Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2243376361> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2243376361 endingPage "50" @default.
- W2243376361 startingPage "23" @default.
- W2243376361 abstract "Drama without Performance and Two Old English Anomalies Francis J. Finan The history of drama in England has customarily been traced back to the apparent enactment of a Latin text, the Visitatio sepulchri, in the second half of the tenth century. Vernacular drama has been tracked to the twelfth century, as typified by the Anglo-Norman Le Mystère (or Jeu) d’Adam. While recitative and mimesis likely accompanied storytelling in Old English, the Anglo-Saxon period is considered devoid of any vernacular drama. As M. Bradford Bedingfield points out, the words Anglo-Saxon and drama are rarely linked.1 Anomalies in Old English literature, two dialogues within the first work of the Exeter Book closely resemble in structure the Visitatio sepulchri. Despite this correspondence, these works, unlike the Visitatio, are not marked for performance. It is, however, because of this comparability that I argue here that drama as a literary form does exist in Old English, if drama is also defined in terms of text alone, rather than just performance. My argument will begin with a discussion of what constitutes medieval drama. I will analyze the feasibility of also defining drama strictly in textual terms from the perspectives of medieval European drama scholarship and performance studies. After a close examination of these dialogues, I will show the structural parallels with the Visitatio. Finally, with my reassessment of certain texts as dramas, I will draw the resultant implications for the history of medieval English drama. I Andrew Hughes speaks for many who contend that performance is essential for a drama “to achieve its full impact.”2 Sheila Lindenbaum asserts that medievalists have for a long time been preoccupied with performance because of their belief that it “accesses behavioral [End Page 23] regimes and other intangibles of medieval culture which a text cannot convey.”3 Thus, medieval dramatic texts that are marked for performance are commonly anthologized as dramas, while comparable texts without any indication of enactment are marginalized and relegated to the merely dramatic category. They are excluded from the canon of dramas. Such works are commonly described, sometimes pejoratively, as “reading texts,” “play texts,” “dramatic scripts,” “liturgical observances,” or “closet dramas.” Such a differentia begs the question of what actually constitutes drama. This question has long vexed students of the Middle Ages. When is a creative work transformed from cult, ritual, or even other literary forms into a drama? For drama editor David Bevington, the search for a precise answer is “a baffling quest.”4 Some scholars have answered this question, in part, by refraining from using the word “drama” to refer to certain early dramatic works. Contrasting them with the dramas of a few centuries later,5 Bedingfield believes that “dramatic ritual” is a more appropriate nomenclature.6 Lawrence M. Clopper distinguishes “liturgical representations” from dramas.7 While Michal Kobialka prefers “representational practice,”8 Nils Holgar Petersen considers “devotional biblical representation,” or some very similar descriptor, a more adequate identifier than “liturgical drama.”9 The evidence of performance requirement recalls the different conditions of extant medieval manuscripts, which, in turn, incites Carol Symes to ask, “How many plays have escaped notice because they have been deprived of their apparatus by careless copyists?”10 I contend that performance as the chief discriminator is also inadequate because it focuses upon what is extrinsic to the dramatic text. The text of a drama and its performance, albeit often seen as interdependent, are ultimately discrete entities. To expand the dramatic canon—beyond those dramas known through their enactment—so that it is more representative, there must be a rethinking of how a particular text, independent of performance, can also be a drama. Clearly there is a precedent for this in how other genres with performance qualities are identified. A lyric text, for example, is recognized as a lyric whether or not it is performed or marked for performance. Certain literary elements are intrinsic to the texts of individual dramas and separate from performance, although they might guide enactment. Gerald F. Else points out that the title characters of [End Page 24] Shakespeare’s Othello and King Lear are, irrespective of any costuming, necessarily a blackamoor and an old king, respectively: The concept..." @default.
- W2243376361 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2243376361 creator A5062097163 @default.
- W2243376361 date "2014-01-01" @default.
- W2243376361 modified "2023-10-17" @default.
- W2243376361 title "Drama without Performance and Two Old English Anomalies" @default.
- W2243376361 cites W103704558 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W1480444057 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W1490612615 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W1513875112 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W1516410319 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W1518283394 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W1531138486 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W1536917307 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W1567616430 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W1569398727 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W1576632330 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W1578474063 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W1582737043 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W1604765312 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W191880096 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W1964147829 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W1967935645 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W1973896673 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W1975150208 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W1975910911 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W1986320902 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W1994486526 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W1999618942 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W1999795308 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2000002928 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2005397663 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2011785150 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2012368312 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2013785140 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2016195287 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2020248778 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2021244022 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2029752378 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2030227467 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2032361012 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2036775475 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2046273130 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2047367461 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2051907272 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2053957408 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2056602686 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2073003633 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2073889862 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2090034882 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2091733285 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2092595532 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2135340511 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2151666737 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2152874482 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2209185092 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2262965896 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2314909188 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2315230505 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2323619372 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2331719462 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2334283225 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2335768620 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2483436729 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2501930568 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2506929491 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2512416779 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2527824499 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2767417665 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2795442669 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2797096495 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2797809499 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2801931745 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2802385421 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2890647962 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2905178453 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W2985925356 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W3165585286 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W359282660 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W561877582 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W564745402 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W567682860 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W574354332 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W577217694 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W581567305 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W586885604 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W591261953 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W598916655 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W603605695 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W606550092 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W637612674 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W68792273 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W814162022 @default.
- W2243376361 cites W988854261 @default.
- W2243376361 doi "https://doi.org/10.1353/mdi.2014.0005" @default.
- W2243376361 hasPublicationYear "2014" @default.
- W2243376361 type Work @default.
- W2243376361 sameAs 2243376361 @default.