Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2203212323> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2203212323 abstract "A prominent finding in public good provision experiments is that contribution exceeds a noncooperative equilibrium. There are at least three possible motivations behind this overcontribution: decision errors, cooperation, and altruism. The aim of this study is to isolate and identify these motivations. The following paragraphs describe our main strategies for building our experimental model. First, in order to discriminate cooperation from altruism, we employ a nonlinear payoff function. If we had used linear payoff functions, as done in most previous studies, such discrimination would be impossible since both cooperative and altruistic motivations appear as full investments. Using a nonlinear payoff function creates one-to-one correspondence between investments and motivations and permits us to differentiate the two motivations. Second, in order to minimize possible decision errors, we prepare a payoff table that is comparable to the standard payoff table from previous studies. The latter is a payoff table in the nonstrategic form, or the whereas the former is a payoff table in the strategic form, or the The most important difference between the two payoff tables is the degree to which subjects can see the interdependence of strategies. In the case of the N table, it is obscure; however, in the S table, subjects can see it clearly because it is a matrix payoff table. Third, we examine how providing information regarding the other's payoff structure to each subject affects his/her decision. Under the complete information condition, each subject knows that the other has the same payoff table as his/her own. Under the incomplete information condition, both subjects are unaware of this fact. Since there are two payoff table conditions and two information conditions, we have four distinct treatments. We summarize the main results as follows. First, when the S table was used, the average individual contributions were not statistically different from the average Nash equilibrium level. On the other hand, when the N table was used, they were significantly greater than the average Nash equilibrium level. This result supports that the understanding of strategic interdependence is crucial for achieving the Nash equilibrium contribution. Second, although the frequencies of Nash motivation were approximately 90% under the S table condition, they were approximately 70% under the N table condition. When subjects knew the other's payoff information, some of them showed cooperative motivation represented by the symmetric Pareto efficient contribution. Altruistic motivation that corresponded to contributing everything was rare under both conditions. These results suggest that the cooperative and altruistic outcomes commonly observed over the past 20 years may be artifacts of the frame of the experimental environment." @default.
- W2203212323 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2203212323 creator A5017527016 @default.
- W2203212323 creator A5018253631 @default.
- W2203212323 creator A5081995261 @default.
- W2203212323 date "2011-12-12" @default.
- W2203212323 modified "2023-09-29" @default.
- W2203212323 title "Isolating and identifying motivations: A voluntary contribution mechanism experiment with interior Nash equilibria" @default.
- W2203212323 cites W1484133690 @default.
- W2203212323 cites W1513359403 @default.
- W2203212323 cites W1533179050 @default.
- W2203212323 cites W1553577417 @default.
- W2203212323 cites W1556452705 @default.
- W2203212323 cites W1576726980 @default.
- W2203212323 cites W1586208727 @default.
- W2203212323 cites W1606176548 @default.
- W2203212323 cites W1976988190 @default.
- W2203212323 cites W1977622357 @default.
- W2203212323 cites W1985321772 @default.
- W2203212323 cites W1987567571 @default.
- W2203212323 cites W2010815901 @default.
- W2203212323 cites W2027038432 @default.
- W2203212323 cites W2033951720 @default.
- W2203212323 cites W2036778766 @default.
- W2203212323 cites W2048489440 @default.
- W2203212323 cites W2048584336 @default.
- W2203212323 cites W2055893782 @default.
- W2203212323 cites W2056598026 @default.
- W2203212323 cites W2059244565 @default.
- W2203212323 cites W2067943613 @default.
- W2203212323 cites W2071031488 @default.
- W2203212323 cites W2093650407 @default.
- W2203212323 cites W2100136304 @default.
- W2203212323 cites W2100667308 @default.
- W2203212323 cites W2105974670 @default.
- W2203212323 cites W2110688506 @default.
- W2203212323 cites W2123850572 @default.
- W2203212323 cites W2149961401 @default.
- W2203212323 cites W2150443705 @default.
- W2203212323 cites W2150519907 @default.
- W2203212323 cites W2161410921 @default.
- W2203212323 cites W2163614477 @default.
- W2203212323 cites W2166368363 @default.
- W2203212323 cites W2801734492 @default.
- W2203212323 cites W3122689917 @default.
- W2203212323 cites W3122867100 @default.
- W2203212323 cites W3124075345 @default.
- W2203212323 cites W3125272355 @default.
- W2203212323 cites W3125943817 @default.
- W2203212323 cites W3125957741 @default.
- W2203212323 cites W2325482650 @default.
- W2203212323 doi "https://doi.org/10.36334/modsim.2011.d1.kumakawa" @default.
- W2203212323 hasPublicationYear "2011" @default.
- W2203212323 type Work @default.
- W2203212323 sameAs 2203212323 @default.
- W2203212323 citedByCount "2" @default.
- W2203212323 countsByYear W22032123232013 @default.
- W2203212323 crossrefType "proceedings-article" @default.
- W2203212323 hasAuthorship W2203212323A5017527016 @default.
- W2203212323 hasAuthorship W2203212323A5018253631 @default.
- W2203212323 hasAuthorship W2203212323A5081995261 @default.
- W2203212323 hasConcept C10138342 @default.
- W2203212323 hasConcept C124101348 @default.
- W2203212323 hasConcept C14036430 @default.
- W2203212323 hasConcept C141824439 @default.
- W2203212323 hasConcept C144237770 @default.
- W2203212323 hasConcept C15744967 @default.
- W2203212323 hasConcept C162324750 @default.
- W2203212323 hasConcept C175444787 @default.
- W2203212323 hasConcept C182306322 @default.
- W2203212323 hasConcept C22171661 @default.
- W2203212323 hasConcept C22349654 @default.
- W2203212323 hasConcept C2780279448 @default.
- W2203212323 hasConcept C32407928 @default.
- W2203212323 hasConcept C41008148 @default.
- W2203212323 hasConcept C45235069 @default.
- W2203212323 hasConcept C46814582 @default.
- W2203212323 hasConcept C47993264 @default.
- W2203212323 hasConcept C77805123 @default.
- W2203212323 hasConcept C78458016 @default.
- W2203212323 hasConcept C86803240 @default.
- W2203212323 hasConceptScore W2203212323C10138342 @default.
- W2203212323 hasConceptScore W2203212323C124101348 @default.
- W2203212323 hasConceptScore W2203212323C14036430 @default.
- W2203212323 hasConceptScore W2203212323C141824439 @default.
- W2203212323 hasConceptScore W2203212323C144237770 @default.
- W2203212323 hasConceptScore W2203212323C15744967 @default.
- W2203212323 hasConceptScore W2203212323C162324750 @default.
- W2203212323 hasConceptScore W2203212323C175444787 @default.
- W2203212323 hasConceptScore W2203212323C182306322 @default.
- W2203212323 hasConceptScore W2203212323C22171661 @default.
- W2203212323 hasConceptScore W2203212323C22349654 @default.
- W2203212323 hasConceptScore W2203212323C2780279448 @default.
- W2203212323 hasConceptScore W2203212323C32407928 @default.
- W2203212323 hasConceptScore W2203212323C41008148 @default.
- W2203212323 hasConceptScore W2203212323C45235069 @default.
- W2203212323 hasConceptScore W2203212323C46814582 @default.
- W2203212323 hasConceptScore W2203212323C47993264 @default.
- W2203212323 hasConceptScore W2203212323C77805123 @default.
- W2203212323 hasConceptScore W2203212323C78458016 @default.