Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2162662783> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2162662783 endingPage "58" @default.
- W2162662783 startingPage "1" @default.
- W2162662783 abstract "The theme of this article is the importance – and the many causes – of lowlevel equilibrium “traps.” Rosenstein-Rodan pointed out that spillovers may cause the return to an activity to increase with the number of others who undertake that activity. If spillovers are strong enough, both lowand high-level equilibria are possible, with no tendency of market forces to lead from the worse to the better state of affairs. This article shows how modern economic theory broadened our view of the sources of spillovers that could lead to with low innovation and inefficient institutions. Evidence from China is consistent with local underdevelopment traps. The article argues for an “ecological” perspective on development, where the influences from others in one’s environment are a critical determinant of outcomes. This perspective provides the basis for the distinction between deep interventions, which change underlying forces, and interventions, which do not. Karla Hoff is a research economist at the World Bank. This article draws on Hoff and Stiglitz (forthcoming). The author would like to thank Irma Adelman for helpful comments, and Abhijit Banerjee, Arnold Harberger, Gustav Ranis, Debraj Ray, and Joseph Stiglitz for discussions of the issues raised in this article. OUTLINE 1. The place of coordination failures in modern economic theory Neoclassical theory and the Coase theorem Institutional outside the 'straitjacket' of neoclassical Path dependence A radically broadened view of externalities and public goods Ecological economics 2. Examples of underdevelopment traps A low R&D trap Self-sustaining institutions Big Push theories of industrialization 3. An econometric test: Local poverty traps in rural China 4. Perspectives on policy Coordinating good equilibria Sequencing of policy reforms A word of caution: Deep versus shallow interventions 5. Conclusion Mathematical appendix Table and Figures Table 1. Old and new views of externalities and public goods Table 2 Taxonomy of models with complementarities. Figure 1. Multiple equilibria (with corner solutions) in the level of enforcement Figure 2. Multiple equilibria in a model with symmetric agents Figure 3. Multiple equilibria in the fraction of homeowners Figure 4. Different individual capital stocks may have the same marginal productivity Figure 5. Minimum levels of county wealth in China to assure rising household consumption given household wealth Paul Rosenstein-Rodan (1943) famously argued that at an early stage of development, the investments of industrializing firms in one sector may increase the profitability of other sectors throughout the economy. Simultaneous industrialization of many sectors of the economy could be profitable for them all, even though no sector would be profitable industrializing alone. As a result, an underdevelopment trap was possible. Even the market mechanism need not succeed in coordinating the activities needed to ensure development. In modern terms, there could be a coordination failure, where individuals' inability to coordinate their choices leads to a state of affairs that is worse for everyone than some alternative state of affairs that is also an equilibrium. The obstacle to achieving the better state of affairs is not a matter of technological opportunities (or even knowledge of those opportunities), nor resources or preferences, but only of coordination. In the 1950s, the possibility of underdevelopment traps or “vicious circles of poverty” was elaborated on by many others (including Nurkse 1953 and Leibenstein 1957). But individuals are rarely convinced by those who do not address their concerns. Without a well-developed theory of the sources of externalities (spillover effects), the idea of an equilibrium trap had little influence on neoclassical economists of that period. They continued to use their models to argue that the market mechanism could coordinate" @default.
- W2162662783 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2162662783 creator A5014711985 @default.
- W2162662783 date "2000-04-10" @default.
- W2162662783 modified "2023-09-27" @default.
- W2162662783 title "Beyond Rosenstein-Rodan: the modern theory of underdevelopment traps" @default.
- W2162662783 cites W139435615 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W1488556245 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W1492460295 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W1494102736 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W1503772292 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W1508130583 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W1513726781 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W1519396984 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W1529442972 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W1550693638 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W1564885043 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W1567773991 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W1590632185 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W1592554016 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W1605261697 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W1968050863 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W1980286469 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W1982108682 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W1988054894 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W1991858771 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W1998781994 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W2002425710 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W2010315914 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W2014610480 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W2022527538 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W2030033665 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W2030631638 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W2032014665 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W2034606455 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W2043476601 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W2058016438 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W2062339387 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W2063474468 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W2063666460 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W2065448907 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W2071776146 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W2072585631 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W2073545542 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W2080184288 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W2087116307 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W2117455041 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W2131740028 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W2151815531 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W2155237739 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W2168605160 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W2170764706 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W2186513470 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W2324656367 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W2542777094 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W2565435152 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W2991813917 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W3121147769 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W3121466124 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W3122166967 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W3122295862 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W3123677830 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W3124767725 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W3125873718 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W3148975945 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W602529524 @default.
- W2162662783 cites W84024344 @default.
- W2162662783 hasPublicationYear "2000" @default.
- W2162662783 type Work @default.
- W2162662783 sameAs 2162662783 @default.
- W2162662783 citedByCount "26" @default.
- W2162662783 countsByYear W21626627832012 @default.
- W2162662783 countsByYear W21626627832013 @default.
- W2162662783 countsByYear W21626627832018 @default.
- W2162662783 countsByYear W21626627832020 @default.
- W2162662783 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2162662783 hasAuthorship W2162662783A5014711985 @default.
- W2162662783 hasConcept C118084267 @default.
- W2162662783 hasConcept C133425853 @default.
- W2162662783 hasConcept C139719470 @default.
- W2162662783 hasConcept C16118543 @default.
- W2162662783 hasConcept C162324750 @default.
- W2162662783 hasConcept C165556158 @default.
- W2162662783 hasConcept C175444787 @default.
- W2162662783 hasConcept C32561294 @default.
- W2162662783 hasConcept C50522688 @default.
- W2162662783 hasConcept C79202496 @default.
- W2162662783 hasConcept C98965940 @default.
- W2162662783 hasConceptScore W2162662783C118084267 @default.
- W2162662783 hasConceptScore W2162662783C133425853 @default.
- W2162662783 hasConceptScore W2162662783C139719470 @default.
- W2162662783 hasConceptScore W2162662783C16118543 @default.
- W2162662783 hasConceptScore W2162662783C162324750 @default.
- W2162662783 hasConceptScore W2162662783C165556158 @default.
- W2162662783 hasConceptScore W2162662783C175444787 @default.
- W2162662783 hasConceptScore W2162662783C32561294 @default.
- W2162662783 hasConceptScore W2162662783C50522688 @default.
- W2162662783 hasConceptScore W2162662783C79202496 @default.