FRINK Linked Data Fragments server

Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2265985380> ?p ?o ?g. }

• W2265985380 abstract "The three most important views in contemporary analytic jurisprudence - namely, inclusive legal positivism (Hart, Coleman, Waluchow), exclusive legal positivism (Raz, Shapiro), and non-positivist views arising from Dworkin's work on adjudication - are currently in a complex logical gridlock. I do not just mean by this that the views themselves are inconsistent; that, after all, is to be expected. I mean to draw attention to the further fact that each view is motivated, in part, by insights into important aspects of the law, which, as things presently stand, would appear to defy harmonization with the rest. To wit: (1) the law purports to provide us with a distinctive source of practical guidance, (2) we nevertheless sometimes identify the law's directives by using moral insight, and (3) the law is deeply bound up in conventions, and legal judgments are often true or false by convention. This Article develops a version of inclusive legal positivism that accommodates all of these important features of the law. It begins by canvassing important contributions that the exclusive legal positivists - namely, Joseph Raz and Scott Shapiro - have made to our understanding of the law, and explaining why these contributions would appear to render inclusive legal positivism internally inconsistent. It then argues that these contributions can be absorbed without generating any such inconsistencies if we accept a novel account of legal obligation (and a corresponding account of legal authority) that makes reference to what Stephen Darwall has recently called the standpoint. There are, moreover, a number of important philosophical reasons to favor this account of obligation over the alternatives in the current literature. This version of inclusive legal positivism can also absorb a number of Dworkin's important insights into the law, which he has taken to warrant a wholesale rejection legal positivism. The Article continues by arguing that, while there were important tensions in Hart's views, Hart himself implicitly understood the importance of reference to something like the second-person in accounting for obligation throughout his career. Indeed, his texts suggest that he became even clearer by the end. What he lacked - and what we have all lacked until now - was a clear account of what Darwall has recently called the standpoint to articulate this view. Hence, the view developed here may not only be an independently viable form of inclusive legal positivism; it may also represent the best available development of Hart's core views and jurisprudential commitments.This paper is based on an earlier idea paper. The ideas have been substantially revised, partly in light of comments from Yale's Center for Law and Philosophy and the Southern California Law and Philosophy Discussion Group." @default.
• W2265985380 created "2016-06-24" @default.
• W2265985380 creator A5002479887 @default.
• W2265985380 date "2007-02-07" @default.
• W2265985380 modified "2023-09-28" @default.
• W2265985380 title "Hart's Response to Exclusive Legal Positivism" @default.
• W2265985380 hasPublicationYear "2007" @default.
• W2265985380 type Work @default.
• W2265985380 sameAs 2265985380 @default.
• W2265985380 citedByCount "0" @default.
• W2265985380 crossrefType "posted-content" @default.
• W2265985380 hasAuthorship W2265985380A5002479887 @default.
• W2265985380 hasConcept C111472728 @default.
• W2265985380 hasConcept C128706718 @default.
• W2265985380 hasConcept C131330614 @default.
• W2265985380 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
• W2265985380 hasConcept C144024400 @default.
• W2265985380 hasConcept C149209484 @default.
• W2265985380 hasConcept C1556254 @default.
• W2265985380 hasConcept C162040827 @default.
• W2265985380 hasConcept C167633797 @default.
• W2265985380 hasConcept C170692843 @default.
• W2265985380 hasConcept C17744445 @default.
• W2265985380 hasConcept C190253527 @default.
• W2265985380 hasConcept C199539241 @default.
• W2265985380 hasConcept C204434341 @default.
• W2265985380 hasConcept C2778447849 @default.
• W2265985380 hasConcept C31264824 @default.
• W2265985380 hasConcept C71043370 @default.
• W2265985380 hasConcept C75011936 @default.
• W2265985380 hasConceptScore W2265985380C111472728 @default.
• W2265985380 hasConceptScore W2265985380C128706718 @default.
• W2265985380 hasConceptScore W2265985380C131330614 @default.
• W2265985380 hasConceptScore W2265985380C138885662 @default.
• W2265985380 hasConceptScore W2265985380C144024400 @default.
• W2265985380 hasConceptScore W2265985380C149209484 @default.
• W2265985380 hasConceptScore W2265985380C1556254 @default.
• W2265985380 hasConceptScore W2265985380C162040827 @default.
• W2265985380 hasConceptScore W2265985380C167633797 @default.
• W2265985380 hasConceptScore W2265985380C170692843 @default.
• W2265985380 hasConceptScore W2265985380C17744445 @default.
• W2265985380 hasConceptScore W2265985380C190253527 @default.
• W2265985380 hasConceptScore W2265985380C199539241 @default.
• W2265985380 hasConceptScore W2265985380C204434341 @default.
• W2265985380 hasConceptScore W2265985380C2778447849 @default.
• W2265985380 hasConceptScore W2265985380C31264824 @default.
• W2265985380 hasConceptScore W2265985380C71043370 @default.
• W2265985380 hasConceptScore W2265985380C75011936 @default.
• W2265985380 hasOpenAccess W2265985380 @default.
• W2265985380 hasRelatedWork W1543792342 @default.
• W2265985380 hasRelatedWork W1654796141 @default.
• W2265985380 hasRelatedWork W1781689989 @default.
• W2265985380 hasRelatedWork W1905411239 @default.
• W2265985380 hasRelatedWork W1956808466 @default.
• W2265985380 hasRelatedWork W2065681694 @default.
• W2265985380 hasRelatedWork W2076354770 @default.
• W2265985380 hasRelatedWork W2114549367 @default.
• W2265985380 hasRelatedWork W2152717085 @default.
• W2265985380 hasRelatedWork W2241387588 @default.
• W2265985380 hasRelatedWork W2253971358 @default.
• W2265985380 hasRelatedWork W2256615650 @default.
• W2265985380 hasRelatedWork W2262659060 @default.
• W2265985380 hasRelatedWork W2315389212 @default.
• W2265985380 hasRelatedWork W2334252109 @default.
• W2265985380 hasRelatedWork W2476940575 @default.
• W2265985380 hasRelatedWork W3043887930 @default.
• W2265985380 hasRelatedWork W3123420973 @default.
• W2265985380 hasRelatedWork W330662170 @default.
• W2265985380 hasRelatedWork W1694122718 @default.
• W2265985380 isParatext "false" @default.
• W2265985380 isRetracted "false" @default.
• W2265985380 magId "2265985380" @default.
• W2265985380 workType "article" @default.