Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2170872023> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2170872023 endingPage "859" @default.
- W2170872023 startingPage "839" @default.
- W2170872023 abstract "Abstract This paper discusses the efficacy of applying a framework of universal to resolve heritage conflicts. It considers the pitfalls and potentials in particular heritage settings for both archaeologists and the constituencies we seek to represent. A distinction is made throughout the paper between invoking universal rights, as opposed to other or claims more broadly. Specifically, I ask what does the mantle of universal bring to heritage? What additional work might it perform, and who wins and loses when archaeologists elevate cultural heritage to this arena of urgency? If archaeologists want to pursue this route, what steps might they take to be conversant with and, more importantly, effective in practically implementing that knowledge? I then describe the situation in post-apartheid South Africa-a nation that has arguably crafted the world's most liberal constitution, yet in reality faces numerous challenges to instrumentalizing rights. In terms of South African heritage rights, the archaeological site of Thulamela is offered as an example of conflict resolution at the local level by briefly examining the role of archaeologists and several connected communities each vying for access and ownership of the site. Following Amartya Sen and Martha Nussbaum I suggest that heritage practitioners might be more effective and ethically responsible by being attendant to pragmatic approaches that enhance capabilities and flourishing. [Keywords: Heritage ethics, rights, heritage rights, claims, South African Archaeology, politics, fieldwork] Forty years ago, UNESCO held a conference entitled Cultural Rights as Human Rights (UNESCO 1970) to reflect on the evolution of the concept of cultural in the twenty years since the proclamation in 1948 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Luminaries including Ernest Gellner, Boutros Boutros-Ghali, and Breyten Breytenbach debated a now familiar set of subjects: the place of culture and tradition, group versus individual rights, the role of the state, and so on. Among the primary concerns were peace, the eradication of poverty, global development, the hegemony of the nation state, international intervention, freedom of media and artistic life, and education in science and technology. Looking back over this remarkably forward-thinking document is both inspiring and sobering. Ostensibly they were having the same conversation in 1968 as many of us are engaged in now. The critical failures they addressed then, understandably, have not been resolved. But what has changed is the astounding upsurge in talk and the desire to harness the urgency of discourse in so many aspects of human, animal and planetary existence. International have become today's lingua franca, speaking to issues of inequality, injustice, and politics in their broadest terms (Stacy 2009). The discourse of is everywhere, a pervasive and thick stratum that overlays our understandings of nationalisms and internationalisms, indigenous movements, historic repressions, and global inequities. Archaeology is no different, and one recent volume suggests that heritage and are inextricably linked (Silverman and Fairchild Ruggles 2008a). However, a danger exists, in that the call for human rights has been so extensive as to dilute the very power and specificity of those fundamental as opposed to other types of claims. Before archaeologists assume that instigating petitions over cultural heritage offers a pragmatic way forward to resolve heritage conflicts, it is certainly worth pausing to consider the potentials and limitations of such an approach. This discussion then revolves around two related issues. First, I consider whether heritage conflicts represent an impingement upon specifically; and second, whether an appeal to an international legislative framework offers the most pragmatic way forward for affected communities. …" @default.
- W2170872023 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2170872023 creator A5039791894 @default.
- W2170872023 date "2010-01-01" @default.
- W2170872023 modified "2023-09-23" @default.
- W2170872023 title "Human Rights and Heritage Ethics" @default.
- W2170872023 cites W1498727342 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W1500164099 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W1502744741 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W1532682097 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W1535803599 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W1556162475 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W1562748400 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W1573048468 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W1577473558 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W1583379703 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W1587411119 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W1603854533 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W1796466512 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W1966999033 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W1989247309 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W1993358969 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W1993568576 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W1999625176 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W2009368207 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W2050739607 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W2068822188 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W2070300800 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W2093039388 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W2099320442 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W2103974528 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W2109778422 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W2111374204 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W2116033428 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W2124000640 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W2127035031 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W2129431391 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W2136290069 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W2299161911 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W2320113698 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W2323798685 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W2341977479 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W2482870575 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W2495135727 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W2496452252 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W2798897633 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W2798947314 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W2802402771 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W2803616553 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W3022448255 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W3144334907 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W3171198244 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W50225531 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W584912237 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W595474632 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W599055454 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W607560233 @default.
- W2170872023 cites W67410282 @default.
- W2170872023 doi "https://doi.org/10.1353/anq.2010.0023" @default.
- W2170872023 hasPublicationYear "2010" @default.
- W2170872023 type Work @default.
- W2170872023 sameAs 2170872023 @default.
- W2170872023 citedByCount "67" @default.
- W2170872023 countsByYear W21708720232012 @default.
- W2170872023 countsByYear W21708720232013 @default.
- W2170872023 countsByYear W21708720232014 @default.
- W2170872023 countsByYear W21708720232015 @default.
- W2170872023 countsByYear W21708720232016 @default.
- W2170872023 countsByYear W21708720232017 @default.
- W2170872023 countsByYear W21708720232018 @default.
- W2170872023 countsByYear W21708720232019 @default.
- W2170872023 countsByYear W21708720232020 @default.
- W2170872023 countsByYear W21708720232021 @default.
- W2170872023 countsByYear W21708720232022 @default.
- W2170872023 countsByYear W21708720232023 @default.
- W2170872023 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2170872023 hasAuthorship W2170872023A5039791894 @default.
- W2170872023 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W2170872023 hasConcept C144024400 @default.
- W2170872023 hasConcept C169437150 @default.
- W2170872023 hasConcept C17744445 @default.
- W2170872023 hasConcept C199539241 @default.
- W2170872023 hasConcept C95124753 @default.
- W2170872023 hasConceptScore W2170872023C138885662 @default.
- W2170872023 hasConceptScore W2170872023C144024400 @default.
- W2170872023 hasConceptScore W2170872023C169437150 @default.
- W2170872023 hasConceptScore W2170872023C17744445 @default.
- W2170872023 hasConceptScore W2170872023C199539241 @default.
- W2170872023 hasConceptScore W2170872023C95124753 @default.
- W2170872023 hasIssue "4" @default.
- W2170872023 hasLocation W21708720231 @default.
- W2170872023 hasOpenAccess W2170872023 @default.
- W2170872023 hasPrimaryLocation W21708720231 @default.
- W2170872023 hasRelatedWork W161289384 @default.
- W2170872023 hasRelatedWork W1991342194 @default.
- W2170872023 hasRelatedWork W2040883266 @default.
- W2170872023 hasRelatedWork W2089999080 @default.
- W2170872023 hasRelatedWork W2245483302 @default.