Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2316691517> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2316691517 endingPage "553" @default.
- W2316691517 startingPage "553" @default.
- W2316691517 abstract "The step in cladistic analysis that has received least attention is delimitation of char- acter states, there usually being little justification for their delimitation. It is generally assumed that states of cladistic characters are discrete, even when variation is quantitative. I show here that a majority of the character states of obviously quantitative characters used in lower-level cladistic studies in botany over the last generation are ambiguous even when ingroup variation alone is analyzed. Consideration of variation in the outgroup may compromize either the states recognized in the ingroup and/or the polarity that they are subsequently assigned. Furthermore, many so- called qualitative characters are based on a quantitative phenomenological base filtered through the reified semantic discontinuities of botanical terminology; such characters face the problems of their more obviously quantitative relatives. Methods for delimiting states within quantitative char- acters are examined. Some produce gaps in the variation by redefining the character, scoring the intermediates in a distinctive fashion, performing phylogenetic analyses within the terminal taxa, or changing the hierarchical level at which the variation is evaluated. Others produce states by manipulation of the statistical properties of the variation of the ensemble of taxa being studied. These latter methods often allow greater resolution of the phylogeny, but at the cost of lowering the significance of the most parsimonious tree. The underlying assumptions of the two sets of methods are briefly analyzed. Problems manifest in the division of continuous variation into char- acter states suggest a reappraisal of the early steps of cladistic analysis; in practice, character states often seem to be delimited in conjunction with developing ideas of the phylogeny, rather than in a step prior to a phylogenetic analysis. It is recommended that character states be delimited by carefully analyzed discontinuities (not necessarily absolute gaps) in the variation, attention having been paid to variation in the outgroup, and that morphological characters in general are assumed to be quantitative unless demonstrated otherwise. Explicit justification for the delimitation of char- acter states should be given as a matter of course in all phylogenetic studies." @default.
- W2316691517 created "2016-06-24" @default.
- W2316691517 creator A5071150995 @default.
- W2316691517 date "1991-07-01" @default.
- W2316691517 modified "2023-10-18" @default.
- W2316691517 title "Character States, Morphological Variation, and Phylogenetic Analysis: A Review" @default.
- W2316691517 cites W112013889 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W164887046 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W1660883763 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W1782312652 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W1904144572 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W1969154557 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W1979068342 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W1990486063 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W1996942618 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W1998763674 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2004526095 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2011268288 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2013410948 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2020524544 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2050001230 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2050917224 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2055568252 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2056394944 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2063034889 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2067123840 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2071530460 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2071598874 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2075187698 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2077953844 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2082598566 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2083193770 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2083306179 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2085986053 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2088901094 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2091227149 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2110224102 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2113673052 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2114950126 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2118942683 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2149243707 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2160109028 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2169444595 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2304691950 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2314011714 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2314036365 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2314713711 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2314810605 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2315753446 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2315840448 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2317744394 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2318271345 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2319189809 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2319193171 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2320670280 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2320929886 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2321520959 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2323706991 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2324974923 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2325104812 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2325972454 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2326153576 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2326175971 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2326637888 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2327165228 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2329218760 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2330601420 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2330719889 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2331060153 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2335430092 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2460522778 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2467881305 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2469782197 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2505440491 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2506868775 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2613247376 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W271455568 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2796990190 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2800000679 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W288427366 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W3184837389 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W404146969 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W564248318 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W962046594 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W2299025057 @default.
- W2316691517 cites W3191547041 @default.
- W2316691517 doi "https://doi.org/10.2307/2419343" @default.
- W2316691517 hasPublicationYear "1991" @default.
- W2316691517 type Work @default.
- W2316691517 sameAs 2316691517 @default.
- W2316691517 citedByCount "270" @default.
- W2316691517 countsByYear W23166915172012 @default.
- W2316691517 countsByYear W23166915172013 @default.
- W2316691517 countsByYear W23166915172014 @default.
- W2316691517 countsByYear W23166915172015 @default.
- W2316691517 countsByYear W23166915172016 @default.
- W2316691517 countsByYear W23166915172017 @default.
- W2316691517 countsByYear W23166915172018 @default.