Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2300311369> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2300311369 endingPage "162" @default.
- W2300311369 startingPage "126" @default.
- W2300311369 abstract "Policy Points: In situations of scientific uncertainty, public health interventions, such as counseling for HIV infection, sometimes must be implemented before obtaining evidence of efficacy. The history of HIV counseling and testing, which served as the cornerstone of HIV prevention efforts at the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) for a quarter of a century, illustrates the influence of institutional resistance on public health decision making and the challenge of de-implementing well-established programs. Context In 1985, amid uncertainty about the accuracy of the new test for HIV, public health officials at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and AIDS activists agreed that counseling should always be provided both before and after testing to ensure that patients were tested voluntarily and understood the meaning of their results. As the “exceptionalist” perspective that framed HIV in the early years began to recede, the purpose of HIV test counseling shifted over the next 30 years from emphasizing consent, to providing information, to encouraging behavioral change. With this increasing emphasis on prevention, HIV test counseling faced mounting doubts about whether it “worked.” The CDC finally discontinued its preferred test counseling approach in October 2014. Methods Drawing on key informant interviews with current and former CDC officials, behavioral scientists, AIDS activists, and others, along with archival material, news reports, and scientific and governmental publications, we examined the origins, development, and decline of the CDC's “counseling and testing” paradigm for HIV prevention. Findings Disagreements within the CDC emerged by the 1990s over whether test counseling could be justified on the basis of efficacy and cost. Resistance to the prospect of policy change by supporters of test counseling in the CDC, gay activists for whom counseling carried important ethical and symbolic meanings, and community organizations dependent on federal funding made it difficult for the CDC to de-implement the practice. Conclusions Analyses of changes in public health policy that emphasize the impact of research evidence produced in experimental or epidemiological inquiries may overlook key social and political factors involving resistance to deimplementation that powerfully shape the relationship between science and policy." @default.
- W2300311369 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2300311369 creator A5007607953 @default.
- W2300311369 creator A5011189269 @default.
- W2300311369 creator A5039492004 @default.
- W2300311369 date "2016-03-01" @default.
- W2300311369 modified "2023-09-23" @default.
- W2300311369 title "Evidence and the Politics of Deimplementation: The Rise and Decline of the “Counseling and Testing” Paradigm for HIV Prevention at the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention" @default.
- W2300311369 cites W146779504 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W152141778 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W1968616446 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W1971406945 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W1974504774 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W1986146511 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W1993198628 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W1996427162 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W1997554428 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W2002150094 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W2007097354 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W2010361572 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W2034285001 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W2042493899 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W2049772547 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W2060196754 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W2064527317 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W2070316010 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W2081138234 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W2081753990 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W2086061035 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W2108599363 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W2117057469 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W2121311063 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W2121362101 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W2125743019 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W2129646044 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W2131552460 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W2149206813 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W2149730917 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W2151991904 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W2152505869 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W2153335467 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W2158216795 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W2159478271 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W2170912671 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W2172067903 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W2329992800 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W2405062379 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W2412501552 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W2436209296 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W2486899377 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W2773236800 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W3125239028 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W4207010854 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W4214751649 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W4231454826 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W4236409059 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W4250065327 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W4290322280 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W4290365548 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W4290367206 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W4298216421 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W4298293558 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W4298836340 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W4299412998 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W4371184 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W9722512 @default.
- W2300311369 cites W2423341951 @default.
- W2300311369 doi "https://doi.org/10.1111/1468-0009.12183" @default.
- W2300311369 hasPubMedCentralId "https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/4941977" @default.
- W2300311369 hasPubMedId "https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26994712" @default.
- W2300311369 hasPublicationYear "2016" @default.
- W2300311369 type Work @default.
- W2300311369 sameAs 2300311369 @default.
- W2300311369 citedByCount "23" @default.
- W2300311369 countsByYear W23003113692017 @default.
- W2300311369 countsByYear W23003113692018 @default.
- W2300311369 countsByYear W23003113692019 @default.
- W2300311369 countsByYear W23003113692020 @default.
- W2300311369 countsByYear W23003113692021 @default.
- W2300311369 countsByYear W23003113692022 @default.
- W2300311369 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2300311369 hasAuthorship W2300311369A5007607953 @default.
- W2300311369 hasAuthorship W2300311369A5011189269 @default.
- W2300311369 hasAuthorship W2300311369A5039492004 @default.
- W2300311369 hasBestOaLocation W23003113692 @default.
- W2300311369 hasConcept C138816342 @default.
- W2300311369 hasConcept C14262774 @default.
- W2300311369 hasConcept C142724271 @default.
- W2300311369 hasConcept C151730666 @default.
- W2300311369 hasConcept C15744967 @default.
- W2300311369 hasConcept C159110408 @default.
- W2300311369 hasConcept C27415008 @default.
- W2300311369 hasConcept C2777267654 @default.
- W2300311369 hasConcept C2779343474 @default.
- W2300311369 hasConcept C512399662 @default.
- W2300311369 hasConcept C71924100 @default.
- W2300311369 hasConcept C74909509 @default.
- W2300311369 hasConcept C86803240 @default.