Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2149332308> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2149332308 endingPage "615" @default.
- W2149332308 startingPage "607" @default.
- W2149332308 abstract "<h3>Introduction</h3> Training procedural skills in GI endoscopy once focused on threshold numbers. As threshold numbers poorly reflect individual competence, the focus gradually shifts towards a more individual approach. Tools to assess and document individual learning progress are being developed and incorporated in dedicated training curricula. However, there is a lack of consensus and training guidelines differ worldwide, which reflects uncertainties on optimal set-up of a training programme. <h3>Aims</h3> The primary aim of this systematic review was to evaluate the currently available literature for the use of training and assessment methods in GI endoscopy. Second, we aimed to identify the role of simulator-based training as well as the value of continuous competence assessment in patient-based training. Third, we aimed to propose a structured training curriculum based on the presented evidence. <h3>Methods</h3> A literature search was carried out in the available medical and educational literature databases. The results were systematically reviewed and studies were included using a predefined protocol with independent assessment by two reviewers and a final consensus round. <h3>Results</h3> The literature search yielded 5846 studies. Ninety-four relevant studies on simulators, assessment methods, learning curves and training programmes for GI endoscopy met the inclusion criteria. Twenty-seven studies on simulator validation were included. Good validity was demonstrated for four simulators. Twenty-three studies reported on simulator training and learning curves, including 17 randomised control trials. Increased performance on a virtual reality (VR) simulator was shown in all studies. Improved performance in patient-based assessment was demonstrated in 14 studies. Four studies reported on the use of simulators for assessment of competence levels. Current simulators lack the discriminative power to determine competence levels in patient-based endoscopy. Eight out of 14 studies on colonoscopy, endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography and endosonography reported on learning curves in patient-based endoscopy and proved the value of this approach for measuring performance. Ten studies explored the numbers needed to gain competence, but the proposed thresholds varied widely between them. Five out of nine studies describing the development and evaluation of assessment tools for GI endoscopy provided insight into the performance of endoscopists. Five out of seven studies proved that intense training programmes result in good performance. <h3>Conclusions</h3> The use of validated VR simulators in the early training setting accelerates the learning of practical skills. Learning curves are valuable for the continuous assessment of performance and are more relevant than threshold numbers. Future research will strengthen these conclusions by evaluating simulation-based as well as patient-based training in GI endoscopy. A complete curriculum with the assessment of competence throughout training needs to be developed for all GI endoscopy procedures." @default.
- W2149332308 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2149332308 creator A5005200745 @default.
- W2149332308 creator A5023392462 @default.
- W2149332308 creator A5052418311 @default.
- W2149332308 creator A5081503066 @default.
- W2149332308 date "2015-01-30" @default.
- W2149332308 modified "2023-09-29" @default.
- W2149332308 title "Training and competence assessment in GI endoscopy: a systematic review" @default.
- W2149332308 cites W119452684 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W1709335561 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W1964153991 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W1971923609 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W1971999737 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W1973748320 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W1974332675 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W1976802313 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W1978821202 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W1978972307 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W1981264331 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W1981412450 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W1985105226 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W1986630690 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W1986716531 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W1987997564 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W1988333055 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W1988433398 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W1992126734 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W1992447778 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W1992740667 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W1993354691 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W1993772752 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W1996502381 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2001400823 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2005707832 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2006031796 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2008346921 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2010007906 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2012181597 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2013786343 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2013828036 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2017255460 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2017941828 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2019123043 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2020853270 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2025620911 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2031062167 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2031888003 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2032333625 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2034617230 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2038321406 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2038717668 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2040835969 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2042411935 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2047185344 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2047439231 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2049167607 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2049672846 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2050185588 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2051705557 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2053972090 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2057792911 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2060575582 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2062403205 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2064249883 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2064931846 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2067551331 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2068291857 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2070399399 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2071607146 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2073037779 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2075360557 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2076203580 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2078440456 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2084346393 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2084909945 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2085225909 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2085363724 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2087861732 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2092676295 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2097627998 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2110578542 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2127255315 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2127436045 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2128837723 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2131239719 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2137229802 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2141558254 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2151162881 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2154867989 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2157739896 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2158773730 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2160423991 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2161266524 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2161642399 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2162740361 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2165010366 @default.
- W2149332308 cites W2171507790 @default.