Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2175364247> ?p ?o ?g. }
Showing items 1 to 87 of
87
with 100 items per page.
- W2175364247 abstract "The contributions in Klosa (2013a) provide information on various aspects of the design of morphological data for (German) language dictionaries. Bergenholtz and Gouws (2013), however, reject most of these contributions as sources lexicographers could use for the design of language dictionaries because they are guided by linguistic theory (cf. their critique of Klosa 2013b), instead of Function Theory, and by a misguided application of methods for user research, (cf. their critique of Topel's 2013 use of the questionnaire as method for user research). The first goal of this article is to provide a critical discussion of Bergenholtz and Gouws's (2013) views on the approach of Function Theory to the theoretical, methodological and practical aspects of the design of morphological/linguistic data in L1/L2 (language) dictionaries. It is argued that the approach of Function Theory provides lexicographers only with a usable overview of the design trends in printed and electronic dictionaries for the selection and presentation of morphological/ linguistic data in dictionaries, but that the theoretical, methodological and practical approach of Function Theory is fraught with difficulties. The strategy Bergenholtz and Gouws (2013) use to debunk the linguistic approach to lexicography is not new; it is a well-known strategy used in the rhetoric of Function Theory. The second goal of this article is therefore to point out some of the general problems with a Function Theory of lexicography for the planning, production and publishing of language dictionaries. Given the problems with the theoretical, methodological and practical aspects of Function Theory, it does not offer a viable alternative to the linguistic approach to the design of morphological/linguistic data in L1/L2 (language) dictionaries. It is argued that linguistic lexicography provides lexicographers with access to a vast body of theoretical, methodological and practical research to support the design of morphological data in L1/L2 (language) dictionaries. Furthermore, it is argued that Function Theory has established the importance of functional variables in the design of (language) dictionaries, but that what lexicography needs now is a truly multidisciplinary approach to lexicography, and not an approach that reduces lexicography to the status of a hand-maiden of another discipline, for example, information science, or of a reductionist Function Theory of lexicography." @default.
- W2175364247 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2175364247 creator A5065046656 @default.
- W2175364247 date "2015-11-01" @default.
- W2175364247 modified "2023-10-14" @default.
- W2175364247 title "The Design of Morphological/ Linguistic Data in L1 and L2 Monolingual, Explanatory Dictionaries: A Functional and/or Linguistic Approach?" @default.
- W2175364247 cites W1032605507 @default.
- W2175364247 cites W1549720787 @default.
- W2175364247 cites W1587912142 @default.
- W2175364247 cites W2006468167 @default.
- W2175364247 cites W2013319146 @default.
- W2175364247 cites W2014217670 @default.
- W2175364247 cites W2036771209 @default.
- W2175364247 cites W2038721957 @default.
- W2175364247 cites W2043302885 @default.
- W2175364247 cites W2043392480 @default.
- W2175364247 cites W2044316986 @default.
- W2175364247 cites W2057615279 @default.
- W2175364247 cites W2065580138 @default.
- W2175364247 cites W2103875817 @default.
- W2175364247 cites W2106402256 @default.
- W2175364247 cites W2106658097 @default.
- W2175364247 cites W2146585965 @default.
- W2175364247 cites W2154647647 @default.
- W2175364247 cites W2158875680 @default.
- W2175364247 cites W2314620621 @default.
- W2175364247 cites W2321506936 @default.
- W2175364247 cites W2325849697 @default.
- W2175364247 cites W2401109438 @default.
- W2175364247 cites W2475278887 @default.
- W2175364247 cites W2590746527 @default.
- W2175364247 cites W2603874622 @default.
- W2175364247 cites W2620991547 @default.
- W2175364247 cites W2750368965 @default.
- W2175364247 cites W2810730578 @default.
- W2175364247 cites W2810920567 @default.
- W2175364247 cites W2897890204 @default.
- W2175364247 cites W304821955 @default.
- W2175364247 cites W3216386611 @default.
- W2175364247 cites W424223014 @default.
- W2175364247 cites W569787612 @default.
- W2175364247 cites W592585162 @default.
- W2175364247 cites W652655586 @default.
- W2175364247 cites W840073890 @default.
- W2175364247 cites W93013668 @default.
- W2175364247 cites W2618028912 @default.
- W2175364247 doi "https://doi.org/10.5788/25-1-1303" @default.
- W2175364247 hasPublicationYear "2015" @default.
- W2175364247 type Work @default.
- W2175364247 sameAs 2175364247 @default.
- W2175364247 citedByCount "3" @default.
- W2175364247 countsByYear W21753642472015 @default.
- W2175364247 countsByYear W21753642472016 @default.
- W2175364247 countsByYear W21753642472019 @default.
- W2175364247 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2175364247 hasAuthorship W2175364247A5065046656 @default.
- W2175364247 hasBestOaLocation W21753642471 @default.
- W2175364247 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W2175364247 hasConcept C154945302 @default.
- W2175364247 hasConcept C15744967 @default.
- W2175364247 hasConcept C204321447 @default.
- W2175364247 hasConcept C41008148 @default.
- W2175364247 hasConcept C41895202 @default.
- W2175364247 hasConceptScore W2175364247C138885662 @default.
- W2175364247 hasConceptScore W2175364247C154945302 @default.
- W2175364247 hasConceptScore W2175364247C15744967 @default.
- W2175364247 hasConceptScore W2175364247C204321447 @default.
- W2175364247 hasConceptScore W2175364247C41008148 @default.
- W2175364247 hasConceptScore W2175364247C41895202 @default.
- W2175364247 hasLocation W21753642471 @default.
- W2175364247 hasLocation W21753642472 @default.
- W2175364247 hasOpenAccess W2175364247 @default.
- W2175364247 hasPrimaryLocation W21753642471 @default.
- W2175364247 hasRelatedWork W1512718085 @default.
- W2175364247 hasRelatedWork W1569841287 @default.
- W2175364247 hasRelatedWork W2293457016 @default.
- W2175364247 hasRelatedWork W2359001871 @default.
- W2175364247 hasRelatedWork W2369308426 @default.
- W2175364247 hasRelatedWork W2748952813 @default.
- W2175364247 hasRelatedWork W2789919619 @default.
- W2175364247 hasRelatedWork W2899084033 @default.
- W2175364247 hasRelatedWork W1551406738 @default.
- W2175364247 hasRelatedWork W2610387714 @default.
- W2175364247 isParatext "false" @default.
- W2175364247 isRetracted "false" @default.
- W2175364247 magId "2175364247" @default.
- W2175364247 workType "article" @default.