Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W212944650> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W212944650 abstract "In a democracy we have to accept that decision processes are participatory in the way that they involve many stakeholders in the decision, not only experts. This is important because most of the decisions cannot only be based on facts but also values have to be included. It is thus important to have transparent information around the consequences of different alternatives and the concept of risk is here one of the most difficult concepts to evaluate. This project has focused on a case study around the location of Loudden oil terminal in the central part of Stockholm. This case study was chosen because of its complexity regarding the decision-making process and stakeholder interests and because risk is an important parameter in the decision of the location of the oil harbour. The case study shows that land use planning is a delicate trade off between economic and social development and protection of environment and between the interests of different stakeholders. This planning process requires that information around risks of different types can be evaluated and presented in a transparent way for all the stakeholders involved. Risk is only one parameter among many in the decision process, but it is often an important one and one which is difficult to grasp. One of the experiences in the project is that many of the stakeholders including politicians and the public, taking part in the planning processes have a consequence based approach more than a risk-based approach. This means that they do not take the low probabilities for mayor accidents into account but merely focus on possible worst case scenarios and if those can be handled. The safety reports for the installations however have a much more risk-based approach relying on different methods for estimating probabilities for accident scenarios. This makes it very difficult to communicate and agree upon the results from these safety reports which are actually the basis for decisions around the acceptance of the installations. Parts of the existing legislation also includes demand for estimation of probabilities or frequencies for accidents, but no recommendations how to calculate it. In connection to this there are also proposals to use acceptance criteria e.g. societal risk and individual risk in order to facilitate evaluation both for the companies and for the authorities. This project shows that this development is very doubtful because of the inherent large uncertainties in the estimation and also because of the problem to communicate the results in participatory decision processes. As a result of this project we therefore argue that there should be a more consequence based approach for accidents and worst case scenarios in the safety reports where ‘real’ worst case scenarios are described. These can then be communicated to the stakeholders and also to the rescue service in order to decide if these worst case scenarios can be handled in a proper way and also how the risk can be reduced by robust barriers and emergency actions. The report should also include an extended summary which in a transparent way can communicate the results to all involved stakeholders. There should also be an overview of major accidents which have occurred internationally at similar installations. From this project the recommendation for further research is that more detailed examples of guidelines for how to develop more consequence based approach for accidents and worst case scenarios should be developed both for industrial sites and transport of dangerous substances. These developed examples should then be discussed among a wide stakeholder group. The result from the training package shows that this type of training course where different stakeholders have to argue from different standpoints is very valuable in order to widen the horizons and understanding different views on the concept of risk. There is not one objective way to evaluate risk, but many depending on values and preferences." @default.
- W212944650 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W212944650 creator A5031765941 @default.
- W212944650 creator A5058840978 @default.
- W212944650 date "2008-01-01" @default.
- W212944650 modified "2023-09-27" @default.
- W212944650 title "Methods for Risk Assessment within the Framework of Sustainable Development" @default.
- W212944650 cites W1479866819 @default.
- W212944650 cites W1493059013 @default.
- W212944650 cites W1501675187 @default.
- W212944650 cites W1544945890 @default.
- W212944650 cites W1564584923 @default.
- W212944650 cites W1566008008 @default.
- W212944650 cites W1594383524 @default.
- W212944650 cites W1871588830 @default.
- W212944650 cites W1981019827 @default.
- W212944650 cites W1993302116 @default.
- W212944650 cites W2009674321 @default.
- W212944650 cites W2010420648 @default.
- W212944650 cites W2033902127 @default.
- W212944650 cites W2053692284 @default.
- W212944650 cites W2081577327 @default.
- W212944650 cites W2095214895 @default.
- W212944650 cites W2104986247 @default.
- W212944650 cites W2113246934 @default.
- W212944650 cites W2186826906 @default.
- W212944650 cites W2367562986 @default.
- W212944650 cites W256349250 @default.
- W212944650 cites W264085030 @default.
- W212944650 cites W293215161 @default.
- W212944650 cites W297902537 @default.
- W212944650 cites W303164577 @default.
- W212944650 cites W3095323615 @default.
- W212944650 cites W313812222 @default.
- W212944650 cites W403980054 @default.
- W212944650 cites W433031618 @default.
- W212944650 cites W600205172 @default.
- W212944650 hasPublicationYear "2008" @default.
- W212944650 type Work @default.
- W212944650 sameAs 212944650 @default.
- W212944650 citedByCount "0" @default.
- W212944650 crossrefType "book" @default.
- W212944650 hasAuthorship W212944650A5031765941 @default.
- W212944650 hasAuthorship W212944650A5058840978 @default.
- W212944650 hasConcept C111919701 @default.
- W212944650 hasConcept C112930515 @default.
- W212944650 hasConcept C122308676 @default.
- W212944650 hasConcept C127413603 @default.
- W212944650 hasConcept C136764020 @default.
- W212944650 hasConcept C144133560 @default.
- W212944650 hasConcept C162853370 @default.
- W212944650 hasConcept C171268870 @default.
- W212944650 hasConcept C17744445 @default.
- W212944650 hasConcept C195094911 @default.
- W212944650 hasConcept C199360897 @default.
- W212944650 hasConcept C201305675 @default.
- W212944650 hasConcept C203663800 @default.
- W212944650 hasConcept C2778813691 @default.
- W212944650 hasConcept C39549134 @default.
- W212944650 hasConcept C41008148 @default.
- W212944650 hasConcept C539667460 @default.
- W212944650 hasConcept C98045186 @default.
- W212944650 hasConceptScore W212944650C111919701 @default.
- W212944650 hasConceptScore W212944650C112930515 @default.
- W212944650 hasConceptScore W212944650C122308676 @default.
- W212944650 hasConceptScore W212944650C127413603 @default.
- W212944650 hasConceptScore W212944650C136764020 @default.
- W212944650 hasConceptScore W212944650C144133560 @default.
- W212944650 hasConceptScore W212944650C162853370 @default.
- W212944650 hasConceptScore W212944650C171268870 @default.
- W212944650 hasConceptScore W212944650C17744445 @default.
- W212944650 hasConceptScore W212944650C195094911 @default.
- W212944650 hasConceptScore W212944650C199360897 @default.
- W212944650 hasConceptScore W212944650C201305675 @default.
- W212944650 hasConceptScore W212944650C203663800 @default.
- W212944650 hasConceptScore W212944650C2778813691 @default.
- W212944650 hasConceptScore W212944650C39549134 @default.
- W212944650 hasConceptScore W212944650C41008148 @default.
- W212944650 hasConceptScore W212944650C539667460 @default.
- W212944650 hasConceptScore W212944650C98045186 @default.
- W212944650 hasLocation W2129446501 @default.
- W212944650 hasOpenAccess W212944650 @default.
- W212944650 hasPrimaryLocation W2129446501 @default.
- W212944650 hasRelatedWork W1183944030 @default.
- W212944650 hasRelatedWork W1491727837 @default.
- W212944650 hasRelatedWork W1549299336 @default.
- W212944650 hasRelatedWork W185944475 @default.
- W212944650 hasRelatedWork W1975404444 @default.
- W212944650 hasRelatedWork W1976689009 @default.
- W212944650 hasRelatedWork W2002381555 @default.
- W212944650 hasRelatedWork W2062511876 @default.
- W212944650 hasRelatedWork W2069402859 @default.
- W212944650 hasRelatedWork W2075193981 @default.
- W212944650 hasRelatedWork W2397073180 @default.
- W212944650 hasRelatedWork W2530353356 @default.
- W212944650 hasRelatedWork W2550029289 @default.
- W212944650 hasRelatedWork W2570372038 @default.
- W212944650 hasRelatedWork W2589900097 @default.
- W212944650 hasRelatedWork W280548034 @default.
- W212944650 hasRelatedWork W2937176323 @default.