Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2185191851> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2185191851 abstract "Like Mises before him, Hayek challenges the validity of socialism as a centrally planned economic regime typically characterized by state ownership of all means of production. What is typical of Hayek's challenge is that he holds that this question is fully theoretical in nature and that it has consequently to be raised and decided as a scientific question. Sketching the historical background of the socialist calculation debate of the 1920s and 1930s, I first show how this debate is linked with the Menger-Wieser Zurechnungsproblem, which indeed constitutes the very topic of Hayek’s 1923 Ph. D. dissertation. I recall that the Pareto-Barone approach based on General Equilibrium Theory (GET) has determined the conceptual framework of this controversy. I then go on to explore Hayek's impracticability argument against market socialism and try to show how it is related to, but different from, Mises’s logical impossibility argument. I argue that the contexts of discussion were completely different in both cases: if Mises was criticizing the possibility of rational economic decisions in a moneyless economy, Hayek was debating against the Lange-Dickinson-Lerner model of market socialism where the prices of first order goods were supposedly fixed following a GET simulation of the competetive market process. The core of Hayek’s line of reasoning is shown to be related to a clever analysis of the notion of ‘data’: the data on which a Central Planification Board is suppose to work out a production and distribution schema for the whole economy are simply unavailable to him because this kind of economic knowledge (which Michael Polanyi calls “tacit knowledge”) cannot be accumulated and stored up anywhere in society, as if the global economy could be directed by a super-brain possessing complete knowledge of every particular situation and able to compute a perfect solution to any economic problem whatsoever. Thirdly, I come to discuss a methodological issue pertaining to the allegedly radical difference between Mises’s and Hayek’s argumentations. I reject the received view following which Mises supposedly argued on theoretical grounds (showing the impossibility in principle of socialism) while Hayek would have" @default.
- W2185191851 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2185191851 creator A5084126873 @default.
- W2185191851 date "2011-01-01" @default.
- W2185191851 modified "2023-09-26" @default.
- W2185191851 title "ON HAYEK'S CONFUTATION OF MARKET SOCIALISM" @default.
- W2185191851 cites W1490726020 @default.
- W2185191851 cites W1503457370 @default.
- W2185191851 cites W1533892525 @default.
- W2185191851 cites W1542281312 @default.
- W2185191851 cites W1546818268 @default.
- W2185191851 cites W1571420026 @default.
- W2185191851 cites W1572241352 @default.
- W2185191851 cites W1578433230 @default.
- W2185191851 cites W1780671468 @default.
- W2185191851 cites W1966638140 @default.
- W2185191851 cites W2003415820 @default.
- W2185191851 cites W2007180942 @default.
- W2185191851 cites W2007297678 @default.
- W2185191851 cites W2015561600 @default.
- W2185191851 cites W2048705672 @default.
- W2185191851 cites W2048894562 @default.
- W2185191851 cites W2062066473 @default.
- W2185191851 cites W2065950363 @default.
- W2185191851 cites W2086140417 @default.
- W2185191851 cites W2112140333 @default.
- W2185191851 cites W2127736977 @default.
- W2185191851 cites W2153590880 @default.
- W2185191851 cites W2161735352 @default.
- W2185191851 cites W2165744048 @default.
- W2185191851 cites W2183588159 @default.
- W2185191851 cites W2295080417 @default.
- W2185191851 cites W2317471338 @default.
- W2185191851 cites W2324775522 @default.
- W2185191851 cites W2329669042 @default.
- W2185191851 cites W2498269794 @default.
- W2185191851 cites W2894453446 @default.
- W2185191851 cites W3004814681 @default.
- W2185191851 cites W3149626885 @default.
- W2185191851 cites W3164207756 @default.
- W2185191851 cites W341127541 @default.
- W2185191851 cites W653832486 @default.
- W2185191851 hasPublicationYear "2011" @default.
- W2185191851 type Work @default.
- W2185191851 sameAs 2185191851 @default.
- W2185191851 citedByCount "0" @default.
- W2185191851 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2185191851 hasAuthorship W2185191851A5084126873 @default.
- W2185191851 hasConcept C118084267 @default.
- W2185191851 hasConcept C133425853 @default.
- W2185191851 hasConcept C137635306 @default.
- W2185191851 hasConcept C138021795 @default.
- W2185191851 hasConcept C162324750 @default.
- W2185191851 hasConcept C17744445 @default.
- W2185191851 hasConcept C185592680 @default.
- W2185191851 hasConcept C199539241 @default.
- W2185191851 hasConcept C21547014 @default.
- W2185191851 hasConcept C2776261394 @default.
- W2185191851 hasConcept C501299471 @default.
- W2185191851 hasConcept C527784420 @default.
- W2185191851 hasConcept C542948173 @default.
- W2185191851 hasConcept C55493867 @default.
- W2185191851 hasConcept C94625758 @default.
- W2185191851 hasConcept C98184364 @default.
- W2185191851 hasConceptScore W2185191851C118084267 @default.
- W2185191851 hasConceptScore W2185191851C133425853 @default.
- W2185191851 hasConceptScore W2185191851C137635306 @default.
- W2185191851 hasConceptScore W2185191851C138021795 @default.
- W2185191851 hasConceptScore W2185191851C162324750 @default.
- W2185191851 hasConceptScore W2185191851C17744445 @default.
- W2185191851 hasConceptScore W2185191851C185592680 @default.
- W2185191851 hasConceptScore W2185191851C199539241 @default.
- W2185191851 hasConceptScore W2185191851C21547014 @default.
- W2185191851 hasConceptScore W2185191851C2776261394 @default.
- W2185191851 hasConceptScore W2185191851C501299471 @default.
- W2185191851 hasConceptScore W2185191851C527784420 @default.
- W2185191851 hasConceptScore W2185191851C542948173 @default.
- W2185191851 hasConceptScore W2185191851C55493867 @default.
- W2185191851 hasConceptScore W2185191851C94625758 @default.
- W2185191851 hasConceptScore W2185191851C98184364 @default.
- W2185191851 hasLocation W21851918511 @default.
- W2185191851 hasOpenAccess W2185191851 @default.
- W2185191851 hasPrimaryLocation W21851918511 @default.
- W2185191851 hasRelatedWork W126657679 @default.
- W2185191851 hasRelatedWork W1535018313 @default.
- W2185191851 hasRelatedWork W2012492033 @default.
- W2185191851 hasRelatedWork W2014562677 @default.
- W2185191851 hasRelatedWork W2051174795 @default.
- W2185191851 hasRelatedWork W2102628396 @default.
- W2185191851 hasRelatedWork W2118382136 @default.
- W2185191851 hasRelatedWork W2146074666 @default.
- W2185191851 hasRelatedWork W2257959974 @default.
- W2185191851 hasRelatedWork W2258166995 @default.
- W2185191851 hasRelatedWork W2339949327 @default.
- W2185191851 hasRelatedWork W2497723973 @default.
- W2185191851 hasRelatedWork W2512226845 @default.
- W2185191851 hasRelatedWork W2911805033 @default.
- W2185191851 hasRelatedWork W2980960340 @default.
- W2185191851 hasRelatedWork W3125177193 @default.
- W2185191851 hasRelatedWork W3147697927 @default.