Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2156566037> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2156566037 endingPage "162" @default.
- W2156566037 startingPage "95" @default.
- W2156566037 abstract "Few psychological concepts evoke simultaneously as much fascination and misunderstanding as psychopathic personality, or psychopathy. Typically, individuals with psychopathy are misconceived as fundamentally different from the rest of humanity and as inalterably dangerous. Popular portrayals of are diverse and conflicting, ranging from uncommonly impulsive and violent criminal offenders to corporate figures who callously and skillfully manuever their way to the highest rungs of the social ladder. Despite this diversity of perspectives, a single well- validated measure of psychopathy, the Psychopathy Checklist-Revised (PCL-R; Hare, 1991; 2003), has come to dominate clinical and legal practice over recent years. The items of the PCL-R cover two basic content domains--an interpersonal-affective domain that encompasses core traits such as callousness and manipulativeness and an antisocial domain that entails disinhibition and chronic antisocial behavior. In most Western countries, the PCL-R and its derivatives are routinely applied to inform legal decisions about criminal offenders that hinge upon issues of dangerousness and treatability. In fact, clinicians in many cases choose the PCL-R over other, purpose-built risk-assessment tools to inform their opinions about what sentence offenders should receive, whether they should be indefinitely incarcerated as a dangerous offender or sexually violent predator, or whether they should be transferred from juvenile to adult court. The PCL-R has played an extraordinarily generative role in research and practice over the past three decades--so much so, that concerns have been raised that the measure has become equated in many minds with the psychopathy construct itself (Skeem & Cooke 2010a). Equating a measure with a construct may impede scientific progress because it disregards the basic principle that measures always imperfectly operationalize constructs and that our understanding of a construct is ever-evolving (Cronbach & Meehl, 1955). In virtually any domain, the construct-validation process is an incremental one that entails shifts in conceptualization and measurement at successive points in the process of clarifying the nature and boundaries of a hypothetical entity. Despite the predominance of the PCL-R measurement model in recent years, vigorous scientific debates have continued regarding what psychopathy is and what it is not. Should adaptive, positive-adjustment features (on one hand) and criminal and antisocial behaviors (on the other) be considered essential features of the construct? Are anxious and emotionally reactive people that are identified as psychopaths by the PCL-R and other measures truly psychopathic? More fundamentally, is psychopathy a unitary entity (i.e., a global syndrome with a discrete underlying cause), or is it rather a configuration of several distinguishable, but intersecting trait dimensions? Although these and other controversies remain unresolved, theory and research on the PCL-R and alternative measures have begun to clarify the scope and boundaries of the psychopathy construct. In the current comprehensive review, we provide an integrative descriptive framework--the triarchic model--to help the reader make sense of differing conceptualizations. The essence of this model is that alternative perspectives on psychopathy emphasize, to varying degrees, three distinct observable (phenotypic) characteristics: boldness (or fearless dominance), meanness, and disinhibition. The triarchic framework is helpful for clarifying and reconciling seemingly disparate historical conceptions, modern operationalizations, and contemporary research programs on psychopathy. Our review addresses what psychopathy is, whether variants or subtypes exist (i.e., primary and secondary, unsuccessful and successful), the sorts of causal influences that contribute to psychopathy, how early in development psychopathy can validly be identified, and how psychopathy relates to future criminal behavior and treatment outcomes. Despite controversies and nuances inherent in each of these topics, the current state of scientific knowledge bears clear implications for public policy. Policy domains range from whether psychopathic individuals should be held responsible for their criminal actions to whether employers should screen job candidates for tendencies toward psychopathy. In many cases, the findings we review converge to challenge common assumptions that underpin modern applications of psychopathy measures and to call for cautions in their use. For example, contemporary measures of psychopathy, including the PCL-R, appear to evidence no special powers in predicting violence or other crime. Instead, they are about as predictive as purpose-built violence-risk-assessment tools, perhaps because they assess many of the same risk factors as those broader-band tools. Specifically, the PCL-R and other psychopathy measures derive most of their predictive utility from their Factor 2 assessment of antisocial and disinhibitory tendencies; the Factor 1 component of such measures, reflecting interpersonal and affective features more specific to psychopathy, play at best a small predictive role. Similarly, current measures of psychopathy do not appear to moderate the effects of treatment on violent and other criminal behavior. That is, an increasing number of studies suggest that psychopathic individuals are not uniquely hopeless cases who should be disqualified from treatment, but instead are general high-risk cases who need to be targeted for intensive treatment to maximize public safety. Misunderstandings about the criminal propensities and treatability of individuals achieving high scores on measures like the PCL-R have been perpetuated by professionals who interpret such high scores in a stereotypic manner, without considering nuances or issues of heterogeneity. A key message of our review is that classical psychopathy, whether measured by the PCL-R or other measures, is not monolithic; instead, it represents a constellation of multiple traits that may include, in varying degrees, the phenotypic domains of boldness, meanness, and disinhibition. Measures such as the PCL-R that do not directly assess features of low anxiety, fearlessness, or boldness more broadly tend to identify heterogeneous subgroups of individuals as psychopathic. As a consequence, efforts to apply one-size-fits-all public policies to psychopathic individuals may be doomed to failure. In aggregrate, these conclusions may help to shed light on what psychopathy is, and what it is not, and to guide policy interventions directed toward improved public health and public safety. Language: en" @default.
- W2156566037 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2156566037 creator A5000791222 @default.
- W2156566037 creator A5003519547 @default.
- W2156566037 creator A5006807832 @default.
- W2156566037 creator A5008385014 @default.
- W2156566037 date "2011-12-01" @default.
- W2156566037 modified "2023-10-16" @default.
- W2156566037 title "Psychopathic Personality" @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1491166721 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1499753847 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1520786107 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1527812011 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1558805034 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1578367135 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1667024897 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W176634084 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W192813600 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W194754083 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1964218847 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1964640465 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1964810226 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1965112672 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1965145944 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1965368844 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1965384586 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1966599406 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1967661203 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1969411568 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1970178118 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1970443848 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1972095764 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1973614326 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1973988709 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1974121081 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1974553160 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1976774247 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1977301793 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1977840965 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1977927756 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1978334959 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1980064872 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1980497200 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1980655158 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1981072410 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1981249947 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1982170598 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1982994480 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1983008944 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1983798824 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1984030600 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1984674146 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1984718322 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1985657523 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1985801230 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1986584821 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1986773418 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1987024005 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1987687402 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1989788150 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1989950118 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1990434315 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1991500749 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1991540992 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1992330947 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1993028529 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1995355682 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1995468441 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1996234777 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1996970619 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1997237487 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1997372835 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1997578931 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1999048656 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W1999973404 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W2000936081 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W2001241885 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W2001647483 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W2002053479 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W2002501515 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W2002751243 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W2002950181 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W2004421654 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W2005395941 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W2005468741 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W2007260514 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W2007667931 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W2008197013 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W2008728054 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W2009449617 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W2010028315 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W2010311549 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W2012186378 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W2012785411 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W2013536305 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W2013758811 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W2013951890 @default.
- W2156566037 cites W2014231459 @default.