2121978552 creator A5042135299 @default.
- W2121978552 date "1998-02-01" @default.
- W2121978552 modified "2023-09-27" @default.
- W2121978552 title "Transitive responding in animals and humans: Exaptation rather than adaptation?" @default.
- W2121978552 cites W1560975049 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W1963729181 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W1965721093 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W1967155622 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W1968205992 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W1975140269 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W1979654182 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W1981605135 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W1992576435 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W1999287391 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W1999349836 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W1999913621 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W2007502801 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W2008575862 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W2018027839 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W2019106215 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W2021363819 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W2022967005 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W2025372192 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W2027032350 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W2028608595 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W2030760286 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W2030830933 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W2037704866 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W2042599203 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W2043168242 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W2045516607 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W2051639574 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W2053973143 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W2056081222 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W2059236159 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W2059929438 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W2060508874 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W2062189980 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W2065903004 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W2067864623 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W2073913380 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W2077118121 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W2080826715 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W2084390283 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W2084828926 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W2088247534 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W2090232391 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W2092506395 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W2093883985 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W2095139416 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W2098256464 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W2106533942 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W2112366700 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W2112563472 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W2119743323 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W2135886642 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W2144018723 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W2153198937 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W2247506020 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W2990606589 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W4205690792 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W4240701545 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W4241203597 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W4241303515 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W4249218298 @default.
- W2121978552 cites W4312729599 @default.
- W2121978552 doi "https://doi.org/10.1016/s0376-6357(97)00072-7" @default.
- W2121978552 hasPubMedId "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24897458" @default.
- W2121978552 hasPublicationYear "1998" @default.
- W2121978552 type Work @default.
- W2121978552 sameAs 2121978552 @default.
- W2121978552 citedByCount "67" @default.
- W2121978552 countsByYear W21219785522012 @default.
- W2121978552 countsByYear W21219785522013 @default.
- W2121978552 countsByYear W21219785522014 @default.
- W2121978552 countsByYear W21219785522015 @default.
- W2121978552 countsByYear W21219785522018 @default.
- W2121978552 countsByYear W21219785522019 @default.
- W2121978552 countsByYear W21219785522020 @default.
- W2121978552 countsByYear W21219785522021 @default.
- W2121978552 countsByYear W21219785522022 @default.
- W2121978552 countsByYear W21219785522023 @default.
- W2121978552 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2121978552 hasAuthorship W2121978552A5025516966 @default.
- W2121978552 hasAuthorship W2121978552A5042135299 @default.
- W2121978552 hasBestOaLocation W21219785522 @default.
- W2121978552 hasConcept C114614502 @default.
- W2121978552 hasConcept C138496976 @default.
- W2121978552 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W2121978552 hasConcept C139807058 @default.
- W2121978552 hasConcept C151730666 @default.
- W2121978552 hasConcept C15744967 @default.
- W2121978552 hasConcept C162324750 @default.
- W2121978552 hasConcept C169760540 @default.
- W2121978552 hasConcept C169900460 @default.