Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2163828867> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2163828867 endingPage "55" @default.
- W2163828867 startingPage "55" @default.
- W2163828867 abstract "ECT, rTMS, and deepTMS in pharmacoresistant drug-free patients with unipolar depression: a comparative review Amedeo Minichino¹, Francesco Saverio Bersani¹, Enrico Capra¹, Rossella Pannese¹, Celeste Bonanno², Massimo Salviati¹, Roberto Delle Chiaie¹, Massimo Biondi¹¹Department of Neurology and Psychiatry, Sapienza University of Rome, Rome, ²Aldo Moro University of Bari, Bari, ItalyBackground: Biological treatments are considered as additional options for the treatment of resistant unipolar depression. Controversial data exist about the efficacy and tolerability of three of the most used somatic treatments: electroconvulsive therapy (ECT), transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS), and deep transcranial magnetic stimulation (deepTMS). The aim of this review is to investigate and compare the efficacy and tolerability of these three techniques in drug-free patients with pharmacoresistant unipolar depression.Methods: Three independent reviewers extracted data and assessed the quality of methodological reporting of selected studies. The first outcome was the clinical response to the three different techniques defined as a percentage improvement of Hamilton Depression Rating Scale (HDRS). The second outcome was the evaluation of their neuropsychological effects. The third outcome was the evaluation of the number of remitted patients; remission was defined as an absolute HDRS-24 score of ≤11 or as an absolute HDRS-17 score of ≤8. Tolerability was the fourth outcome; it was evaluated by examining the number of dropped-out patients.Results: The comparative evaluation of HDRS percentage variations shows ECT as the most effective method after 4 weeks of therapy; on the other hand, a better efficacy is obtainable by deepTMS after 2 weeks of therapy. DeepTMS is the technique that gives the best improvement of cognitive performances. The percentage of remitted patients obtained with ECT treatment is the same obtained in the deepTMS group. Both techniques have a remitted patients percentage two times larger than the rTMS. DeepTMS shows a tolerability, measured by the number of dropped-out patients, worse than ECT.Conclusion: Our investigation confirms the great therapeutic power of ECT. DeepTMS seems to be the only therapy that provides a substantial improvement of both depressive symptoms and cognitive performances; nevertheless it is characterized by a poor tolerability. rTMS seems to provide a better tolerability for patients, but its therapeutic efficacy is lower. Considering the small therapeutic efficacy of deepTMS in the last 2 weeks of treatment, it could be reasonable to shorten the standard period of deepTMS treatment from 4 to 2 weeks, expecting a reduction of dropped-out patients and thus optimizing the treatment outcome.Keywords: deep transcranial magnetic stimulation, transcranial magnetic stimulation, electroconvulsive therapy, pharmacoresistant unipolar depression" @default.
- W2163828867 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2163828867 creator A5008949312 @default.
- W2163828867 creator A5011405857 @default.
- W2163828867 creator A5029644593 @default.
- W2163828867 creator A5030396911 @default.
- W2163828867 creator A5041536829 @default.
- W2163828867 creator A5050250273 @default.
- W2163828867 creator A5055040763 @default.
- W2163828867 creator A5077872880 @default.
- W2163828867 date "2012-01-01" @default.
- W2163828867 modified "2023-10-10" @default.
- W2163828867 title "ECT, rTMS, and deepTMS in pharmacoresistant drug-free patients with unipolar depression: a comparative review" @default.
- W2163828867 cites W1509868652 @default.
- W2163828867 cites W1604617206 @default.
- W2163828867 cites W1665095741 @default.
- W2163828867 cites W1971992037 @default.
- W2163828867 cites W1991888420 @default.
- W2163828867 cites W1999924919 @default.
- W2163828867 cites W2011717420 @default.
- W2163828867 cites W2025494252 @default.
- W2163828867 cites W2031572915 @default.
- W2163828867 cites W2042371311 @default.
- W2163828867 cites W2047325024 @default.
- W2163828867 cites W2049695419 @default.
- W2163828867 cites W2053293311 @default.
- W2163828867 cites W2053472601 @default.
- W2163828867 cites W2059946204 @default.
- W2163828867 cites W2062103870 @default.
- W2163828867 cites W2065073792 @default.
- W2163828867 cites W2065307148 @default.
- W2163828867 cites W2068394638 @default.
- W2163828867 cites W2070828096 @default.
- W2163828867 cites W2082830582 @default.
- W2163828867 cites W2097342181 @default.
- W2163828867 cites W2105071925 @default.
- W2163828867 cites W2117212688 @default.
- W2163828867 cites W2117345428 @default.
- W2163828867 cites W2118761232 @default.
- W2163828867 cites W2124758883 @default.
- W2163828867 cites W2128512121 @default.
- W2163828867 cites W214831933 @default.
- W2163828867 cites W2212831968 @default.
- W2163828867 cites W2330500859 @default.
- W2163828867 cites W2408897252 @default.
- W2163828867 cites W90311496 @default.
- W2163828867 cites W1984676472 @default.
- W2163828867 doi "https://doi.org/10.2147/ndt.s27025" @default.
- W2163828867 hasPubMedCentralId "https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/3280107" @default.
- W2163828867 hasPubMedId "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22347797" @default.
- W2163828867 hasPublicationYear "2012" @default.
- W2163828867 type Work @default.
- W2163828867 sameAs 2163828867 @default.
- W2163828867 citedByCount "20" @default.
- W2163828867 countsByYear W21638288672012 @default.
- W2163828867 countsByYear W21638288672013 @default.
- W2163828867 countsByYear W21638288672014 @default.
- W2163828867 countsByYear W21638288672015 @default.
- W2163828867 countsByYear W21638288672017 @default.
- W2163828867 countsByYear W21638288672018 @default.
- W2163828867 countsByYear W21638288672022 @default.
- W2163828867 countsByYear W21638288672023 @default.
- W2163828867 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2163828867 hasAuthorship W2163828867A5008949312 @default.
- W2163828867 hasAuthorship W2163828867A5011405857 @default.
- W2163828867 hasAuthorship W2163828867A5029644593 @default.
- W2163828867 hasAuthorship W2163828867A5030396911 @default.
- W2163828867 hasAuthorship W2163828867A5041536829 @default.
- W2163828867 hasAuthorship W2163828867A5050250273 @default.
- W2163828867 hasAuthorship W2163828867A5055040763 @default.
- W2163828867 hasAuthorship W2163828867A5077872880 @default.
- W2163828867 hasBestOaLocation W21638288671 @default.
- W2163828867 hasConcept C118552586 @default.
- W2163828867 hasConcept C126322002 @default.
- W2163828867 hasConcept C138496976 @default.
- W2163828867 hasConcept C139719470 @default.
- W2163828867 hasConcept C14216870 @default.
- W2163828867 hasConcept C15744967 @default.
- W2163828867 hasConcept C162324750 @default.
- W2163828867 hasConcept C169900460 @default.
- W2163828867 hasConcept C197934379 @default.
- W2163828867 hasConcept C24998067 @default.
- W2163828867 hasConcept C2776867660 @default.
- W2163828867 hasConcept C2777330709 @default.
- W2163828867 hasConcept C2778375690 @default.
- W2163828867 hasConcept C2778542668 @default.
- W2163828867 hasConcept C2778581513 @default.
- W2163828867 hasConcept C2779134260 @default.
- W2163828867 hasConcept C2779734285 @default.
- W2163828867 hasConcept C71924100 @default.
- W2163828867 hasConcept C83849319 @default.
- W2163828867 hasConceptScore W2163828867C118552586 @default.
- W2163828867 hasConceptScore W2163828867C126322002 @default.
- W2163828867 hasConceptScore W2163828867C138496976 @default.
- W2163828867 hasConceptScore W2163828867C139719470 @default.
- W2163828867 hasConceptScore W2163828867C14216870 @default.
- W2163828867 hasConceptScore W2163828867C15744967 @default.
- W2163828867 hasConceptScore W2163828867C162324750 @default.