Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2230537518> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2230537518 endingPage "45" @default.
- W2230537518 startingPage "18" @default.
- W2230537518 abstract "Unnatural Graphic Narration:The Panel and the Sublime Christopher D. Kilgore (bio) Over the last ten years, a small cadre of narrative theorists has proposed the concept “unnatural narration” as an antidote to the prescriptive realism they encountered in many structuralist, rhetorical, and cognitive models. Authors, these theorists argue, have a far wider palette of potential techniques than has been acknowledged, and in fact some of the most esoteric methods undergird even apparently “natural” narratives. To date, scholarly work on unnatural narration has focused primarily on prose, but given its emphasis on the differences between “prototypical” conversational narrative and “literary” narrative, the concept seems ripe for application to other media forms. In this essay, I use the “unnatural narrative” concept to reassess the functionalist theories of narration in comics proposed in landmark studies by Scott McCloud and Thierry Groensteen (among others). This reassessment refines the theoretical models for both unnatural and graphic narration by using them to illuminate the unusual narrative capacities of the as-yet underappreciated Dave McKean / Neil Gaiman collaboration, Signal To Noise (1990-2006).1 I conclude, first, that the effects produced by experimental “unnatural” narratives such as Signal To Noise align closely with recent re-formulations of a “cognitive sublime,” by Thomas Weiskel and Porter Abbot. Such formulations envision a cognitive rather than mystical event: a mind in a habitual state meets an overwhelming array of possible [End Page 18] textual meanings, overcomes the momentary shock by interpreting the multiplicity itself, and thereby re-interprets the mind’s own relation to the text, experiencing a further shock of self-consciousness. This kind of maneuver allows readers to gain global insight into texts such as Signal To Noise, without reducing their unnatural properties to one “realistic” story, or sapping their affective power. Secondly, I conclude that there is always already something “unnatural” about the hybrid visual-verbal comics form, and about mediated narrative (that is, narrative other than real-time or face-to-face communication) as such. Many of the factors employed to identify individual narratives as “unnatural” result more from the way we abstract mediated narrative from a conversational context, than from any one text’s conceptual distance from a “prototypical” form. Mediated narratives, in other words, are more different from any prototypical conversational narrative than they are from one another, confirming that the “unnatural” domain is a broad one indeed. “Unnatural narration” encompasses three primary categories. The first, as described by Alber, Iverson, Nielsen, and Richardson, includes “unnatural storyworlds,” which “contain physically or logically impossible scenarios and events” (124). This category focuses on what Thomas Pavel would call the “salient ontology” (Pavel 42, 57)—the story-world elements that depart most markedly from the “real” world—and therefore overlaps significantly with broader studies in speculative fiction.2 But because this sense of the label “unnatural” or “speculative” focuses on story-world contents, it would suit prose narratives like Riddley Walker (1980) or On the Beach (1957) just as well as it would suit Signal To Noise. In order to inquire directly into the unnatural capacities of the graphic medium, then, I will focus on the other two general fields of unnatural narratology: unnatural minds and unnatural acts of narration. Unnatural minds occur when textual details challenge the process by which readers are “typically cued to evoke a mind” (Alber, et al. 120), and might include the fractured consciousness in Shelley Jackson’s Half Life (2007), or the strange chronologies in Mark Z. Danielewski’s Only Revolutions (2006). The third type of unnatural narrativity concerns unnatural acts of narration. This category includes the familiar “omniscient” narrator who knows more than should be humanly possible, as well as strange creatures such as Nielsen’s and Heinze’s omniscient first-person narrators (Nielsen 299; Heinze 284–6). Richardson’s formulation also includes in this category self-contradictory [End Page 19] acts of narration, or “denarration,” and texts composed of contradictory narratives by different characters that seem to concern the same events, but ultimately do not allow the reader to create a coherent story-world—such as Robbe-Grillet’s famous In the Labyrinth (1959). Graphic narratives might simply adapt such strategies from prose, but is there an unnatural..." @default.
- W2230537518 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2230537518 creator A5021338434 @default.
- W2230537518 date "2015-01-01" @default.
- W2230537518 modified "2023-10-17" @default.
- W2230537518 title "Unnatural Graphic Narration: The Panel and the Sublime" @default.
- W2230537518 cites W1493532058 @default.
- W2230537518 cites W1527872513 @default.
- W2230537518 cites W1536258620 @default.
- W2230537518 cites W1558275547 @default.
- W2230537518 cites W158061083 @default.
- W2230537518 cites W1584771591 @default.
- W2230537518 cites W1598025530 @default.
- W2230537518 cites W1605925468 @default.
- W2230537518 cites W181878435 @default.
- W2230537518 cites W1977639890 @default.
- W2230537518 cites W1984645963 @default.
- W2230537518 cites W1995258346 @default.
- W2230537518 cites W1999727766 @default.
- W2230537518 cites W2000477125 @default.
- W2230537518 cites W2002091147 @default.
- W2230537518 cites W2002658673 @default.
- W2230537518 cites W2023230814 @default.
- W2230537518 cites W2024080024 @default.
- W2230537518 cites W2036937632 @default.
- W2230537518 cites W2040619180 @default.
- W2230537518 cites W2040724015 @default.
- W2230537518 cites W2045970910 @default.
- W2230537518 cites W2068741783 @default.
- W2230537518 cites W2073042819 @default.
- W2230537518 cites W2095444845 @default.
- W2230537518 cites W2108925713 @default.
- W2230537518 cites W2123221967 @default.
- W2230537518 cites W2129215867 @default.
- W2230537518 cites W2159211647 @default.
- W2230537518 cites W2319290096 @default.
- W2230537518 cites W2486722056 @default.
- W2230537518 cites W2503454366 @default.
- W2230537518 cites W2800618982 @default.
- W2230537518 cites W2917130359 @default.
- W2230537518 cites W333667837 @default.
- W2230537518 cites W559973919 @default.
- W2230537518 cites W560224352 @default.
- W2230537518 cites W603021720 @default.
- W2230537518 cites W641937701 @default.
- W2230537518 cites W646503399 @default.
- W2230537518 cites W968527600 @default.
- W2230537518 doi "https://doi.org/10.1353/jnt.2015.0006" @default.
- W2230537518 hasPublicationYear "2015" @default.
- W2230537518 type Work @default.
- W2230537518 sameAs 2230537518 @default.
- W2230537518 citedByCount "1" @default.
- W2230537518 countsByYear W22305375182018 @default.
- W2230537518 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2230537518 hasAuthorship W2230537518A5021338434 @default.
- W2230537518 hasConcept C107038049 @default.
- W2230537518 hasConcept C111472728 @default.
- W2230537518 hasConcept C117893075 @default.
- W2230537518 hasConcept C124952713 @default.
- W2230537518 hasConcept C12772571 @default.
- W2230537518 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W2230537518 hasConcept C142362112 @default.
- W2230537518 hasConcept C192562157 @default.
- W2230537518 hasConcept C199033989 @default.
- W2230537518 hasConcept C2776717531 @default.
- W2230537518 hasConcept C529099274 @default.
- W2230537518 hasConcept C63985673 @default.
- W2230537518 hasConcept C98369314 @default.
- W2230537518 hasConceptScore W2230537518C107038049 @default.
- W2230537518 hasConceptScore W2230537518C111472728 @default.
- W2230537518 hasConceptScore W2230537518C117893075 @default.
- W2230537518 hasConceptScore W2230537518C124952713 @default.
- W2230537518 hasConceptScore W2230537518C12772571 @default.
- W2230537518 hasConceptScore W2230537518C138885662 @default.
- W2230537518 hasConceptScore W2230537518C142362112 @default.
- W2230537518 hasConceptScore W2230537518C192562157 @default.
- W2230537518 hasConceptScore W2230537518C199033989 @default.
- W2230537518 hasConceptScore W2230537518C2776717531 @default.
- W2230537518 hasConceptScore W2230537518C529099274 @default.
- W2230537518 hasConceptScore W2230537518C63985673 @default.
- W2230537518 hasConceptScore W2230537518C98369314 @default.
- W2230537518 hasIssue "1" @default.
- W2230537518 hasLocation W22305375181 @default.
- W2230537518 hasOpenAccess W2230537518 @default.
- W2230537518 hasPrimaryLocation W22305375181 @default.
- W2230537518 hasRelatedWork W1976390626 @default.
- W2230537518 hasRelatedWork W1993816146 @default.
- W2230537518 hasRelatedWork W2355810782 @default.
- W2230537518 hasRelatedWork W2375320413 @default.
- W2230537518 hasRelatedWork W2391363454 @default.
- W2230537518 hasRelatedWork W2393727725 @default.
- W2230537518 hasRelatedWork W2570654734 @default.
- W2230537518 hasRelatedWork W2621114289 @default.
- W2230537518 hasRelatedWork W2794754358 @default.
- W2230537518 hasRelatedWork W3102740701 @default.
- W2230537518 hasVolume "45" @default.
- W2230537518 isParatext "false" @default.
- W2230537518 isRetracted "false" @default.