Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2473607902> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2473607902 abstract "This is a case study of diagrams in a field of biological mechanism research (apoptosis), revealing that mechanism diagrams play a crucial role in the practice of developing mechanistic explanations for cell biology. This thesis supports and extends the existing literature in the following aspects: the relationship between scientific representation and practice (Daston and Galison, 2007), inter-field and inter-level integration in biological practice of mechanism research (Bechtel, 2006; Craver and Darden, 2013), and the assertive and engaging power of diagrams (Bender and Marrinan, 2010; Wood, 1992, 2010). The methodology is composed of two parts: quantitative and qualitative. The quantification draws the comprehensive patterns of diagram use via analysing the coverage of diagrams. The qualitative part analyses three layers of the diagrams: visual element, composition, and style. This part contextualises the diagrams in four senses: source of ideas, perspective, adjacent text, scope of research. The results and the interpretation of results are also composed of quantitative and qualitative parts. The quantitative part shows a noticeable prevalence of two themes of diagrams: object and mechanism. The former reflects an interest in manipulating entities. The latter reflects an interest in integration of, and interaction between, different perspectives. The relative changes in the coverage of these two themes suggest a shift in the focus of practice from manipulation of biological entities toward inter-field interaction between heterogeneous perspectives. The qualitative part contains a central argument and several interesting discoveries. The central argument is that mechanism diagrams synthesise heterogeneity and thus have the power to assert novel ideas and engage real-world practice. The heterogeneity of perspectives is embedded in the practice of developing the cell models. The term “synthesis” means that novel meanings emerge from the integration of existing perspectives. This novelty of meanings attributes to the assertive power of mechanism diagrams. The engaging power facilitates interaction amongst the component perspectives, which is an important feature of mechanism research. In sum, this argument can explain the increasing reliance upon diagrams found in the quantitative results. The other interesting qualitative discoveries include but are not limited to the following. Firstly, biological diagrams can go beyond visual resemblance to entities. Secondly, there are many creative ways of making diagrams, such as importing visual vocabulary from non-specialist areas and modular use of visual elements. These creative ways show that visual conventions in biological diagrams are not given but undergo evolution, probably responding to the growing complexity of ideas. Thirdly, the evolution of biological visualisation is not merely driven by development of technology but embodies the interaction between ideas and technological advancement. The conclusion of this study treats mechanism diagrams as both epistemological and communicative devices acting in the research dynamics. The communication is part of the processes of knowing and intervening, taking place both horizontally and longitudinally. The horizontal communication is amongst different research groups in the field. The longitudinal communication is between different stages of model developing by the same individuals. Diagrams serve in the constant defining and redefining of boundary of research arenas through bringing about new problems and activating future research." @default.
- W2473607902 created "2016-07-22" @default.
- W2473607902 creator A5028089507 @default.
- W2473607902 date "2016-04-28" @default.
- W2473607902 modified "2023-09-26" @default.
- W2473607902 title "Synthesising heterogeneity: trends of visuality in biological sciences circa 1970s - 2000s" @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1052718895 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1480098410 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1481804214 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1489530964 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1489838709 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1491459594 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1501238827 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1532194993 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1545424811 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1549914502 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1551580981 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1567384416 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1568184863 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1585300371 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1593921172 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1598335299 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1609959357 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1682391564 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1751549534 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1754192684 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1791834434 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1843461492 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1886337131 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1898133347 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1902144921 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1919423561 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1948560807 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1950332654 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1963876890 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1964007943 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1964037688 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1966230375 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1967534538 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1968174418 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1969331809 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1970669146 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1974744750 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1975460230 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1976186736 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1980414703 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1980805550 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1981034486 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1983843802 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1985520226 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1985681395 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1986826194 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1987564128 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1990098732 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1991170866 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1992068201 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1993178967 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1994683536 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1995467171 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1995842427 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1995895461 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1996544267 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1999179844 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1999262482 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W1999445587 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W2001443225 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W2002097809 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W2002993931 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W2003939380 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W2004329409 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W2004550343 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W2008620264 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W2011854836 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W2014944687 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W2015085080 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W2015640955 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W2016411107 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W2017836748 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W2019572526 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W2019788712 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W2020269306 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W2020462222 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W2022247016 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W2022761661 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W2024105041 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W2027501274 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W2027669146 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W2032279931 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W2034326857 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W2036044676 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W2037159578 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W2037463396 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W2039112170 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W2040155866 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W2040483531 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W2042345167 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W2042614301 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W2044117808 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W2045478141 @default.
- W2473607902 cites W2046666752 @default.