Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2498332365> ?p ?o ?g. }
- W2498332365 abstract "Quintilian’s Theory of Certainty and Its Afterlife in Early Modern Italy Charles J. McNamara This dissertation explores how antiquity and some of its early modern admirers understand the notion of certainty, especially as it is theorized in Quintilian’s Institutio Oratoria, a first-century educational manual for the aspiring orator that defines certainty in terms of consensus. As part of a larger discussion of argumentative strategies, Quintilian turns to the “nature of all arguments,” which he defines as “reasoning which lends credence to what is doubtful by means of what is certain” (ratio per ea quae certa sunt fidem dubiis adferens: quae natura est omnium argumentorum, V.10.8). These certainties, he later specifies, include not matters of scientific demonstration or objective fact, but the agreements of various communities: the laws of cities, local customs, and other forms of consensus. As the foundation of persuasive rhetoric, these consensus-based certainties situate argumentation as the practice of crafting agreements rather than demonstrating necessary conclusions. Taking as its point of departure Quintilian’s novel understanding of certainty, this study looks to some of Quintilian’s intellectual forebears as well as his later readers to show how his work is both a nexus of earlier intellectual developments as well as an important inspiration for later accounts of certainty, even into the early modern period. After illustrating in the first chapters of this dissertation how Quintilian’s manual incorporates elements from Aristotelian notions of dialectic and rhetoric as well as from Ciceronian skeptical approaches to epistemology, I show how Quintilian’s curriculum for the orator shapes the thought of Italian humanists, especially that of Lorenzo Valla (1406– 1457), a reformer of scholastic logic and dialectic, and Giambattista Vico (1668–1744), an influential Neapolitan jurist. Adopting Quintilian’s rendering of certainty as a matter of agreements and conventions, these later authors elaborate their own novel approaches to various fields—including law, language, and logic—through this ancient understanding of certum. Contrary to modern notions of certainty as objective or scientific fact, Quintilian’s humanist readers continue to root this concept in consensus, both within the courtroom and without." @default.
- W2498332365 created "2016-08-23" @default.
- W2498332365 creator A5055712668 @default.
- W2498332365 date "2016-01-01" @default.
- W2498332365 modified "2023-09-26" @default.
- W2498332365 title "Quintilian's Theory of Certainty and Its Afterlife in Early Modern Italy" @default.
- W2498332365 cites W1480995697 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W1493231848 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W1499621117 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W1512407315 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W1515515109 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W1516264150 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W1542944553 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W1559281245 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W1569243919 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W1598962393 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W1804136744 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W1964761924 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W1969355092 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W1972152503 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W1977326431 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W1977515325 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W1978543790 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W1986452125 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W1989741860 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W1999991797 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W200935431 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W2011738557 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W2026320825 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W2039917470 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W2063328607 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W2068552971 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W2072190206 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W2080510885 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W2080841287 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W2081424656 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W2083264381 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W2085110941 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W2093837890 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W2108072238 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W2108264874 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W2161027534 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W2242986499 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W2244016001 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W2246000514 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W2248952618 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W2251843422 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W2312860112 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W2317219854 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W2332571608 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W2335456833 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W2337510739 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W2342709255 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W2480581590 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W2486576541 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W2498799467 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W2504879392 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W2598711671 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W2602935032 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W2603166797 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W2605189604 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W2612675639 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W2796132680 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W2798041461 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W2799280642 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W2803097379 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W2890647663 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W3167899460 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W413465849 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W571274355 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W580834775 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W611328416 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W617310323 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W628834525 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W628857333 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W630755863 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W631704630 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W636148949 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W656001566 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W658702534 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W2040492647 @default.
- W2498332365 cites W3013154594 @default.
- W2498332365 doi "https://doi.org/10.7916/d8kp8293" @default.
- W2498332365 hasPublicationYear "2016" @default.
- W2498332365 type Work @default.
- W2498332365 sameAs 2498332365 @default.
- W2498332365 citedByCount "0" @default.
- W2498332365 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
- W2498332365 hasAuthorship W2498332365A5055712668 @default.
- W2498332365 hasConcept C111472728 @default.
- W2498332365 hasConcept C13184196 @default.
- W2498332365 hasConcept C1370556 @default.
- W2498332365 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
- W2498332365 hasConcept C18296254 @default.
- W2498332365 hasConcept C2781306805 @default.
- W2498332365 hasConcept C41895202 @default.
- W2498332365 hasConcept C538439097 @default.
- W2498332365 hasConcept C65059942 @default.
- W2498332365 hasConcept C7493553 @default.
- W2498332365 hasConceptScore W2498332365C111472728 @default.