Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2187367908> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2187367908 abstract "Department of Psychology, University of Washington,Seattle, WA 98195, USASummaryThe standard view of neurons in early visual cortex is thatthey behave like localized feature detectors [1–7]. Here wedemonstrate that processing in early visual areas goesbeyond feature detection by showing that neural responsesare greater when a feature deviates from its contextcomparedtowhenitdoesnotdeviatefromitscontext.Usingpsychophysics, fMRI, and electroencephalography method-ologies, we measured neural responses to an orientedGabor (‘‘target’’) embedded in various visual patterns asdefinedbytherelativeorientationofflankingstimuli.Wefirstshow using psychophysical contrast adaptation and fMRIthat a target that differs from its context results in moreneural activity compared to a target that is contained withinan alternating sequence, suggesting that neurons in earlyvisual cortex are sensitive to large-scale orientationpatterns. Next, we use event-related potentials to show thatorientation deviations affect the earliest sensory compo-nents of the target response. Finally, we use forced-choiceclassification of ‘‘noise’’ stimuli to show that we are morelikely to ‘‘see’’ orientations that deviate from the context.Our results suggest that early visual cortex is sensitive toglobal patterns in images in a way that is markedly differentfrom the predictions of standard models of cortical visualprocessing.ResultsInseparateexperiments,wemeasuredneuralresponsesusingpsychophysical contrast adaptation, human fMRI, and event-related potentials (ERPs) to an oriented Gabor stimulus(‘‘target’’) embedded in various visual patterns as defined bythe relative orientation of flanking stimuli. Specifically, wevaried whether a central target deviated from its context bychanging the orientation of distant gratings while leaving theimmediately neighboring flankers unchanged. For example,we hypothesized that the neural response to a verticallyoriented target grating would be greater when it deviatedfromtheorientationofitsflankers(horizontalflankers,HHVHH)compared to when it was grouped into an alternatingsequence of orientations (VHVHV). Keeping the localorientation configuration around the target the same acrossconditions (e.g., HVH) eliminates effects of simple spatialsummation [8–10].Contrast Adaptation: Deviations from the Context Resultin More AdaptationOur first experiment used psychophysical contrast adaptationto infer the magnitude of the neural response in early visualcortex to the target stimulus [11–13]. To quantify adaptationstrength, we calculated the ratio of each observer’s contrastdetection threshold for a target before and after adaptation.Our assumption is that more adaptation—as indexed by anincrease in postadaptation detection thresholds—reflectsstronger neural activity in response to the adapting stimulus[11, 14–21] (see also Figure S1A available online). Observerswere initially adapted to a stimulus for 30 s before performingatwo-intervalforcedchoicedetectiontask.A5stop-upadap-tation period was inserted between trials to maintain stableadaptation (see Figure S1B and Supplemental ExperimentalProcedures for detail).Usingaverticallyorientedtarget(V),wefoundmoreadapta-tion with orthogonal, horizontally oriented local flankers (HVH,‘‘orthogonal’’ condition) compared to vertically oriented localflankers (VVV, three-element ‘‘same’’ condition) [paired two-tailed t test, t(6) = 6.15, p < 0.001; Figure 1A]. In an additionalexperiment, we found that the horizontal and vertical flankersalone (no stimulus in the target position) did not produce anyadaptation, indicating that differences in adaptation observedbetween the same and orthogonal condition were due todifferences in the orientation relationship between the targetand flankers and not due to differences in the flankers them-selves (Figure S1A). Larger adaptation to a target with orthog-onally oriented flankers is consistent with electrophysiologystudies showing larger neural responses in V1 to a stimuluswhen it is surrounded by orthogonal as compared to iso-oriented stimuli [9, 22, 23]. One possible interpretation of thisresult is that neurons respond more strongly to stimuli thatdeviate from the context. However, because this conditionalso manipulates the local orientation arrangement of thetarget and flankers, this result in isolation can also be ex-plained through local orientation-selective spatial summationor normalization [8–10].Wethenaddeddistantflankerstotheoriginalthree-elementstimulitocreatefive-elementstimuli.Thisallowedustomanip-ulate whether the target deviated from the context withoutchanging the local (the target and its immediate neighbors)feature arrangement. Adding distant vertical flankers to thethree-element ‘‘same’’ condition, generating a five-elementsame condition (VVVVV), did not change the amount of adap-tation [t(6) = 1.23, p = 0.26], demonstrating that additionalvertical flankers do not necessarily alter responses to thetarget. Importantly, we observed a significant difference inour critical condition: adaptation to the three-element orthog-onal condition (HVH) was significantly reduced when distantvertical flankers were added, producing a five-element ‘‘alter-nating’’ condition (VHVHV) [t(6) = 4.25, p = 0.005], presumablybecause the target does not deviate from—and is groupedinto—the alternating pattern induced by the flankers. Asa further test, we directly compared the amount of adaptationbetween the alternating VHVHV condition and the orthogonalHHVHHcondition.Consistentwithourhypothesis,theamountofadaptationwassignificantly lessinthealternatingcondition(see Figure S1C).We observed the same results for horizontally (Figure 1B)and obliquely (Figure 1C) oriented targets. In all cases," @default.
- W2187367908 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2187367908 creator A5022722599 @default.
- W2187367908 creator A5028894097 @default.
- W2187367908 creator A5031619204 @default.
- W2187367908 date "2012-01-01" @default.
- W2187367908 modified "2023-09-28" @default.
- W2187367908 title "Report Long-Range, Pattern-Dependent Contextual Effects in Early Human Visual Cortex" @default.
- W2187367908 cites W109907426 @default.
- W2187367908 cites W1497878968 @default.
- W2187367908 cites W1504757957 @default.
- W2187367908 cites W1844800426 @default.
- W2187367908 cites W1914401667 @default.
- W2187367908 cites W1954638517 @default.
- W2187367908 cites W1985519873 @default.
- W2187367908 cites W2002144318 @default.
- W2187367908 cites W2017850232 @default.
- W2187367908 cites W2028071797 @default.
- W2187367908 cites W2029346512 @default.
- W2187367908 cites W2029683698 @default.
- W2187367908 cites W2034260846 @default.
- W2187367908 cites W2039360139 @default.
- W2187367908 cites W2072336730 @default.
- W2187367908 cites W2075724496 @default.
- W2187367908 cites W2088927213 @default.
- W2187367908 cites W2093527688 @default.
- W2187367908 cites W2104325300 @default.
- W2187367908 cites W2104491490 @default.
- W2187367908 cites W2104871368 @default.
- W2187367908 cites W2107098820 @default.
- W2187367908 cites W2108992228 @default.
- W2187367908 cites W2116079555 @default.
- W2187367908 cites W2119885245 @default.
- W2187367908 cites W2124220989 @default.
- W2187367908 cites W2130284485 @default.
- W2187367908 cites W2131470433 @default.
- W2187367908 cites W2138558323 @default.
- W2187367908 cites W2141145724 @default.
- W2187367908 cites W2142963090 @default.
- W2187367908 cites W2150052800 @default.
- W2187367908 cites W2152811887 @default.
- W2187367908 cites W2156423697 @default.
- W2187367908 cites W2164137768 @default.
- W2187367908 cites W2164287247 @default.
- W2187367908 cites W2165422719 @default.
- W2187367908 cites W2166689701 @default.
- W2187367908 cites W2167553001 @default.
- W2187367908 cites W2170319235 @default.
- W2187367908 cites W2323067647 @default.
- W2187367908 cites W64652264 @default.
- W2187367908 hasPublicationYear "2012" @default.
- W2187367908 type Work @default.
- W2187367908 sameAs 2187367908 @default.
- W2187367908 citedByCount "0" @default.
- W2187367908 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2187367908 hasAuthorship W2187367908A5022722599 @default.
- W2187367908 hasAuthorship W2187367908A5028894097 @default.
- W2187367908 hasAuthorship W2187367908A5031619204 @default.
- W2187367908 hasConcept C15123163 @default.
- W2187367908 hasConcept C151730666 @default.
- W2187367908 hasConcept C153180895 @default.
- W2187367908 hasConcept C154945302 @default.
- W2187367908 hasConcept C15744967 @default.
- W2187367908 hasConcept C16345878 @default.
- W2187367908 hasConcept C169760540 @default.
- W2187367908 hasConcept C180747234 @default.
- W2187367908 hasConcept C2524010 @default.
- W2187367908 hasConcept C26760741 @default.
- W2187367908 hasConcept C2776502983 @default.
- W2187367908 hasConcept C2778251979 @default.
- W2187367908 hasConcept C2779343474 @default.
- W2187367908 hasConcept C2779345533 @default.
- W2187367908 hasConcept C2779918689 @default.
- W2187367908 hasConcept C2993858690 @default.
- W2187367908 hasConcept C33923547 @default.
- W2187367908 hasConcept C41008148 @default.
- W2187367908 hasConcept C86803240 @default.
- W2187367908 hasConcept C94487597 @default.
- W2187367908 hasConceptScore W2187367908C15123163 @default.
- W2187367908 hasConceptScore W2187367908C151730666 @default.
- W2187367908 hasConceptScore W2187367908C153180895 @default.
- W2187367908 hasConceptScore W2187367908C154945302 @default.
- W2187367908 hasConceptScore W2187367908C15744967 @default.
- W2187367908 hasConceptScore W2187367908C16345878 @default.
- W2187367908 hasConceptScore W2187367908C169760540 @default.
- W2187367908 hasConceptScore W2187367908C180747234 @default.
- W2187367908 hasConceptScore W2187367908C2524010 @default.
- W2187367908 hasConceptScore W2187367908C26760741 @default.
- W2187367908 hasConceptScore W2187367908C2776502983 @default.
- W2187367908 hasConceptScore W2187367908C2778251979 @default.
- W2187367908 hasConceptScore W2187367908C2779343474 @default.
- W2187367908 hasConceptScore W2187367908C2779345533 @default.
- W2187367908 hasConceptScore W2187367908C2779918689 @default.
- W2187367908 hasConceptScore W2187367908C2993858690 @default.
- W2187367908 hasConceptScore W2187367908C33923547 @default.
- W2187367908 hasConceptScore W2187367908C41008148 @default.
- W2187367908 hasConceptScore W2187367908C86803240 @default.
- W2187367908 hasConceptScore W2187367908C94487597 @default.
- W2187367908 hasLocation W21873679081 @default.
- W2187367908 hasOpenAccess W2187367908 @default.