FRINK Linked Data Fragments server

Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2186928070> ?p ?o ?g. }

• W2186928070 abstract "Hannah et al. (1) recently published a com-prehensive study showing substantial im-pacts of climate change on viticultural suit-ability, leading to potential ecological issues.We agree that expansion of viticulture intonew areas can lead to a decrease in biodiver-sity and that an increase in water use forirrigation might lead to major freshwaterconservation impacts. However, we disagreewith the alarming statement that suitabilityfor winegrowing of main wine-producingareas worldwide will dramatically decreaseoverthenext40y.Wepointoutmajormeth-odological flaws in ref. 1, mostly linked to ( i)themisuseofbibliographicaldatatocomputesuitabilityindex,(ii)underestimationofadap-tations of viticulture to warmer conditions,and (iii) the inadequacy of the monthly timestep in the suitability approach.The suitability index in ref. 1 is mainlycompiled from grapevine maturity groupingsasdefinedbyJones(ref.2isawrongcitation;thisclassificationisgiveninref.3)andGlad-stones[(4),notpeer-reviewed].Inrefs.3and4, groupings were constructed from empiri-cal observations collected in premium wine-growing areas and not based on grapevinephysiological modeling. We argue that it isverydifficulttoestablishpreciseupperlimitsby variety for growing high-quality winesand that those given in ref. 3 are underesti-mated.Toillustratethisaspect,wecomparedaveragegrowingseasontemperature(AvGST)from 1971 to 1999 and from 2000 to 2012 forthree major wine-growing regions (Fig. 1):Rheingau(Germany),Burgundy(France),andRhoneValley(France).Burgundycon-tinues to produce great wines with Pinotnoir since 2000, although AvGST is alreadyabove the upper temperature limit citedin ref. 3. The same is true for Rheingauwith Pinot gris and the Rhone Valley withSyrah. High-quality viticulture is sustained inthese regions despite increased temperaturesanddryfarming,becauseofboththeevolutionof consumer’s preferences and implementa-tion of adaptative strategies by growers.Amajorflaw in ref. 1 is that noncappedgrowingdegreedays(GDDs)arecomputedand subsequently compared with varietalmaturity groupings from ref. 4, whereinGDDs are capped at 19 °C [called biologi-cally effective degree days (BEDDs)]. Asthe climate becomes warmer, the seasonaldifference between BEDDs and noncappedGDDs increases up to several hundreds ofDDs. Hence, projected ripeness in ref. 1 isweeks ahead when compared with ripenessproperly estimated using ref. 4. This sub-sequently results in much higher temper-atures during the projected last monthbefore ripeness, which was the main crite-rionusedinref.1toconsideraregionsuit-able for viticulture or not.A monthly time step was used in ref. 1.One month accounts for up to 270 BEDDs.When varieties are compared in maturitygroupings that are 50 DDs apart, this reso-lution is too crude to yield reliablematuritypredictions.Hannah et al. make an interesting point inpredicting which regions worldwide maybecome suitable for viticulture by 2050 asa consequence of climate change, and inestimating related potential ecological impact.However, their conclusion that most of thepresent wine-growing regions will becomeunsuitable for viticulture is erroneous.Cornelis van Leeuwen" @default.
• W2186928070 created "2016-06-24" @default.
• W2186928070 creator A5073391854 @default.
• W2186928070 date "2013-01-01" @default.
• W2186928070 modified "2023-09-27" @default.
• W2186928070 title "Why climate change will not dramatically decrease viticultural suitability in main wine-producing areas by 2050" @default.
• W2186928070 cites W1979241560 @default.
• W2186928070 cites W2158756518 @default.
• W2186928070 cites W328415054 @default.
• W2186928070 hasPublicationYear "2013" @default.
• W2186928070 type Work @default.
• W2186928070 sameAs 2186928070 @default.
• W2186928070 citedByCount "0" @default.
• W2186928070 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
• W2186928070 hasAuthorship W2186928070A5073391854 @default.
• W2186928070 hasConcept C132651083 @default.
• W2186928070 hasConcept C139019045 @default.
• W2186928070 hasConcept C151107107 @default.
• W2186928070 hasConcept C185592680 @default.
• W2186928070 hasConcept C18903297 @default.
• W2186928070 hasConcept C205649164 @default.
• W2186928070 hasConcept C2994243853 @default.
• W2186928070 hasConcept C31903555 @default.
• W2186928070 hasConcept C37621935 @default.
• W2186928070 hasConcept C39432304 @default.
• W2186928070 hasConcept C55952523 @default.
• W2186928070 hasConcept C86803240 @default.
• W2186928070 hasConcept C97137747 @default.
• W2186928070 hasConceptScore W2186928070C132651083 @default.
• W2186928070 hasConceptScore W2186928070C139019045 @default.
• W2186928070 hasConceptScore W2186928070C151107107 @default.
• W2186928070 hasConceptScore W2186928070C185592680 @default.
• W2186928070 hasConceptScore W2186928070C18903297 @default.
• W2186928070 hasConceptScore W2186928070C205649164 @default.
• W2186928070 hasConceptScore W2186928070C2994243853 @default.
• W2186928070 hasConceptScore W2186928070C31903555 @default.
• W2186928070 hasConceptScore W2186928070C37621935 @default.
• W2186928070 hasConceptScore W2186928070C39432304 @default.
• W2186928070 hasConceptScore W2186928070C55952523 @default.
• W2186928070 hasConceptScore W2186928070C86803240 @default.
• W2186928070 hasConceptScore W2186928070C97137747 @default.
• W2186928070 hasLocation W21869280701 @default.
• W2186928070 hasOpenAccess W2186928070 @default.
• W2186928070 hasPrimaryLocation W21869280701 @default.
• W2186928070 hasRelatedWork W1196932001 @default.
• W2186928070 hasRelatedWork W1213479045 @default.
• W2186928070 hasRelatedWork W1512550933 @default.
• W2186928070 hasRelatedWork W1806945304 @default.
• W2186928070 hasRelatedWork W1966238413 @default.
• W2186928070 hasRelatedWork W2003044127 @default.
• W2186928070 hasRelatedWork W2066676275 @default.
• W2186928070 hasRelatedWork W2095828943 @default.
• W2186928070 hasRelatedWork W2320978103 @default.
• W2186928070 hasRelatedWork W2418317497 @default.
• W2186928070 hasRelatedWork W2433811008 @default.
• W2186928070 hasRelatedWork W2500146650 @default.
• W2186928070 hasRelatedWork W2557194764 @default.
• W2186928070 hasRelatedWork W2601105560 @default.
• W2186928070 hasRelatedWork W2732898678 @default.
• W2186928070 hasRelatedWork W2765260078 @default.
• W2186928070 hasRelatedWork W2888227798 @default.
• W2186928070 hasRelatedWork W2944233054 @default.
• W2186928070 hasRelatedWork W3006210918 @default.
• W2186928070 hasRelatedWork W3182016287 @default.
• W2186928070 isParatext "false" @default.
• W2186928070 isRetracted "false" @default.
• W2186928070 magId "2186928070" @default.
• W2186928070 workType "article" @default.