Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2236405957> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2236405957 abstract "Author(s): Matthes, Erich | Advisor(s): Kolodny, Niko; Wallace, R. Jay | Abstract: We value many things for their historical significance--for instance, the Parthenon, Gettysburg, the redwood forests, and the tea ceremony. While they may also be beautiful, educational, or useful, we often value them simply in virtue of their historical properties. This mode of valuation carries with it a suite of common assumptions: what we value for its history is irreplaceable, it demands preservation, and we should value it only if we have a personal stake in its history. My dissertation interrogates these seemingly intuitive commitments, and explores the moral, evaluative, and political consequences of rethinking them. I develop an account of the norms governing our interactions with historically valuable objects and places, yielding an improved understanding of the values latent in such diverse examples as heirlooms, relationships, artworks, artifacts, and historic sites. It also, I argue, sheds light on other important sources of value, including persons and the natural environment.It is often thought that things worth valuing for their historical properties are necessarily irreplaceable, and that this fact makes a defining contribution to their distinctive value. For example, no candidate substitute can be valuable in the same way as my father's ring. Against this widespread view, I argue that a plausible understanding of historical significance entails that many things we value for their histories are not irreplaceable after all. What makes historically significant things worth valuing is not their irreplaceability, but rather the connection with the past that they afford.This raises the difficult question of how we can best realize a connection with the past. I argue that historical value, like value in general, fundamentally involves reasons to engage appropriately with valuable things: that is, to respond to them in a manner sensitive to the specific ways in which they are valuable, for instance, by viewing a painting, playing a sport, or savoring a fine meal. This contrasts with the views of many philosophers, who believe that the value of objects fundamentally involves reasons to preserve them. As I argue, reasons for preservation are subordinate to and explained by reasons for engagement--there is no reason to preserve even the Mona Lisa if no one can have the opportunity to engage with it. Recognizing the centrality of engagement in evaluative theory and practice has extensive implications, both in historical cases and beyond.Consider the distinction between personal and impersonal value. It is natural to think that some objects (such as family heirlooms) have merely personal value, whereas others (such as the pyramids or the Grand Canyon) have value for anyone. But how exactly are we to understand this distinction? Traditional accounts suggest that things are impersonally valuable if they would be valued from a suitably detached perspective. But I show that this criterion does not reliably identify things of impersonal value. On the alternative framework I propose, an object's value is impersonal if and only if it is appropriate (and therefore evaluatively permissible) for anyone to engage with it. Only a few people have reason to engage with a family heirloom, whereas the pyramids are candidates for universal engagement. Moreover, this account leaves open the possibility that the reasons that each individual has to value the pyramids can vary with that individual's particular history, interests, and capacities, unlike the shapeless agent-neutral reasons of the traditional view. Finally, I argue that the historical mode of valuation is often properly understood as a kind of aesthetic valuing. While many twentieth century philosophers have acknowledged the importance of art historical properties to aesthetic evaluation, I distinguish between art historical properties and the more general historically significant properties that are found both within and beyond the artworld. I then argue that these historical properties can be accommodated on a number of influential accounts of aesthetic value, and indeed, that they comprise an important dimension in aesthetic experience. This helps cement the extension of aesthetic inquiry beyond the artworld, and articulates a familiar yet surprising way in which we engage with the past." @default.
- W2236405957 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2236405957 creator A5025961193 @default.
- W2236405957 date "2013-01-01" @default.
- W2236405957 modified "2023-09-27" @default.
- W2236405957 title "Engaging with the Past: Essays on History, Value, and Practical Reason" @default.
- W2236405957 cites W1492308798 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W1495752346 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W1528100045 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W1542644658 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W1552740712 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W1558905324 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W1581147604 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W1600019194 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W1762458952 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W179447297 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W1892337234 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W1964356493 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W1964453631 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W1971707653 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W1972969680 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W1972980869 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W1974609519 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W1975043972 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W1983287532 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W1984743919 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W1986330957 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W1987608986 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W1988978047 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W1989542192 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W1989898242 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W1991609225 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W1992164204 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W1993242876 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W1997093225 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2001478678 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2002993931 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2007249831 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2007286247 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2008253770 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2008942963 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2010411976 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2010752228 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2020114666 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2025247788 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2026317106 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2028858878 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2029525431 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2041872473 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2044608255 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2060629887 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2063856316 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2070466018 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2077618083 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2080069809 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2081910628 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2081953606 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2084864309 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2088724026 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2104281606 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2123742276 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2126023237 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2128927091 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2131856109 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2139258643 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2140228380 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2155684357 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2156146807 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2156667598 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2167644634 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2171506198 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2250285100 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2277423587 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2324627472 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2326408471 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2329625478 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2330370575 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2332133844 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2334809073 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2464459453 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2484552835 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2493305878 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2496455427 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2514536450 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2518080250 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2625160211 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2797399619 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W2890847991 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W3124679894 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W3144911456 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W437384789 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W636494210 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W644353465 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W847521723 @default.
- W2236405957 cites W99895778 @default.
- W2236405957 hasPublicationYear "2013" @default.
- W2236405957 type Work @default.
- W2236405957 sameAs 2236405957 @default.
- W2236405957 citedByCount "0" @default.
- W2236405957 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.