Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2313868051> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2313868051 abstract "I wish to thank Dr. Ward (1992) for his thoughtful critique of my earlier article (Michaud 1990). It is often constructive to contrast the predictions of models that differ in conceptual approach and basic assumptions. The model I proposed was based on the assumption that an insect is capable of completing development on a variety of plant species. I then investigated conditions that might preclude elimination of all but one host type. Given that the majority of insect herbivores are dietary specialists, it seemed appropriate to examine conditions which might select against specialization. The model proposed by Ward assumes that an optimal host exists and then examines conditions which might select for inclusion of a less suitable host in the diet. Despite this difference in approach, both models attempt to identify conditions that select for and against polyphagous habits. While the fitness of ovipositing insects may often be more limited by lifespan than by fecundity, oviposition behaviour is not moulded by time constraints alone. The model I presented was specifically formulated to be time-independent for the sake of simplicity. I assumed that the insect lives long enough to encounter a variety of hosts and to distribute its offspring among them such that each plant species contributes a distinct term to the insect fitness function. No assumption is made that any one host species is always more suitable than another, only that there are two or more acceptable I would concede it is more appropriate to remove host abundance from the suitability term and replace it with an encounter rate or some probability function that acts as a constraint on insect behaviour independent of host quality. However, this change does not alter the general implications of the model for host utilization strategies. Ward (1992) argues that the most important focus in host range evolution is the trade-off between the need to maximize offspring fitness by seeking the most suitable host, and the need to find a host before the forager's resources are exhausted. It is true that maximizing parental fitness does not always equate to maximizing individual offspring fitness (Wiklund 1975, Parker and Courtney 1984) but this may occur for reasons other than time constraints. Females can be observed to place eggs on hosts of low suitability for offspring even when the optimal host is available (Chew 1977, Wiklund 1981, Stanton 1984, Shreeve 1986). As Singer (1984) suggests ...behaviour patterns that maximize the fitness of the parent may not involve preference for the most suitable larval hosts. Thomas (1987) provides evidence that mulitiple host use can also arise in the absence of variation for species preference among individuals when there exists sufficient intraspecific variation in host quality. It is an a priori assumption of Ward's model that selection 'recognize' a superior host, i.e. that there exists an inequality in average suitability between the host species or host types that are distinguishable by the foraging insect. In fact, the 'optimal' host species may vary from one habitat to the next, or from one season to the next. The role of habitat characterisitics in influencing host selection has often been recognized (Tahvanainen 1983, Shreeve 1986, Courtney and Chew 1987). For example, suppose an insect forages in two habitats, HI and H2, and exploits two host types, A and B which yield fitness returns WA and WB respectively such that in Hi, WA > WB and in H2, WA < WB. This is conceivable if, for example, there exists some predator associated with A in H2 but not in HI. It is therefore evident that habitat differences could favour multiple host utilization and I question Ward's general assumption that spatial heterogeneity cannot select for polyphagy. In some situations the information neccessary to assess host quality relative to available alternatives may be lacking. If host-specific sources of larval mortality are occasionally high on each host type, the best strate-" @default.
- W2313868051 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2313868051 creator A5084453892 @default.
- W2313868051 date "1992-09-01" @default.
- W2313868051 modified "2023-09-27" @default.
- W2313868051 title "Further Considerations on Host Range Evolution in Herbivorous Insects" @default.
- W2313868051 cites W1920059663 @default.
- W2313868051 cites W1964470929 @default.
- W2313868051 cites W1969834203 @default.
- W2313868051 cites W1985707787 @default.
- W2313868051 cites W1990446962 @default.
- W2313868051 cites W1996968315 @default.
- W2313868051 cites W2002421955 @default.
- W2313868051 cites W2004579048 @default.
- W2313868051 cites W2017177160 @default.
- W2313868051 cites W2018853737 @default.
- W2313868051 cites W2021003305 @default.
- W2313868051 cites W2022322759 @default.
- W2313868051 cites W2024712957 @default.
- W2313868051 cites W2035279157 @default.
- W2313868051 cites W2045291252 @default.
- W2313868051 cites W2051625405 @default.
- W2313868051 cites W2056497615 @default.
- W2313868051 cites W2063126254 @default.
- W2313868051 cites W2065740780 @default.
- W2313868051 cites W2066672509 @default.
- W2313868051 cites W2087995620 @default.
- W2313868051 cites W2088178409 @default.
- W2313868051 cites W2095039580 @default.
- W2313868051 cites W2119511002 @default.
- W2313868051 cites W2140667840 @default.
- W2313868051 cites W2143607674 @default.
- W2313868051 cites W2315965226 @default.
- W2313868051 cites W2316943719 @default.
- W2313868051 cites W2317170939 @default.
- W2313868051 cites W2319054223 @default.
- W2313868051 cites W2320678050 @default.
- W2313868051 cites W2327470962 @default.
- W2313868051 cites W2327784759 @default.
- W2313868051 cites W2332437947 @default.
- W2313868051 cites W2499485387 @default.
- W2313868051 cites W9892590 @default.
- W2313868051 doi "https://doi.org/10.2307/3545178" @default.
- W2313868051 hasPublicationYear "1992" @default.
- W2313868051 type Work @default.
- W2313868051 sameAs 2313868051 @default.
- W2313868051 citedByCount "1" @default.
- W2313868051 countsByYear W23138680512016 @default.
- W2313868051 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2313868051 hasAuthorship W2313868051A5084453892 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConcept C111472728 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConcept C111919701 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConcept C121332964 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConcept C126831891 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConcept C136197465 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConcept C144024400 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConcept C149923435 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConcept C154945302 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConcept C165287380 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConcept C18903297 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConcept C2776372474 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConcept C2777612826 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConcept C2778701210 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConcept C2908647359 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConcept C41008148 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConcept C46325548 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConcept C61797465 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConcept C62520636 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConcept C67283656 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConcept C78458016 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConcept C86803240 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConcept C95812059 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConcept C98045186 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConceptScore W2313868051C111472728 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConceptScore W2313868051C111919701 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConceptScore W2313868051C121332964 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConceptScore W2313868051C126831891 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConceptScore W2313868051C136197465 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConceptScore W2313868051C138885662 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConceptScore W2313868051C144024400 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConceptScore W2313868051C149923435 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConceptScore W2313868051C154945302 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConceptScore W2313868051C165287380 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConceptScore W2313868051C18903297 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConceptScore W2313868051C2776372474 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConceptScore W2313868051C2777612826 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConceptScore W2313868051C2778701210 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConceptScore W2313868051C2908647359 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConceptScore W2313868051C41008148 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConceptScore W2313868051C46325548 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConceptScore W2313868051C61797465 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConceptScore W2313868051C62520636 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConceptScore W2313868051C67283656 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConceptScore W2313868051C78458016 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConceptScore W2313868051C86803240 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConceptScore W2313868051C95812059 @default.
- W2313868051 hasConceptScore W2313868051C98045186 @default.
- W2313868051 hasLocation W23138680511 @default.
- W2313868051 hasOpenAccess W2313868051 @default.