FRINK Linked Data Fragments server

Matches in SemOpenAlex for { <https://semopenalex.org/work/W2509536637> ?p ?o ?g. }

• W2509536637 endingPage "243" @default.
• W2509536637 startingPage "197" @default.
• W2509536637 abstract "THREE NOTIONS OF RESOLUTIO AND THE STRUCTURE OF REASONING IN AQUINAS 1 EILEEN c. SWEENEY Boston College Chestnut Hill, Massachusetts RESOLUTIO, better known by the English transliteration of its Greek counterpart, analysis, has been touted as the conceptual model for some of the most important ideas in the history of philosophy, including the history of the methodology and philosophy of science. 2 But while resolution /analysis may be important in the histories of philosophy and science, its own history is, to say the least, confused. A Renaissance commentator, Jeremias Triverius gives some sense of this when, after giving a list of four methods of dialectic (division , definition, demonstration, and resolution) ,3 he writes, 1 I have used the following abbreviations for works by Thomas Aquinas. All translations of Aquinas are my own. Commentum in Quatuor Libros Sententiarum (ed. Busa): In Sent; Compendium Theologiae (ed. Busa): Comp Theo!; E:rpositio Super Librum Boethii De Trinitate (ed. Decker): Exp de Trin; In Aristotelis Libros Posterium Analyticorum (ed. Marietti) : In Anal Post; In Duodecem Libros Metaphysicorum Aristotelis E:rpositio (ed. Marietti): In Meta; In Librum Beati Dionysii De Divinis Nominibus E:rpositio (ed. Marietti): In Div Nom; Sententia Libri Ethicorum Aristotelis ad Nichomachum: In Ethic; Sententia Libri Politicormn Aristotelis (ed. Leonine): In Pol; De Substantiis Separatis (ed. Busa): De Sub Sep; Summa Contra Gentiles (ed. Leonine): SCG; Summa Theologiae (ed. Leonine): ST; Questiones Disputatae de Veritate: QDV. 2 Jaakko Hintikka and Unto Remes, The Method of Analysis (Boston: D. Reidel, 1974), p. 1. s These four methods of dialectic are also given by a number of ancient commentators, for example, Ammonius (In Porphyrii Isagogen, in Commentaria in Aristotelem Graeca [hereafter, CAG], ed. Maximilian Wallies [Berlin , 1891], vol. IV, pt. 6, p. 34, 11. 19-20) and a later commentator, David (Davidis Prolegomena et in Porphyrii Isagogen Commentarium, CAG, ed. Adolf Busse [Berlin, 1904], vol. 18, p. 88, 11. 6-10). 197 198 EILEEN C. SWEENEY Now anyone who has some knowledge of dialectical matters knows what Definition, Division, and Demonstration are. There is no general agreement, however, so far as I can see, on Resolution. Some identify it with Division. Others regard it as contrary [to Divi- • ] 4 S!On , ••• Triverius, like many modern commentators, adds to, rather than sorts out, the confusion, continuing, And since each one is entitled to his opinion, I am now maintaining that Resolution is contrary to Demonstration.... 5 Many centuries before Triverius we find a similar ambiguity in Greek commentators on Aristotle , who outline several types of analysis. Unlike Triverius, however, most seem untroubled by the multiple types; Ammonius and David, without puzzlement, explain carefully that analysis is the opposite of each of the other three methods.6 The lack of 4 Jeremias Triverius, In texnhn [sic] Galeni clarissimi commentarii (Lyon, 1547), p. 14; cited and translated in Nea! Gilbert, Renaissance Concepts of Method (New York: Columbia University Press, 1960), p. 106. Galen's opening remarks of the Ars medica, giving three methods of teaching (analysis, synthesis, and definition) is a common locus for the discussion of resolution/ analysis in the Middle Ages and Renaissance. Galen's contribution, at least for Aquinas, seems to have been completely mediated by Medieval Arabic commentators. Galen's own discussions are either incomplete, as in the opening passage to the Ars medica (in Claudii Galeni Opera Omnia, ed. C. G. Kiihn, [Repr. Hildesheim: Georg Olms, 1965], vol. I, pp. 305-306), which merely mentions the word, or are unclear accounts of analysis (Cf. Galen's discussion of analysis in De Peccatorum, in Opera Omnia, vol. 5, ch. 5, pp. 80-81). On two of the Arabic commentaries' descriptions of analysis to accompany medieval translations of Galen, see below, nn. 80 & 83. On Galen's supposed contribution to the notion of resolution and method in the development of experimental science, see A. C. Crombie, Robert Grosseteste and the Origins of Experimental Science (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1953), especially pp. 7680 , and Gilbert, Renaissance Method, pp, 13-27, 44-46. 5 Triverius, In texnhn, p. 14; Gilbert, p. 106. 6 For analysis as the opposite of division, definition, and demonstration, see Ammonius, In Aristotelis Analyticorum Priorum Librum I Commentarium, CAG, ed. Maximilian Wallies, (Berlin, 1891..." @default.
• W2509536637 created "2016-09-16" @default.
• W2509536637 creator A5059360455 @default.
• W2509536637 date "1994-01-01" @default.
• W2509536637 modified "2023-09-26" @default.
• W2509536637 title "Three Notions of Resolutio and the Structure of Reasoning in Aquinas" @default.
• W2509536637 cites W1527052990 @default.
• W2509536637 cites W1559503622 @default.
• W2509536637 cites W1572931619 @default.
• W2509536637 cites W1615249722 @default.
• W2509536637 cites W1964230244 @default.
• W2509536637 cites W1966110718 @default.
• W2509536637 cites W1974484221 @default.
• W2509536637 cites W1984391567 @default.
• W2509536637 cites W2023625485 @default.
• W2509536637 cites W2030951107 @default.
• W2509536637 cites W2044904169 @default.
• W2509536637 cites W2051690462 @default.
• W2509536637 cites W2055870787 @default.
• W2509536637 cites W2077680803 @default.
• W2509536637 cites W2082846886 @default.
• W2509536637 cites W2122516211 @default.
• W2509536637 cites W2134224853 @default.
• W2509536637 cites W2211906990 @default.
• W2509536637 cites W2294860407 @default.
• W2509536637 cites W2316377657 @default.
• W2509536637 cites W2332949152 @default.
• W2509536637 cites W2334215557 @default.
• W2509536637 cites W3004695419 @default.
• W2509536637 cites W3151480898 @default.
• W2509536637 cites W590316821 @default.
• W2509536637 cites W612807433 @default.
• W2509536637 cites W617385311 @default.
• W2509536637 cites W872140214 @default.
• W2509536637 cites W2343257857 @default.
• W2509536637 doi "https://doi.org/10.1353/tho.1994.0027" @default.
• W2509536637 hasPublicationYear "1994" @default.
• W2509536637 type Work @default.
• W2509536637 sameAs 2509536637 @default.
• W2509536637 citedByCount "31" @default.
• W2509536637 countsByYear W25095366372013 @default.
• W2509536637 countsByYear W25095366372014 @default.
• W2509536637 crossrefType "journal-article" @default.
• W2509536637 hasAuthorship W2509536637A5059360455 @default.
• W2509536637 hasConcept C111472728 @default.
• W2509536637 hasConcept C13184196 @default.
• W2509536637 hasConcept C138885662 @default.
• W2509536637 hasConcept C27206212 @default.
• W2509536637 hasConcept C2778473407 @default.
• W2509536637 hasConcept C41895202 @default.
• W2509536637 hasConcept C74916050 @default.
• W2509536637 hasConcept C95457728 @default.
• W2509536637 hasConceptScore W2509536637C111472728 @default.
• W2509536637 hasConceptScore W2509536637C13184196 @default.
• W2509536637 hasConceptScore W2509536637C138885662 @default.
• W2509536637 hasConceptScore W2509536637C27206212 @default.
• W2509536637 hasConceptScore W2509536637C2778473407 @default.
• W2509536637 hasConceptScore W2509536637C41895202 @default.
• W2509536637 hasConceptScore W2509536637C74916050 @default.
• W2509536637 hasConceptScore W2509536637C95457728 @default.
• W2509536637 hasIssue "2" @default.
• W2509536637 hasLocation W25095366371 @default.
• W2509536637 hasOpenAccess W2509536637 @default.
• W2509536637 hasPrimaryLocation W25095366371 @default.
• W2509536637 hasRelatedWork W148813601 @default.
• W2509536637 hasRelatedWork W1529648096 @default.
• W2509536637 hasRelatedWork W2337382594 @default.
• W2509536637 hasRelatedWork W2350365405 @default.
• W2509536637 hasRelatedWork W2799332305 @default.
• W2509536637 hasRelatedWork W2900800520 @default.
• W2509536637 hasRelatedWork W2999138942 @default.
• W2509536637 hasRelatedWork W3023572764 @default.
• W2509536637 hasRelatedWork W3112806567 @default.
• W2509536637 hasRelatedWork W2462667148 @default.
• W2509536637 hasVolume "58" @default.
• W2509536637 isParatext "false" @default.
• W2509536637 isRetracted "false" @default.
• W2509536637 magId "2509536637" @default.
• W2509536637 workType "article" @default.